Musical Fidelity X-Pre Preamp Reviewed
- By: Ken Kessler
- - Reviewer's System
- Category:
- Audio Reviews, Equipment Reviews, Stereo Amplifier Reviews (Classic), Stereo Preamplifier Reviews (Classic)
- Resources & Links:
- Stereo Amplifiers ,
- Stereo Preamplifiers
- January 4, 2009
So aggravatingly prolific is Musical Fidelity that it's hard to know what has and hasn't been reviewed. The excuse for such a flood of products? Anthony Michaelson argues that it's the only way to keep everyone watching his brand, to avoid ennui, to ensure that his company will survive the bleakest sales period in audio history. And his latest mid-field offerings are so effin' good that he's kicking his opponents while their down.
Let's dispense with something right away. The latest MF products, like most other affordable, so-called UK products, are made off-shore. But time for a reality check. First of all, companies in the West not making cost-no-object products have to do it if they're to survive, unlike makers of high-end audio, watches, exotic cars or other goods where the customers DEMAND manufacture in the company's country of origin. Secondly, gone are the days when Taiwan, China, Korea and other Asian countries produced shoddy products. There, I've said it and it sounds traitorous, but this is the 21st Century.
So it's no wonder that Musical Fidelity has, in the X-PREv3 pre-amplifier and the matching X-P200 stereo power amplifier, a couple of seriously covetable products with prices of, respectively, only £799 and £899. Fit, feel, function and finish are impeccable. And the sound is so good that the pair can see off gear with price including an added zero.
You gotta love the X-PREv3, a fully remote-controllable gem with a motorised volume control, gorgeous tiny blue LEDs shining at you, three line inputs, tape and main outputs and an mm phono stage. And that huge volume control is simply irresistible. One turn, and you'll be hooked, it's that smooth. You cannot fault the X-PREv3 however you examine it. Moreover, you will sigh with relief at its dimensions of only 8.6x3.9x14.7in (WHD). It was designed with vast overload margins, low feedback, ultra-quiet operation and superb stereo separation, the later effected by dual mono circuitry including separate power supplies for each stage and isolation of each gain block.
Housed in the same chassis is the X-P200 rated at 120W/ch, but it's bridgeable into mono for 260W. This is accomplished by wiring a single speaker to the two positive terminals and switching the amp to bridged mode through front panel buttons. You can also bi-amplify with the X-P200 with throughput circuitry; the back of the X-P200 has a single set of outputs in addition to the two pairs of inputs.
The X-P200 is 'a direct descendant of and evolution from the original Nu-Vista M3,' one of the finest amplifiers of recent times. And it's no mere boast: as one who used every Nu-, Tri- or Mu-Vista at some point, I can attest to the family resemblance. Despite the dearth of glassware, this is one tube-y sounding amplifier.
I used the two pieces with the matching X-RAYv3 CD player, the matching X-series accessories (see below), the SME 30/2 turntable/Series V arm and Decca Super Gold cartridge, and speakers including LS3/5A, Quad ESL 57 and 63, Sonus Faber Guarneri and Wilson WATT Puppy 7. Yes: Wilsons at £22,000. And not one pair hassled the X-P200. In fact, I never got the volume control past the ¾ mark.
While I immediately discovered that the line stages were superb - the X-RAYv3 showed them to be as quiet and widely dynamic as promised - I was not prepared for the sheer goodness of the phono stage. Nowadays, any phono stage is a gift as most pre-amps come in line level form. But this was no compromise beyond the lack of mc step-up capability. It suited the Decca perfectly, matching its speed, stage width and depth, and bass control and extension. This was mirrored by the line stages, so the X-PREv3 easily dealt with big band crescendos from Jackie Gleason LPs, subtle acoustic guitar work from Antonio Forcione CDs and LPs, close harmonies by the Judds on CD, mono Judy Garland. It rose to the occasion every time - even complementing the McIntosh MC2102 all-valve power amplifier.
As much as I adore the X-PREv3, it was the X-P200 which impressed me even more, if for no other reasons than its unflappability and brute force. Hey, I abused this amplifier, even when I mono'ed two of them to cope with Guarneris and the WATT Puppy 7s. They never even grew warm, after six-hour-long sessions. The transient attack is breathtaking, the bass deep, rounded and controlled without too much damping, the soundstage is massive. I dug out Kodo drummers, some vinyl blockbusters like the Billy May Orchestra on Capitol, hard rock via Green Day - and I played it offensively loud. The X-P200s never let me down.
So what you have here is the heart of a system offering embarrassing good value, with the added bonus of classy looks. (I'm a sucker for the matt silvery finish MF has adopted.) And you'll find yourself listening for hours longer than you might deem normal. But that's only the start of it.
The Upgrade Path
What struck me as so appealing about the ¬¬¬'Xv3' series is the upgrade path. As one who fell in love early on with the original, cylindrical X series, I found the new edition a wonderful return to the earlier range's wit, novelty value, practicality, anti-obsolescence and user friendly-ness. Even a complete Xv3 series system in its ultimate form - pre-amp, CD player, TWO power amps and all five accessories - will occupy minimal space.
But how to go about upgrading to that all-in level is real 'pub argument' stuff. Three of the five accessories are purchased solely on a need-to-use basis, so that's entirely moot, while the fourth and fifth - the range's outboard DAC and phono stage - are true upgrades of existing elements rather than add-on facilities. Here's the list of options, housed in the smaller 7.1x3.5x8.2in (WHD) boxes:
The X-LPv3 (£249) is obviously only necessary for vinyl users (shame on you if you're not amongst them) who demand more than the X-PREv3's basic mm capability. And it's an absolute cracker of a phono stage - versatile, affordable and great sounding - so it is a true upgrade as well as an add-on. However, the built-in stage is so good, that the X-LPv3 can wait. The X-CANSv3 (£249) are aimed solely at one sort of user, the headphone aficionado, so this is something you either need or you don't. Again, the device is a bargain, the best I've used below the AudioValve headphone amp. As for the X-10 v3 valve buffer (£299), well, that's more of a religious consideration than a purchase, and I am not about to sway you with words: listen to it, and seen if you can live without it. Odds are, probably not.
That leaves us with two of the small-chassis add-ons to consider. And, clearly, the X-PSUv3 (£249) is a must if you have more than one of the X modules because it powers all four of them, saving you three sockets by ridding you of the need for the supplied 'wall wart' mains adaptors. Trust me, even if you only use one of the four - X-LPv3, X-CANS v3, X-10v3 or X-DACv3 - you will be rewarded with precisely the sonic gains you'd expect of a power supply upgrade. Then again, you don't buy the X-PSUv3 if you don't already have one of the other boxes. So this leaves the other small-chassis unit, the latterly-named X-DACv3, that leads to the aforementioned pub brawl.
Where's the fracas? It's between buying the X-DACv3 and...a second X-P200. I called Musical Fidelity's Anthony Michaelson and he was adamant that, 'provided this is not an issue about cost - after all, an X-DACv3 costs £400 less than a second X-P200 - then I'm convinced that the sonic rewards are far greater running a pair of X-P200s.' He goes on to explain that, 'I firmly believe that you cannot approach realistic sound reproduction with less than a real 200W/channel.' And it's not worth arguing with him about that, regardless of the sensitivity of your speakers, etc, etc.
On the other hand, Anthony is convinced that the X-DAC v3 is the best DAC on the planet. And you do get a helluva lot for the money, a compact, great-sounding device that AM believes to be so close to the sound of the now-collectible Tr-Vista 21 DAC that he's even amazed himself. It's fitted with the latest Burr-Brown chips (DSD1792 and SRC4192/3), its specs actually improve on those of its dearer predecessors, and an A/B of the X-RAYv3 on its own direct versus the X-RAYv3 via X-DACv3 is more than illuminating: it's shocking. The X-DACv3 is more analogue-like, more dynamic, sweeter at the top, faster - it turns the X-RAYv3 into the sonic equivalent of a £2500 CD player. For a total price of £1398.
What we have in the new X range is an excruciatingly 'more-ish' pile of audio goodies. Every person who's seen them in my room marvelled at the looks, the finish, the feel of the controls. Even visitors in no need of new additions to their systems were musing about adding, say, the headphone unit just to have one of these classy little boxes on the shelf. So look at the purchase of X-RAYv3, X-PREv3 and a single X-P200 not as system in and of itself, but as an almost insidious way to pre-spend your audio allocation for the next couple of years, up to a grand total (with two X-P200s) of £5041. Damn, that Michaelson's clever...
Keywords
audiophile preamp, audiophile power amp, Musical Fidelity preamp and amp reviewed
- Musical Fidelity X-Pre Preamp ...
- Air Tight ATC-1 Preamp and ATM-...
- Audio Research LS16 Preamp Revi...
- Audio Research LS2 Line Stage P...
- Audio Research LS25 Preamp Revi...
- Audio Research LS8 Preamp Revie...
- Audio Research PH5 Phono Preamp...
- Audio Research SP16 Tube Preamp...
- Beard BB 30-60 Integrated Amp R...
- Cadence PRE2 Preamp and MA2 Pow...
- Cello Audio Palette, Performanc...
- Classe DR-5 Preamp and DR-5 Pow...
- Classe Thirty Preamp and the Se...
- Conuterpoint SA-1000 Preamp and...
- Counterpoint Natural Progressio...
- Croft Chameleon Integrated Amp ...
- Croft Vitale Preamp Reviewed...
- Da Vinci Typhoon Preamp Reviewe...
- EAR-Yoshino Stereo Preamp Revie...
- Graaf 13.5B II Preamp Review...
- Gryphon Audiophile Preamp Revie...
- Gryphon Limited Edition Preamp ...
- Jadis JPS8 Preamp and JA50 Powe...
- Krell KAV-250a and KAV-250p Rev...
- Krell MD-20 CD Transport, Krell...
- Marantz Model 7 Reviewed...
- Marantz PM-17 Preamp Reviewed...
- Marantz SC-7S1 Preamp and MA-9S...
- Metaxas Solitaire Power Amp and...
- Music & Sound's DCC-1 Digital C...
- Musical Fidelity Nu-Vista 300 P...
- Musical Fidelity Nu-Vista Pream...
- Musical Fidelity kW750 Preamp R...
- Nagra PL-L Preamp and PMA Mono ...
- Panasonic DVD-RV32 DVD Player R...
- Quad 33 Preamp and 303 Amp Revi...
- Quad II Reissue Preamp Reviewed...
- Rothwell Passive Preamp Reviewe...
- Sinfonia Preamp and Amp Reviewe...
- Sugden Masterclass Preamp and M...
- Unison Research Mystery One Pre...
- darTZeel NHB-18NS Preamplifier ...
Featured Audio-Video News
Experiencing Your Dream Home Theater While On Vacation -
It isn't any news that the economy is in the dumps. Morphing your living room, garage or basement into the...
Latest Stereo Preamplifier Reviews (Classic)
Quad II Reissue Preamp Reviewed -
A feature worthy of our 40th Anniversary issue. A once-in-a-career opportunity. That's what Editor Harris wanted for this issue, something so memorable that it would mark the occasion in style. Something to have every other magazine editor on the planet... Click for more...
Unison Research Mystery One Preamp Reviewed -
It probably took a bit longer to grow the wood which forms the Mystery One's case. All I know is that nearly a year has passed since I first took delivery of the prototype, and enough detail changes occurred between... Click for more...
Marantz Model 7 Reviewed -
Twist my arm. Go on. me to review a couple of products I've been dreaming about owning for years. What's that? If I've actually been waiting for 'years', did I suddenly find some mint originals? Not quite: Marantz took it... Click for more...
Krell KAV-250a and KAV-250p Reviewed -
What signals are you receiving from Krell? What do you make of the turnaround that has produced so much prime entry-level gear? Let's not be too glib about this, for even the Krell components we're about to explore sell for... Click for more...
Beard BB 30-60 Integrated Amp Reviewed -
Ever less than aggressive, Bill Beard has been quietly - if you'll forgive the term - manufacturing all-tube amplifiers for export these past few years. Those of us who see on occasion magazines from foreign countries have noticed ads for... Click for more...
Audio Research LS25 Preamp Reviewed -
Down-scaling - as opposed to dumbing down - has a patchy record in the annals of luxury goods. The VW/Porsche 914 didn't satisfy 911 wannabees, few would-be Leica M-Series owners cherished the economical CL and you'd have to hypnotise... Click for more...
Musical Fidelity Nu-Vista Preamp Reviewed -
Anthony Michaelson knows how to push the right buttons. All he had to say was the word 'nuvistor', and every tube crazy worth his weight in anode plates was clamouring for a listen. After all, wasn't the nuvistor the last-ever,... Click for more...
Marantz PM-17 Preamp Reviewed -
Having established itself as THE brand for affordable audiophile CD players, Marantz is going out of its way to prevent what's known as 'cherry-picking'. Cherry-picking happens when a brand has one outrageously successful product, but the rest of the range... Click for more...
Audio Research LS8 Preamp Reviewed -
All-tubed, classically ARC-styled and featuring a few touches which have filtered down from the dearer models, the LS8 joins the (thankfully) ever-lengthening list of entry-level high-end goodies...just in case you were afraid the Ref 1 pre-amp and Ref 600 monoblocks... Click for more...
Graaf 13.5B II Preamp Review -
Eagle-eyed readers blessed with -grade memories know that I've used GRAAF's flagship pre-amp off and on since reviewing it five years ago. The sonic performance of the GM13.5B made it one of my references for a tube pre-amp with balanced... Click for more...
Latest Stereo Preamplifier Reviews (Classic)
Quad II Reissue Preamp Reviewed -
A feature worthy of our 40th Anniversary issue. A once-in-a-career opportunity. That's what Editor Harris wanted for this issue, something so memorable that it would mark the occasion in style. Something to have every other magazine editor on the planet... Click for more...
Unison Research Mystery One Preamp Reviewed -
It probably took a bit longer to grow the wood which forms the Mystery One's case. All I know is that nearly a year has passed since I first took delivery of the prototype, and enough detail changes occurred between... Click for more...
Marantz Model 7 Reviewed -
Twist my arm. Go on. me to review a couple of products I've been dreaming about owning for years. What's that? If I've actually been waiting for 'years', did I suddenly find some mint originals? Not quite: Marantz took it... Click for more...
Krell KAV-250a and KAV-250p Reviewed -
What signals are you receiving from Krell? What do you make of the turnaround that has produced so much prime entry-level gear? Let's not be too glib about this, for even the Krell components we're about to explore sell for... Click for more...
Beard BB 30-60 Integrated Amp Reviewed -
Ever less than aggressive, Bill Beard has been quietly - if you'll forgive the term - manufacturing all-tube amplifiers for export these past few years. Those of us who see on occasion magazines from foreign countries have noticed ads for... Click for more...
Audio Research LS25 Preamp Reviewed -
Down-scaling - as opposed to dumbing down - has a patchy record in the annals of luxury goods. The VW/Porsche 914 didn't satisfy 911 wannabees, few would-be Leica M-Series owners cherished the economical CL and you'd have to hypnotise... Click for more...
Musical Fidelity Nu-Vista Preamp Reviewed -
Anthony Michaelson knows how to push the right buttons. All he had to say was the word 'nuvistor', and every tube crazy worth his weight in anode plates was clamouring for a listen. After all, wasn't the nuvistor the last-ever,... Click for more...
Marantz PM-17 Preamp Reviewed -
Having established itself as THE brand for affordable audiophile CD players, Marantz is going out of its way to prevent what's known as 'cherry-picking'. Cherry-picking happens when a brand has one outrageously successful product, but the rest of the range... Click for more...
Audio Research LS8 Preamp Reviewed -
All-tubed, classically ARC-styled and featuring a few touches which have filtered down from the dearer models, the LS8 joins the (thankfully) ever-lengthening list of entry-level high-end goodies...just in case you were afraid the Ref 1 pre-amp and Ref 600 monoblocks... Click for more...
Graaf 13.5B II Preamp Review -
Eagle-eyed readers blessed with -grade memories know that I've used GRAAF's flagship pre-amp off and on since reviewing it five years ago. The sonic performance of the GM13.5B made it one of my references for a tube pre-amp with balanced... Click for more...
Latest Equipment Reviews
Oppo BDP-83 Special Edition Universal Player Reviewed -
Oppo Digital's first Blu-ray player the BDP-83 entered the market in mid 2009 to numerous accolades. A mere half year later, Oppo Digital, not satisfied with the untapped performance potential of the player, released the BDP-83 Special Edition reviewed here.... Click for more...
Parker Audio 95MK II Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Chances are you've never heard of or seen a pair of Parker Audio 95MK II loudspeakers. Because of that fact, you're probably thinking they're some sort of uber-esoteric, high-end, ultra-expensive loudspeakers from some designer's garage in Munich. Well, you'd be... Click for more...
Bel Canto e. One S300iu Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Integrated amplifiers have always been an effective and affordable way to get into two-channel audio. However, in recent years, integrated amplifiers have come into their own, offering performance and simplicity that even high-end separate systems have trouble matching. Case in... Click for more...
Bel Canto e.One S300 Power Amplifier Reviewed -
Stereo amplifiers have been a staple since music went from single speakers to two-way back in the day. Over the years, we've seen stereo amplifiers go from simple, manageable black boxes to over-the-top, larger-than-thou space heaters for the home and... Click for more...
OmniMount Link Series A/V Stands Reviewed -
As its name suggests, OmniMount's Link Series is a modular line of A/V stands that you can mix and match to craft the exact entertainment solution you need. You can also add on as your system grows. The Link Series,... Click for more...
Paradigm Reference Studio 20 v.5 Bookshelf Speaker Reviewed -
I've been a fan of Paradigm for years, owning and enjoying seemingly every speaker in their product line from the awesome and affordable Atoms to their flagship Signature S8s. Over the years there have been two Paradigm speaker designs that... Click for more...
Bel Canto REF 1000M Mono Amplifier Reviewed -
When one thinks of a 500-Watt mono amplifier you probably picture a large, heat sink clad hunk of steel that weighs more than the car you drove it home in and probably costs more too. What if I told you... Click for more...
OmniMount VideoBasics TV Mounts Reviewed -
You've spent the extra money to buy an ultra-thin HDTV. The last thing you want to do is hinder the minimalist look by mating the TV with a bulky wall-mount. OmniMount designed the VideoBasics line of flat-panel TV mounts with... Click for more...
OmniMount OmniLite TV Mounts Reviewed -
Wait, an environmentally friendly TV mount? Yes, it's true. OmniMount's OmniLite Series of fixed, tilt, and cantilever mounts is touted as the company's first eco-friendly line of flat-panel TV mounts. So what exactly makes an eco-friendly mount? In this case,... Click for more...
Parasound Halo JC 2 Preamplifier Reviewed -
If you're an audiophile, you almost certainly know of the Parasound company, a manufacturer of high-end audio/video electronics (and other products) that are of extremely high quality, yet are not stratospherically priced. Halo is Parasound's premium line of components. (The... Click for more...





Comment on this article
0Post a Comment