• AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Wilson Audio Alexandria Loudspeakers Reviewed


  • January 4, 2009

| Print Page | Adjust Font Size:

Free Home Theater Review Weekly Newsletter.

Enter your e-mail below to get Home Theater Review's weekly newsletter with the latest equipment reviews and home theater news sent directly to your inbox.


*Required

Few audio designers are so grand that a meeting with them suffers an ambience of 'an audience with'. Usually, the ones who do inspire that reaction are conceited tossers whose ego rather than achievement creates the impression of being in the presence of royalty. Dave Wilson comes from the other end of the scale: truly a boffin, a propeller-headed, crazed enthusiast whose very enthusiasm is as infectious as a smile from a three-year-old.

He's a veritable Duracell Bunny of an audiophile: wind him up and he'll talk about torsional strength and impedance curves and adhesives and how the specification of an F-15 fighter relates to his loudspeakers. And he'll do it with a delicious mix of humility and authority such as I've witnessed only from the likes of Peter Walker and Alastair Robertson-Aikman. And yet, with all three, meeting them has an air of 'audience' not because they demand it, but because know in your gut that they're worthy of your respect.

I tell you this because I've known Dave Wilson for nearly 20 years, been to his home, his factory, used his products, eaten his M&Ms at CES. And still I'm always slightly awed that he would waste his time with a subjective reviewer who thinks that a 'slide rule' has something to do with the legality of a child's ride at the playground. He puts on neither airs nor graces, grins like a kid when faced with a cool new toy and is as happy to eat a Pizza Hut 'Filled Crust' pizza as the finest dim sum. And now, with a company that would fit in B&W's or Bose's staff canteen, he's produced what just may be the greatest loudspeaker on the planet. Bar none. And I mean a production speaker, not a demented one-off that appears at a hi-fi show, never to be seen (nor heard) again.

Like Peter Walker, who spent 18 years before he was happy with the ESL-63, Wilson has taken his time - nearly a decade - with the Alexandria, or X-2. It had to do two things...with neither task to be taken lightly. The first is to replace the WAMM, the venerable flagship that Wilson saw through, what? Seven incarnations? Impractical, expensive, dependent on hard-to-find ingredients, requiring DW to set them up himself regardless of the location - the WAMM has been officially out of production for a few years, and Wilson was aware of the gaping hole this created.

Even though the WAMM was never a 'production' speaker, being entirely made to order, it provided well-heeled audiophiles with something unlikely to be found in their mates' homes. Alas, Wilson made the task of creating a WAMM replacement that much more difficult, because, for the past nine years, the just-below-WAMM flagship has been the incredibly successful and highly-respected X-1 Grand SLAMM. Thus, the second task: coming in above an established near-masterpiece.

This exceptional design has been a reference product for most of its life, and is the wellspring from which most of the post-1994 Wilson products have derived their technology, DW firmly believing in the trickle-down approach. Most notable was the development of 'X' material, which found its way into every Wilson product, to one degree or another.

Wilson designs his cabinets using a range of high-density materials, including what looks like a type of ply made from layers of MDF (the so-called 'M' material). This is used in the speakers' carcasses, and was chosen over conventional MDF because it can be worked to much tighter tolerances, it provides superior hardness, uniform density and dimensional stability, and can be made to accept the high-gloss, automotive-grade paint finishes that are one of Wilson's signature details. Yes, it costs more and is harder to use, but it does 'what it says on the box', so to speak: create a superior cabinet. Go on: rap on the side of and then lift a Puppy. Then tell me that you believe that the majority of the panels are fashioned from a variant of MDF.

But it's the Wilson-developed 'X' material that the X-1 showcased, a high density phenolic material that DW describes as, '...the best, most non-resonant material we have ever encountered. It has almost no ringing at all, and does not alter the pitch or tonal character of music.' Not only is it heavy and expensive, it's a monster to work: each panel used in the X-2 takes eight hours to machine via CNC, which explains why Wilson can only make two pairs of X-2 per month, maybe ramping up to four.

As for the F-15 mentioned above? A slab of X-material will support a stack of 'em.

Additionally, the X-1 was the first installer-friendly implementation of Wilson's patented, trade-marked Group Delay technology. An evolutionary by-product of the WAMM's modular construction, Group Delay is a combination of proprietary crossover design, about which DW is close-lipped, and the ability to adjust all of the individual drivers in the time domain. In the X-1, each driver module - midrange and treble - is precisely positioned during the set-up procedure 'to create a seamless coherency throughout the frequency range', while optimising the sound for the primary listening position. To appreciate it another way, the 'tiltable' top section of the WATT Puppy, the WATT module itself, is the most basic application of Group Delay.

But back to the X-2. This speaker takes the Group Delay facility a stage further, with even greater flexibility, such that DW said, straight-faced, that he could make a pair of these leviathans work even in my 12x18ft room. Moreover, the added flexibility of the 'head' units means that the height can vary by degrees; that 72in specification is its nominal height. While the same materials are used in X-2 as in X-1, just about everything else has changed, as detailed in the sidebar, with every driver a new one bar the main tweeter.

Without going into detail, DW has been a victim of unscrupulous rivals in the past, so he's understandably cagey about certain aspects of the X-2's design. Just as photographs were forbidden at the Las Vegas showing of the prototype, so, too, will Dave not discuss crossover details until the X-2 has been around for a while. Even the aesthetic details, such as smaller gaps around the modules, and the 'slashes' in the sides, are topics about which Dave will not elucidate, at least, not beyond, 'Notice how the cabinet sides differ in thickness above and below the slashes?' Which caused me to ask, 'In there a sonic benefit?' Dave responded with nowt but an enigmatic smile.

To facilitate a review, I visited the Wilson home in Provo, Utah, where DW had set up a unique demonstration. Because the speakers wouldn't be shipping until July, it seems that any reviews will be undertaken at the Wilson home; it just isn't practical to send out review pairs at this stage. So why was I, through , blessed with the honour of the first review? I can only imagine it was because I had the initiative to seek out Wilson at CES and this was the reward for my enthusiasm.

Now, before any of you get 'het up' about me reviewing the speakers Chez Wilson, doubting worth or validity because it wasn't undertaken in my own room, please note the following ripostes. Firstly, I'd enjoyed a long and unforgettable session in the Wilson listening room once before, and found it to be as neutral a venue as one could imagine, right up there with the SME room. Thus, I believe that could walk into it cold, audition product they care to try, and leave with a justifiable opinion. Steve Harris, who visited Wilson Audio last year, concurred.

Secondly, the review system consisted entirely of components familiar to me: McIntosh MC2000 'Anniversary' power amplifier, Audio Research's Reference 2 Mk II pre-amplifier, the Audio Research CD-3 CD player, Transparent cables, a Basis Turntable with Air Tangent arm and Lyra Helikon cartridge. [Also auditioned briefly, due to possible concerns about headroom, were the Mark Levinson No. 33 mono amplifiers. Although they produced tighter bass, the sound was more forward than I prefer. Besides, DW had no reason to suspect that, unlike most reviewers, I prefer to listen at ear-bleeding levels, and the McIntosh was more than adequate even in his 40x30ft room.]

To assess the Alexandria, I supplied the review material, while DW made sure that every part of the chain was familiar to me. And I pretty much ran the session for four hours or so, to - no doubt - the great anguish of others (Sheryl Lee Wilson, John Giolas and Peter McGrath of Wilson Audio, and Deedra Allison of ) forced to listen to Tennessee Ernie Ford, Willie Nelson and Mickey Katz.

Before being let loose with my own CDs, Dave demonstrated the X-1 and X-2 side-by-side. It proved to be one of the most disconcerting experiences I have ever be subjected to as a reviewer. Using recordings from the Persuasions, Diana Krall and others, we listened to the X-1. It was sublime. I sat there wondering what on earth could the X-2 do that I wasn't already hearing. Using a switch box fashioned by Wilson, I A/B'd the two. To the shock of all present - the Wilson household is not where one uses salty language - I blurted out, after a mere three seconds, a loud 'Bloody hell!'

It was like this: I had been shocked into a situation familiar to all scribes who wish to maintain a sense of proportion, and I was let off the hook by one thing only: the price difference between X-1 and X-2 is on the order of approximately 45 percent. When that 45 percent is $40,000, the differential makes the speakers non-combatants in my book. But I must also add that one industry observer told me not to feel too much relief. He said, 'Don't kid yourself. The kind of people who can afford $85,000 for speakers can probably afford $125,000. We're not talking about normal people, who have to think twice about a $1250 purchase instead of $850.'

Fat help that was, then. Because the X-2 so clearly bettered the X-1 in so many ways, it could ONLY be the price that would cause one to choose the X-1, which stays in production to fill the huge gap between MAXX and X-2. Instantly, the X-2 revealed itself to be capable of less congestion in the upper midband, and it was more open overall. The bass was less aggressive, there was finer image specificity, and even a smoother left-to-right spread. The sound was more homogeneous, with better pin-point precision. And, more than anything, X-2 made the X-1 seem positively nasal in comparison.

All of which placed me in a quandary. Mere seconds before, I was sitting there marvelling at the X-1. With the flick of a switch, I was suddenly confronted with sound that bettered it . Which reminded me of my favourite hi-fi adage, coined when a certain school of idiot reviewer declared new 'world's bests' on a monthly basis: if something is wonderful on Monday, it's still wonderful on Wednesday, . So, by any measure, the X-1 is the same magnificent beast it's been since 1994. Only now there's something better.

So I scratched my head for a perfect analogy and came up with this one, alas automotive. Imagine the Porsche Boxster S, a car so capable, so loved, so respected that most car nuts wonder, 'Why spend more?' It handles like a dream, it's built by Germans, it looks great. It is worth every penny. Then, you get the keys to the 911 Turbo. Same badge. Same nose. Similar layout. Three times the price. In comparison, the Boxster's a dog. But in reality? The Boxster is still an astounding vehicle,

Anyway, for four hours, I raided my CD wallet. 'Assassin Of Love' acquired a majesty I'd never heard, with richer, more fluid bass and a sense of physical scale that provided a much larger playing field for the wondrous 3D effects within. Decay on all notes was more authentic, smoothly transitional without any overhang. And when bass transients hit, WHAM! They stopped with a finality I have never associated with such massive, non-servo'd woofers. The treble? It made me think of the X-2 as a WATT 7 on steroids. Industrial strength, disgraced-professional-athlete-on-the-lam steroids.

Willie Nelson, whose through-the-nose intonation illustrated the X-2's refinement over the X-1, regaled us with 'All Of Me' and other standards, opportunities to hear some fine guitar, pedal steel and piano. Uncharacteristic of Wilsons in general, given the quest for arch neutrality, was a warmth, a luscious, life-like 'woodiness' that spoke of real instruments. With Ella and Louis on vinyl, the vocal textures - hers like fine crystal, his like fine gravel - yielded one of J. Gordon Holt's in-the-room-realism frissons. Dino, Frank, Lou Rawls, Louis Prima - a continuing series of little shocks, plenty of those otherwise rare moments of being lulled into the illusion that the event was real, in front of you. But instead of one of these 'frissons' every month or so, it was a decade's worth in an afternoon. Even the mono seemed to take on width and depth.

So consider this: when I visited Wilson Audio in mid-May, the company had already sold, sight unseen and sound unheard, enough pairs to create an eight month waiting period. Retailers customers had placed orders solely on word-of-mouth, for few were those who got see - and I mean see, not even hear - the prototype behind closed doors in Las Vegas last January. And Deedra and I were the first people outside of Wilson Audio actually to listen to the X-2.

Thus we have a situation where at least 32 music lovers have, on faith alone, placed firm orders for a speaker costing around US $125,000 per pair. I'd like to tell them that their faith will be rewarded. Not necessarily in the afterlife, mind you, but certainly in the here and now.

Absolute Sounds 020 8971 3909


SIDEBAR: X-1 vs X-2
Without any frame of reference, i.e. the two speakers side-by-side, only the most fanatical of Wilson-spotters can tell a Grand SLAMM X-1 from an Alexandria X-2. And yet the only part they have in common is the main tweeter. Here, for easy reference, is a point by point list of the ways they differ.

SPECIFICATIONS X-2 Alexandria X-1 Grand SLAMM
Woofer loading: Ported, front-slotted; ceramic Ported, milled
phenolic resin aluminium, rear
open-back vent; not frequency-tuned
but impedance curve tuned mid-section
Bass drivers: 1x15.5in,1x13in Focal 1x15in, 1x12in Focal
Midrange: 2x7in Vifa (proprietary to Wilson) 2x6in Dynaudio
Tweeter: 1in inverted dome Focal (built by Wilson) same
Supertweeter: 1xScanspeak 2xHarman
Frequency response: 18-22.5kHz, -2 dB 19.5-22.5kHz, -3dB
Crossover points: NA (proprietary) NA (proprietary)
Impedance: 8 ohms same
Sensitivity: 95dB@1W same
Dimensions (HWD): 72 (variable)x17.5x26.75 72x16.5x25.25
Weight ea: 750lbs 600lb

Keywords

Wilson Audio Alexandria Loudspeakers Reviewed

Subscribe to the Newsletter
Subscribe to HomeTheaterReview.com's Weekly Newsletter to get the latest news, reviews and insight on the world of home theater, HDTV and audiophile equipment. Subscription is 100% FREE!
*Required
Email Marketing by VerticalResponse
subscribe to rss Subscribe with RSS
Follow home theater equipment reviews and daily news via our RSS feed.
Related Floor-Standing Speaker Reviews:
  • Comment on this article

    1
  • By greg

Wilson Audio has enjoyed a very enviable reputation in the AV industry. I did get to hear for the first time, the Watt Puppy 8`s at HE 2007. They sounded pretty good, but conditions were not the best. This cost no object X-2, along with the Maxx, I would like to demo for myself, so that I can finally hear, what all the fuss is about.

Post a Comment

Please answer the following question (required) before posting to help us prevent Spam.


Featured Audio-Video News

Experiencing Your Dream Home Theater While On Vacation

Experiencing Your Dream Home Theater While On Vacation -

It isn't any news that the economy is in the dumps. Morphing your living room, garage or basement into the...

Latest Floor-Standing Speaker Reviews

Parker Audio 95MK II Loudspeakers Reviewed -

Chances are you've never heard of or seen a pair of Parker Audio 95MK II loudspeakers. Because of that fact, you're probably thinking they're some sort of uber-esoteric, high-end, ultra-expensive loudspeakers from some designer's garage in Munich. Well, you'd be... Click for more...

Vienna Acoustics Beethoven Baby Grand Loudspeaker Reviewed -

The Beethoven Baby Grand from Vienna Acoustics sits just below the Beethoven Grand in the Grand lineup of loudspeakers. The Baby Grand starts at $3,995 a pair for Maple, Cherry and Piano Black finishes and jumps to $4,400 a pair... Click for more...

Vienna Acoustics Schonberg Loudspeaker Reviewed -

Vienna Acoustics makes some of the finest looking loudspeakers available today and the Schonberg Loudspeaker, reviewed here, is no exception. Retailing for $1,495 a pair, clad in either silver or piano black lacquer, the Schonberg's are a design tour de... Click for more...

Magnepan MG 3.6 Planar-Magnetic Loudspeaker Reviewed -

There are good speakers. There are great speakers. However, few speakers are able to surpass mere greatness and cement themselves as the stuff of legend. Unless you're talking about the Magnepan MG 3.6 of course, which I am, and yes,... Click for more...

Klipsch RF-52 Floorstanding Loudspeakers Reviewed -

Part of its diverse Reference Series of slightly upmarket loudspeakers featuring a staggering twenty models, the Klipsch RF-52 Floorstanding Loudspeaker sits second from the bottom in its six-model floorstanding class (RF-83, RF-63, RF-82, RF-62, RF-52, RF-10). The $658.00 per pair... Click for more...

Home Theater Review 2009 Best of Awards -

For the first time, Home Theater Review com's editors have picked a select list of the best gear from many of our AV equipment categories. The winners are picked subjectively by our staff. In today's economy, value matters - this... Click for more...

Canton Chrono SL 580 DC Loudspeaker Reviewed -

OK, I admit it. I am attracted to tall, slim and beautiful...loudspeakers. No surprise, then, that the new Canton Chrono SL 580 DC floorstanding loudspeaker recently caught my eye. (Actually, I've also gotten attached to petite and plus-size models--of loudspeakers,... Click for more...

Totem Acoustic Wind Design Loudspeaker Reviewed -

The Totem Acoustic Wind Design is a unique-looking floor-standing loudspeaker that combines a rakish appearance with extremely high-quality drivers and construction. At $13,995 per pair suggested retail, the made-in-Canada Totem Wind Design is clearly a high-end loudspeaker - and looks... Click for more...

Dynaudio Sapphire Loudspeaker Reviewed -

Danish loudspeaker company Dynaudio is one of the few manufacturers that is both a supplier of raw drivers, and a provider of complete, high-end loudspeakers for consumer and professional audio. (They also supply drivers and systems for automobiles.) As such,... Click for more...

Meridian DSP5200 Digital Active Loudspeaker -

Meridian is well known among audiophiles and music lovers as a company offering audio components and loudspeakers that aspire to the highest of high-end performance. The company created something of a sensation in the audiophile world with the introduction of... Click for more...

Latest Floor-Standing Speaker Reviews

Parker Audio 95MK II Loudspeakers Reviewed -

Chances are you've never heard of or seen a pair of Parker Audio 95MK II loudspeakers. Because of that fact, you're probably thinking they're some sort of uber-esoteric, high-end, ultra-expensive loudspeakers from some designer's garage in Munich. Well, you'd be... Click for more...

Vienna Acoustics Beethoven Baby Grand Loudspeaker Reviewed -

The Beethoven Baby Grand from Vienna Acoustics sits just below the Beethoven Grand in the Grand lineup of loudspeakers. The Baby Grand starts at $3,995 a pair for Maple, Cherry and Piano Black finishes and jumps to $4,400 a pair... Click for more...

Vienna Acoustics Schonberg Loudspeaker Reviewed -

Vienna Acoustics makes some of the finest looking loudspeakers available today and the Schonberg Loudspeaker, reviewed here, is no exception. Retailing for $1,495 a pair, clad in either silver or piano black lacquer, the Schonberg's are a design tour de... Click for more...

Magnepan MG 3.6 Planar-Magnetic Loudspeaker Reviewed -

There are good speakers. There are great speakers. However, few speakers are able to surpass mere greatness and cement themselves as the stuff of legend. Unless you're talking about the Magnepan MG 3.6 of course, which I am, and yes,... Click for more...

Klipsch RF-52 Floorstanding Loudspeakers Reviewed -

Part of its diverse Reference Series of slightly upmarket loudspeakers featuring a staggering twenty models, the Klipsch RF-52 Floorstanding Loudspeaker sits second from the bottom in its six-model floorstanding class (RF-83, RF-63, RF-82, RF-62, RF-52, RF-10). The $658.00 per pair... Click for more...

Home Theater Review 2009 Best of Awards -

For the first time, Home Theater Review com's editors have picked a select list of the best gear from many of our AV equipment categories. The winners are picked subjectively by our staff. In today's economy, value matters - this... Click for more...

Canton Chrono SL 580 DC Loudspeaker Reviewed -

OK, I admit it. I am attracted to tall, slim and beautiful...loudspeakers. No surprise, then, that the new Canton Chrono SL 580 DC floorstanding loudspeaker recently caught my eye. (Actually, I've also gotten attached to petite and plus-size models--of loudspeakers,... Click for more...

Totem Acoustic Wind Design Loudspeaker Reviewed -

The Totem Acoustic Wind Design is a unique-looking floor-standing loudspeaker that combines a rakish appearance with extremely high-quality drivers and construction. At $13,995 per pair suggested retail, the made-in-Canada Totem Wind Design is clearly a high-end loudspeaker - and looks... Click for more...

Dynaudio Sapphire Loudspeaker Reviewed -

Danish loudspeaker company Dynaudio is one of the few manufacturers that is both a supplier of raw drivers, and a provider of complete, high-end loudspeakers for consumer and professional audio. (They also supply drivers and systems for automobiles.) As such,... Click for more...

Meridian DSP5200 Digital Active Loudspeaker -

Meridian is well known among audiophiles and music lovers as a company offering audio components and loudspeakers that aspire to the highest of high-end performance. The company created something of a sensation in the audiophile world with the introduction of... Click for more...

All Floor-Standing Speaker Reviews

Latest Equipment Reviews

Mapleshade Time-Correcting Maple Bedrock Speaker Stands Reviewed -

For ages the adage with bookshelf and/or monitor speakers has always been getting the tweeter or tweeter/midrange as close to ear height will yield the best results. Of course proper placement in a room as well as in relation to... Click for more...

Mapleshade Samson V.1 Equipment Rack Reviewed -

Seemingly everyone makes an equipment rack of some form or another these days with varying degrees of success, however for best results you're better off going with a third party or specialty equipment rack. The problem with going with an... Click for more...

Oppo BDP-83 Special Edition Universal Player Reviewed -

Oppo Digital's first Blu-ray player the BDP-83 entered the market in mid 2009 to numerous accolades. A mere half year later, Oppo Digital, not satisfied with the untapped performance potential of the player, released the BDP-83 Special Edition reviewed here.... Click for more...

Parker Audio 95MK II Loudspeakers Reviewed -

Chances are you've never heard of or seen a pair of Parker Audio 95MK II loudspeakers. Because of that fact, you're probably thinking they're some sort of uber-esoteric, high-end, ultra-expensive loudspeakers from some designer's garage in Munich. Well, you'd be... Click for more...

Bel Canto e. One S300iu Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -

Integrated amplifiers have always been an effective and affordable way to get into two-channel audio. However, in recent years, integrated amplifiers have come into their own, offering performance and simplicity that even high-end separate systems have trouble matching. Case in... Click for more...

Bel Canto e.One S300 Power Amplifier Reviewed -

Stereo amplifiers have been a staple since music went from single speakers to two-way back in the day. Over the years, we've seen stereo amplifiers go from simple, manageable black boxes to over-the-top, larger-than-thou space heaters for the home and... Click for more...

OmniMount Link Series A/V Stands Reviewed -

As its name suggests, OmniMount's Link Series is a modular line of A/V stands that you can mix and match to craft the exact entertainment solution you need. You can also add on as your system grows. The Link Series,... Click for more...

Paradigm Reference Studio 20 v.5 Bookshelf Speaker Reviewed -

I've been a fan of Paradigm for years, owning and enjoying seemingly every speaker in their product line from the awesome and affordable Atoms to their flagship Signature S8s. Over the years there have been two Paradigm speaker designs that... Click for more...

Bel Canto REF 1000M Mono Amplifier Reviewed -

When one thinks of a 500-Watt mono amplifier you probably picture a large, heat sink clad hunk of steel that weighs more than the car you drove it home in and probably costs more too. What if I told you... Click for more...

OmniMount VideoBasics TV Mounts Reviewed -

You've spent the extra money to buy an ultra-thin HDTV. The last thing you want to do is hinder the minimalist look by mating the TV with a bulky wall-mount. OmniMount designed the VideoBasics line of flat-panel TV mounts with... Click for more...

Read All Reviews