B&W Signature Diamond Loudspeakers Reviewed
- By: Ken Kessler
- - Reviewer's System
- Resources & Links:
- Bowers & Wilkins (B&W) ,
- Dynamic Loudspeaker
- December 4, 2008
A sea-change is affecting high-end speakers. It's a result of manufacturers realizing that the only way they're going to get decent sound into rooms where aesthetics matter is to design pretty speakers. In a nutshell, custom installation and hidden speakers have taken over an entire world ignored by and unknown to audiophiles: wealthy customers who can actually afford the stuff we dream about. They simply don't want to see the stuff.But we, the hobbyists, know that the instant a speaker goes in the wall, the sound is compromised beyond recovery. So this admirable action from commercially savvy manufacturers is about the survival of standalone primary speakers in serious sound systems not owned by audio enthusiasts.
Briefly, we all know that brands like Sonus faber, MartinLogan and a couple of others are default recommendations when someone asks about "speakers that won't make my wife/interior decorator throw a hissy fit." Even more exciting of late to the house-proud, moneyed gadget lover are visual "statements" in which the looks have been as much a reason for purchase as the sound; these include the original, snail-shaped B&W Nautilus and the new KEF Muon. But something else has been added to the recipe, an idea borrowed or inspired by other luxury goods, such as watches and cars: limited edition status and the inherent status of cost-based exclusivity.
This preamble is necessary if you're to put the Bowers & Wilkins Signature Diamond into the correct context. While at no time am I suggesting that performance has been regarded as secondary by B&W at any stage in its creation, there is no doubt that much of the appeal - and justification for the outrageous price - will be a direct result of the limited production of 1000 pairs, 500 each in white or Wakame wood, and intrinsic exclusivity of a price that serves no other purpose than to affirm said prestige. And it doesn't hurt if a well-known industrial designer, in this case Kenneth Grange, has his or her hands all over the form.
B&W developed the Signature Diamond to mark its fortieth anniversary. Some brilliant copywriter came up with this statement, which you just have to love for its delightful cheek: "Yes, we know; diamonds should be reserved for sixtieth anniversaries. But then, were it not ahead of its time, it wouldn't be a B&W speaker."
So, regardless of the effort lavished on the form, the stunning finish, the materials and the pleasing shape, this boasts enough of the right stuff to tempt audiophiles: a diamond vapor deposit on the dome tweeter, the seven-inch woven Kevlar bass/midrange driver, the signature detail of an utterly inert, solid sculptured marble, free-standing housing for the tweeter. Make no mistake: this is far more than a cosmetics job.
In addition to the tweeter housing, which stands like a car mascot from the days before the health 'n' safety nannies made them illegal, the most distinctive and eye-pleasing element of the Signature Diamond is the non-boxy enclosure. While hardly radical - the shape has an egg-like cross section, tapering to the back - the compact dimensions and exquisite finish transform it into what a speaker of this elevated cost must suggest: sculpture.
It is made of formed plywood, it employs B&W's trademark Matrix innards and it is finished as nicely as anything I've seen - at least, the white ones are. I've not yet viewed the Wakame finish in person, but if it's anything like the woodwork on B&W's other upscale offerings, then none can fault it.
If anything jars about its physical presence, it has to be the size. I know, I know: we should focus on quality, not quantity. But a system of
eight 930 x 230 x 375mm (H/W/D) falls into the small floor-stander category. Whatever way you judge it, that simply doesn't sound like an £11,000 per pair speaker, and it's an observation that can be leveled at many of the Signature Diamond's rivals.
(Note from a worried Ken Kessler: The matter of "perceived value" is contentious and always will be. I'm just trying to address the way consumers respond to price tags. Someone who wouldn't balk at paying £75 for a mere mouthful of foie gras would freak out at spending £45 on a burger, even if made from Kobe beef. So, it's my belief that normal people would expect an £11,000 speaker to be massive. Not that normal people would even accept the mere notion of an £11,000 speaker ...)
Dr John Dibb, who designed anniversary models for the company's twenty-fifth and thirtieth, made sure that the sound was commensurate with the styling, and he visited my listening room to ensure that I would hear what he heard in his laboratory. Dibb is responsible for the use here of a newly-designed silver wire, hardwired in the crossover to match the silver/gold foil crossover components. He oversaw the shaping of all components, including the flow of the port in this two-way design, and it's clear he "voiced" the system. You've just gotta listen to a man who recognizes Billy Cotton in under a single revolution of the LP.
On paper? No knowledgeable audio enthusiast would show shock at a frequency response stated as -6dB at 32Hz and 33kHz, or 40-28kHz ±3dB on axis. Power shouldn't be an issue for someone shopping in this sector, so sensitivity of 88dB - what is now deemed low to medium - is no cause for fear.
Dr. Dibb set up the speakers with medium toe-in, and they were driven at various times by the Quad II-eighty and the McIntosh MC2102, with the Quad 99CDP II CD player/preamp, the McIntosh C2200 preamp and an analog front end of SME 30/Series V arm, with an Air-Tight moving coil cartridge, into the Audio Research PH5 phono stage. Wiring was Yter throughout.
If a single trait can endow a speaker with enough credibility to render it truly noteworthy, then - for me, at least - the B&W's portrayal of sheer scale is the standout element. No kidding: you'd be forgiven for thinking that the wall-to-wall/floor-to-ceiling span of the soundstage was coming from a well-developed dipole. The issue of free-standing tweeters and their superior dispersion finds an inarguable exponent here. With the gloriously huge-sounding performance of the aforementioned Billy Cotton spreading across the room, you could hear the hall in which it was recorded in all of its cavernous glory.
As with other high-end B&Ws I've heard, the detail and speed of the treble reproduction was ideally suited to producing convincing applause in this live recording. Equally, a bout of Nils Lofgren in full-on string-torturing mode exposed attack that I have no hesitation in regarding as utterly world-class. Impact, body, controlled decay, no overhang - seriously cutting-edge.
Indeed, the only concern I have is strictly personal: I found it at times a bit too sharp and too edgy, though neither more nor less sibilant than I would accept at this level. Well-recorded voices, as much as electric guitar, revealed this tendency, injecting just enough over-etched artifice into the soaring vocals of Jackie Wilson's "Doggin' Around" to suggest some sort of lift in the upper reaches.
This, however, is to me a B&W trait which endears the speakers to its more vehement supporters (who would argue that it's more accurate than everything else, and I am deaf). Conversely, the bass is so rich and full and solid that I can only marvel at such sheer scale and quantity from such a small enclosure. The way it handled the opening bass and drum component of the Four Season's "Walk Like a Man" thrills and delights. And yet ... for half the money, the prettier Sonus Faber Cremona M outperforms it in every parameter.
But these are not issues that will concern the target consumer, any more than fuel consumption figures cross the lips of the potential owner of a Bentley, nor worries of cancer affect the buyer of a big, fat Cohiba. What we see here is a terrific speaker wrapped in a gorgeous enclosure, the potential client having to accept that things like marble tweeter housings add to overall cost.
With any speaker where cosmetics are as important as sound, there are invariably compromises between the two. Sonically, scale and detail are world-class, bass is generous, but there's an identifiable trace of edgy "hi-fi" artifice, even with tubes. By loony audio standards, this is a £6000 speaker in a £5000 frock ... albeit a limited-edition, name-designer 'objet.' But for those to whom status matters, the sound/looks balance isn't an issue.
Style Vs. Substance
It's easy for audiophiles to be snobby about the need for gorgeous cabinets to seduce customers not impressed solely by sound. But that's why high-end audio has always struggled in the face of other luxury goods. Even allowing for the most extreme examples of odd personal taste, there is no such thing as an ugly Ferrari or a cheap-looking high-end watch. But cars are on the road, watches go on the wrist: speakers take over the room they're filling with sound.
I speak from personal experience of well-heeled music lovers torn between sound and looks. In my opinion, B&W has, with this speaker, tipped the balance of the two in favor of the speaker as an objet d'art. But it still qualifies as a serious high-end speaker. You just have to accept that good looks cost money, and that means using name designers. Kenneth Grange for B&W, Ross Lovegrove for KEF - wise choices. But God forbid someone calls on Tracey Emin or Damien Hirst.
- Wilson Audio Alexandria Loudsp...
- Acoustic Zen Adagio Loudspeaker...
- Aerial Acoustics Model 20T Loud...
- B&W Signature Diamond Loudspeak...
- Bang & Olufsen BeoLab 6000 Loud...
- Bang & Olufsen BeoLab 8000 Loud...
- Bowers & Wilkins 683 Loudspeake...
- Bowers & Wilkins 703 Floorstand...
- Bowers & Wilkins CT 700 Series ...
- Bowers & Wilkins XT4 Loudspeake...
- Definitive Technology Mythos ST...
- Floorstanding and Audiophile Lo...
- Infinity Classia Series C336 Lo...
- JBL ES90 Loudspeakers Reviewed...
- JBL Project Array 1400 Array Lo...
- JBL Project Everest DD66000 Lou...
- JBL Studio L Series L890 Floors...
- JBL WEM-1 Wireless Expansion Mo...
- KEF Muon Floorstanding Loudspea...
- MBL 101 Loudspeakers Reviewed...
- Magnepan MMG Floor-Standing Spe...
- MartinLogan CLX Electrostatic L...
- MartinLogan Purity Hybrid Elect...
- MartinLogan Spire Hybrid Electr...
- MartinLogan Summit Loudspeakers...
- MartinLogan Vantage Hybrid Elec...
- MartinLogan Vista Hybrid Electr...
- Monitor Audio Silver RS6 Loudsp...
- Nola Viper Reference II Loudspe...
- PSB Imagine T Loudspeaker Revie...
- Paradigm Monitor 7 Floorstandin...
- Paradigm Reference Studio 100v4...
- Paradigm Signature S8 v.2 Louds...
- Paradigm Studio 100 5.1 Speaker...
- Quad Super System Reviewed...
- Revel Concerta F12 Floorstandin...
- Revel Performa F52 Floorstandin...
- Revel Ultima Salon2 Loudspeaker...
- Vandersteen 1c Loudspeaker Revi...
- Vandersteen 5A Loudspeaker Revi...
- Wilson WATT Puppy Version 8 Lou...
- Wisdom Audio Sage Series Speake...
Today's Top Story
Can The Home Theater Business Re-price Itself Back Into The Hearts and Wallets of Consumers? -
This recession is a bitch. The talking heads on the Sunday morning shows were shooting off this weekend about the fact that the American economy was headed into recession no matter what, but the collapse of the real estate market... Click for more...
Latest Floor-Standing Speaker Reviews
JBL Project Everest DD66000 Loudspeaker -
The JBL Project Everest DD66000 is the most ambitious loudspeaker in the history of JBL--and that's saying something considering the company's long lineage of research and development. The DD66000, ranging in price from $60,000 to $70,000 a pair depending on... Click for more...
Nola Viper Reference II Loudspeakers Reviewed -
There are many specialty audio brands that may not be well-recognized by the general public, yet which have the admiration of those in the know. Nola is one of those brands, something of an unsung hero of the audiophile world.... Click for more...
Paradigm Studio 100 5.1 Speaker System Reviewed -
The Paradigm Studio v.5 series was introduced at CES 2009 as the fifth iteration of the Studio series. The Studio series was first introduced about a decade ago and, as the version number implies, it has been updated as new... Click for more...
Wisdom Audio Sage Series Speakers Reviewed -
The modern world of AV gear is expanding. Speakers that were once simple boxes filled with drivers have grown into complex designs, thanks to the increase in available technology and experience the years have offered. With these technological advances, speakers... Click for more...
Bowers & Wilkins CT 700 Series Loudspeakers Reviewed -
It didn't take me long to realize that this wasn't going to be your normal product review. Not because the product, Bowers & Wilkins' new CT 700 series loudspeaker, is either bad or wholly unique, but because, unlike other traditional... Click for more...
Infinity Classia Series C336 Loudspeaker Reviewed -
Infinity is a company known for loudspeakers that combine attractive styling with high-tech driver design. The Classia C336 floor-standing loudspeaker is no exception. Its subtle yet distinctive visual elements give it a unique look that sets it apart from your... Click for more...
JBL ES90 Loudspeakers Reviewed -
The JBL ES90 is part of the legendary speaker company's mainstream ES Series lineup of home theater and music loudspeakers. At $599 each, suggested retail, the ES90 floor-standing tower is at the top of the ES Series, combining unique wedge-shaped... Click for more...
JBL WEM-1 Wireless Expansion Module -
Many people would love to install a home theater (yes, there are still legions of people out there who don't have one), but face a very real obstacle: how do they get the wires from the A/V receiver to the... Click for more...
JBL Project Array 1400 Array Loudspeaker -
The JBL Project Array series of home theater and music loudspeakers is one of JBL's high-end speaker lines, incorporating professional-quality drivers and a number of unique design aspects in its quest to deliver exceptional sound quality. The 1400 Array (suggested... Click for more...
Magnepan MMG Floor-Standing Speakers Reviewed -
The Magnepan MMG is the smallest and least expensive speaker in the Magnepan line, priced at $599 per pair and coupled with a very generous 60-day return policy. Magnepan also offers the option of trading in your "Maggies" for full... Click for more...




Comment on this article
1For me, equipment is made to reproduce music. You have the lower end products, then you have the all out top of the line products. These speakers fall into a category that says, you`ll have something different and unique, will sound good, maybe very good, but price performance per dollar value is not in the equation here.
In my opinion, these B&W`s are for those who are looking to make a statement. And the manufacturer, the same. So, this speaker is not for everybody.
Post a Comment