Celestion 3000 Ribbon Loudspeakers Reviewed
- By: Ken Kessler
- - Reviewer's System
- Resources & Links:
- Bookshelf Speaker Reviews ,
- View Ken Taraszka's Reviews
- February 13, 1989
Hybrids are supposed to be the best of two or more technologies, and we've seen the approach used for all manner of products. Solid-state-plus-valve electronics, moving-coil cartridges with 'Decca' architecture -- I could go on and on. The most feverish of hi-fi's Dr Frankensteins, though, have always been devoted to loudspeakers.
Name any type of tweeter and I can assure you that it's been mated to a cone-type bass driver. The reasons are simple: planar tweeters (electrostatic, isodynamic etc) offer the speed, openness or transparency not generally available from cone or dome tweeters, while cone woofers offer greater damping, control, 'snap, efficiency and domestic suitability than manageable panel-type bass units can deliver. This isn't to suggest that cone bass drivers are superior to panel woofers, only that they're usually more practical and cost-effective.
Ribbon/cone hybrids have been around for years, with the Germans producing variants in the way that the British pump out £99 per pair budget speakers. Among the most famous, though, is the Decca London enclosure, which used Stan Kelly's ribbon, so there are British precedents. SD Acoustics, Alphason -- this hybrid may be slightly off-the-wall, but it's not uncommon. Tweaky, yes, but not all that rare.
Noble though the efforts of SD and the others may be, their products are fairly exclusive and less 'commercial' than is required for spreading the word beyond audiophile circles. Now it's time for one of the majors to step in, and with a design to address the curses which keep ribbon technology from being truly affordable and domestically acceptable.
Celestion's 3000 attempts to banish the problems of low sensitivity, death-defying impedances, low power handling, domestically aggravating siting requirements and a host of other concerns. Indeed, the Celestion 3000 is the most 'complete' new
product I've examined in years, with every single detail -- right
down to the owner's manual -- dealt with in full before a single
unit left the factory. Aesthetics, fit and finish,
fine-tuning...nothing's been left to chance.
The 3000 (and the 5000, which is identical except for cabinet
finish) employs a box-type enclosure measuring a mere
650x330x300mm (HWD). It's substantial, assembled from high
density particle board and made rigid with figure-of-eight
internal bracing. The company also offers a sonically and
aesthetically ideal support for #159 per pair which stands 550mm
tall; I can't imagine anyone not using this beautifully styled,
sand-and-lead-filled, spiked sculpture. The novelty of a ribbon
tweeter is highlighted by an aluminum casting which runs the
height of the speaker, at an angle and situated on the inner edge
of the baffle. As you'd expect; the speakers are supplied in
left-and-right-handed pairs. The 3000 is all black; for an extra
#100, you can purchase the 5000, identical except for walnut
surfaces.
The front surface is covered by a black grille cloth on a solid,
sculpted frame; it protects a 200mm polyolefine cone bass bass
driver, which operates up to 900Hz. The grille has been designed
to create a smooth surface on the outside edge of the ribbon's
chassis, mirroring the inner, veneered surface, so the grilles
should be left in place at all times.
The back contains binding posts for single, bi-wire or bi-amping
connections, and they accept spaced banana plugs. For some
strange reason, Celestion fitted them in a row reading (from left
to right) treble minus, bass minus, bass plus, treble plus, so
you've got to interleave and spread the wires across the
connectors; I'd have preferred to see the connections grouped as
bass plus/minus and treble plus/minus, but this is a small
quibble. It simply meant paying attention to the wiring of the
spaced bananas I insist on using.
And now for the ribbon. This 500mm driver consists of a narrow
strip of 12 micron thick, corrugated aluminum foil suspended
between two rows of strontium ferrite bar magnets. Although it
looks like a clone of the Apogee tweeter, it differs in details.
For starters, the ribbon itself is pure aluminum without any
backing; the Apogee uses Kapton. At the top and bottom, the
Celestion ribbon is connected with a foam-damped 'kink' in the
ribbon to relieve strain. Where Apogee uses foam 'knuckles' to
support and centre the ribbon at various points, Celestion uses
stretched silicon rubber belts supported by small pillars on
either side of the ribbon. The other major difference relates to
the 3000's non-dipole status.
There is no gap between the ribbon's edges and the magnets, a
critically selected gap being required for use in dipole
installations. With the Celestion, the sound firing from the back
of the ribbon is reflected off of the surfaces in the speaker
cabinet, the ribbon actually being mounted to its own separate
enclosure within the 3000. This partially explains why the ribbon
is mounted at a 45 degree angle to the enclosure; the rear-firing
sound fires directly into absorptive foam and out of harm's way.
The other reason for the 45 degree angle is to aid in positioning
and the creation of a line source which disperses sound in a
cylindrical manner. I mentioned before that the rigid grille is
to be left in place so as to create smooth surfaces on either
side of the ribbon. This fools the driver into reacting to the
cabinet as if it were a cylinder, the result being an enclosure
which has no edges to cause diffraction. In practice, it means
that the only requirements for siting concern the bass, because
'toe-in' requirements have been eliminated. Sayonara, hot seat.
These are, without doubt, the easiest speakers I've ever reviewed
as far as positioning is concerned, save for certain types where
the siting is fixed or quite specific (e.g. Bose 901s, some
Allisons). Celestion recommends that they stand approximately six
inches from the back wall, with the backs parallel to the wall.
Because of the dispersion characteristics of the ribbons, the
distance between the speakers is not critical. The further apart
you're able to place them, the wider the sound stage they'll
produce. I had to move them over 15 feet apart before I could
detect anything resembling a 'hole in the middle', from a
listening position 12 feet away. Naturally, you'll augment the
bass if the speakers are too close to the side walls, but that's
true of most loudspeakers. Where I differed from Celestion's
preferred siting is in the distance from the back wall. I found
the bass just a bit too overpowering, so the ideal spot in my
room was 15in from the back wall.
Amplifier selection is another matter entirely, and I wasted a
whole week before I hit on the first of three magic combinations.
Arbitrary though it may be, I try to review speakers with the
kind of amplifiers which I think the consumer will use, as well
as with 'reference' amplifiers. The argument for the latter is
that only by hooking up a pair of, say, #99 Celestion 3s to a
#10,000 Rowland will I be able to assess the full potential of
the speaker. On the other hand, the reviews are only valid for
the readers if the speakers have been tried with likely
candidates.
In the case of the 3000, I had to throw out all of the rules. I
started with what I thought would be a sensible choice for a
speaker/stand combination at this price point, the #1250
Counterpoint SA-12. (Also, I should add, a hybrid.) For 80
percent of the time, all was wonderful except for the handling of
torture tracks I use to test sibilance. These include recordings
which are 'right on the edge', such as Juice Newton's 'Break It
To Me Gently' or Poco's Head Over Heels. The 3000/SA12 pairing,
while stunning in most respects, simply fell to pieces. And it
was a textbook lesson in why you should always audition a
potential purchase with the system in which it will reside. The
Counterpoint -- sweet and smooth with the Sonus Fabers -- sounded
edgy with the Celestion 3000, the opposite of its general
behavior.
Out came Old Faithful, my Radford SA25 Mk IV. Talk about a
transition. The spit and sizzle disappeared, without taking away
any of the top end information. But I was still in a quandary.
How valid is a review of an affordable new speaker with an
out-of-production amplifier with a circa #1000 price tag? Relief
came in the form of Antony Michaelson, who dropped by with the
Musical Fidelity B1 (#199) and A100 (#499) integrated amplifiers,
products which you can buy and which you shouldn't have too hard
a time finding in shops which also sell Celestion. The results
were absolute bliss, so -- for those of you who crave the 3000 --
you can drive 'em with a #199 integrated amp and still get almost
all they can deliver bar the absolute dynamics. As for the A100,
well, why spend more?
Before launching into a description of the performance, let me
put you into the right frame of mind. I have this crazy image of
polyester suited sales reps in countries like the USA running
around hyping the new Celestion hybrids with lines like 'They
blow away Apogees/Mangenpans/etc'. Let me tell you from the outset
that these speakers cannot be compared to full-range ribbons or
any other dipoles because there are certain things which the
3000s cannot do. For starters, they are nowhere near as
'open-sounding' or transparent as dipoles. Furthermore, the bass
has a distinctly cone-like speed and control which dipoles (or
affordable ones, at least) can't emulate. It is unfair to compare
the Celestion to dipoles -- ribbon tweeter or not -- because
they can't compete. They should be compared to other boxes...in
which case they'll clean up. I suggest that Celestion sacks any
rep who employs the above practice, because he or she obviously
doesn't understand the product, the market, hi-fi or
salesmanship.
What the Celestion does to boxes in its price class is elevate
the standards by a frightening degree. Given that the speakers
will compete with like-priced, like-dimensioned boxes, I expect
that Celestion shares are the ones to buy for those of you with
stock portfolios. Talk about high-end for the poor...
I've settled on one track which tells me more about a product
under review than any dozen can. It's my crash course in hi-fi
assessment; anything I listen to afterwards is simply for
confirmation. The track is the CD single version of Willy De
Ville's 'Assassin of Love', which even Antony -- a classical-only
type who thinks that Fleetwood Mac is a village in Berkshire --
found to be revealing in excelsis. It tests, with great
authority, the following: bass extension; bass control; transient
attack, decay and recovery; stage width, depth and height; vocal
textures; sibilance; scale; image specificity; 'layering' and a
whole lot more. The 3000 sailed through with flying colors.
It was through the use of this disc that I learned how the 3000s
could convert power and scale without compression, and do a damned
fine 'disappearing act' of near-dipole invisibility. Another test
disc, supplied by Antony, yielded a second opinion. The recording
in a church of some classical bit to do with Daniel and the lions
proved the 3000s capable of replicating the sound of a massive,
echo-y venue, the procession starting far behind the back wall
and ending in front of the line of the speakers. So far so good.
In absolute terms, the Celestion's staging capabilities were of
an order so far beyond what is expected at this price point that
I wanted only to listen to other 3-D extravaganzas. More telling,
though, was the utter independence which the listener has, with
seating three abreast not resulting in a fight for centre
position. This, my friends, is the perfect speaker for those of
you who eschew onanistic listening practices and prefer to share
the music with others. And it's one area where price doesn't
enter into the equation, because in this respect I reckon that
the 3000 beats all comers.
The other feat performed by Celestion which makes the 3000 so
special is its seamlessness. This speaker is the first hybrid
I've used which shows no joins, the bass driver having been
tailored to the ribbon (or vice versa) with such overwhelming
synergy that you're forgiven for thinking that it's a full-range
system. The result is an 'of a whole' sonic spectrum, with
consistent speed, clarity and low coloration throughout.
The sound is drier than that of, say, the Apogee Diva, less rich
and a shade cooler, but it only sounds clinical or hygienic when
paired with too dry an amplifier. The two Musical Fidelity amps
and the Radford were perfectly capable of keeping the 3000 from
sounding too much like hi-fi rather than music, so I'd suggest
that you audition the Celestions with amps in that vein. Lord
knows what these would sound like with -- no, I'd better not name
it.
So what do you get by spending more? At #699 per pair (or #858
including the mandatory stands), the 3000 has revised the
expectations of a purchaser with under #1000 to spend. What you
get from the floor-standing model 7000 is greater bass, dynamics
and power handling. What you get from other speakers, like the
Quad ESLs, Apogees, Martin-Logans et al is more transparency.
True, the Celestion has a finely-grained texture all of its own,
but it's euphonic and -- sighs of relief from Ipswich -- utterly
consistent from top to bottom. In other words, you'll have to pay
at least the same amount again to remove one or two rather
diaphanous veils.
As far as I'm concerned, this is the best speaker money can buy
for under #1k, provided that the purchaser understands the
critical nature of matching this to a sonically sympathetic
amplifier. In basic terms, driving these is no great challenge, so
you don't have to spend your readies on sheer power. With a
beauty like the B1, the combination is a bargain for would-be
high-enders. So don't think of these as a poor man's Apogees.
Regard them instead as Everyman's ribbon.
Keywords
Celestion 3000 speaker reviewes
- KEF KIT100 Speaker System Revi...
- Opera Mini Bookshelf Loudspeak...
- Stirling LS3 V2 Bookshelf Loud...
- AAD PL-100 / PL-200 / PL-200C /...
- ALR Entry 2M Loudspeakers Revie...
- ATC A7 Loudspeakers Reviewed...
- ATC SCM20 Bookshelf Loudspeaker...
- Anthony Gallo Acoustics Due Lou...
- Anthony Gallo Due Speaker Syste...
- B&W Nautilus 805 Loudspeakers R...
- B&W Solid Sub/Sat Speaker Syste...
- B&W VM1 Speakers and AS1 Subwoo...
- Boston Acoustics P400 Home Thea...
- Bowers and Wilkins (B&W) 602 Bo...
- Canton Movie 10-MX II Home Cine...
- Castle Durham 900 Loudspeakers ...
- Celestion 3000 Ribbon Loudspeak...
- Celestion 5 Loudspeakers Review...
- Celestion SL700 Loudspeaker Sys...
- Dali Evidence Speaker Ensemble ...
- Definitive Technology Powermoni...
- Definitive Technology Procinema...
- Diapason Karis Bookshelf Loudsp...
- DynAudio Contour T2.5 Speakers ...
- Energy ACT6 SUB/SAT Speaker Sys...
- Indigo Stage One Bookshelf Spea...
- Infinity Kappa Series and Inter...
- Infinity TSS-750 Home Cinema Sy...
- JBL L1 Bookshelf Speakers Revie...
- JBL Northridge E Series 24A WII...
- JBL SCS160SI Home Speaker Syste...
- JBL SCS300.7 Surround Cinema Sp...
- JBL XPL 90 Loudspeakers Reviewe...
- JL Audio XR650-CSI Component Sp...
- JM Labs Micron Carat Speakers R...
- JM Labs SIB & CUB 5.1 Speaker S...
- KEF Q-Series Speaker System Rev...
- KEF Reference 205/201/202C and ...
- KEF XQ Series and psw3500 Louds...
- Klipsch Synergy Series SLX/SUB-...
- LOTH-X ION BS1 Loudspeaker Revi...
- Loth-X Ino Amaze Loudspeakers R...
- Mirage OMNISAT 6 Speakers Revie...
- Mirage Omnisat Micro Loudspeake...
- Monitor Audio Bronze Series Lou...
- Monitor Audio Reference 1200 "G...
- Monitor Audio Studio 10 Loudspe...
- Opera Callas Speakers Reviewed...
- Opera Platea Loudspeakers Revie...
- Orb Audio Mod4 Custom Home Thea...
- Paradigm Phantom Speakers Revie...
- Phase Technology Velocity V-10 ...
- Polk Audio RM6900 Home Theater ...
- RBH CT-7.1 Compact Theater Spea...
- RBH MC Series Mark II Reviewed...
- Rogers LS3a Bookshelf Speakers ...
- Rogers db101 Speakers Reviewed...
- Roxsan Hotcakes Bookshelf Louds...
- Ruark Epilogue Loudspeakers Rev...
- Sonance Cinema Ultra II LCR Spe...
- Sonus fabber Musical Loudspeake...
- Sonus faber Concerto GP Loudspe...
- Sonus faber Cremona Bookshelf L...
- Spendor S-3/5 Speakers Reviewed...
- Spendor S3 Speakers Reviewed...
- TDL Studio 0.5 Bookshelf Loudsp...
- THEIL Viewpoint Speakers and Sm...
- THIEL ViewPoint Speakers Review...
- Tannoy 603 Audiophile Loudspeak...
- Tannoy Arena 5.1 Loudspeaker Sy...
- Totem Acoustic: TRIBE I, TRIBE ...
- Wharfdale Diamond 8.1 Speakers ...
- Wharfedale Diamond 8 Series Spe...
- XHi-Fi xDucer 2.1 Desltop Louds...
- Yamaha DVX-S120 Home Cinema Spe...
- Zingali Coliseum Loudspeakers R...
Featured Audio-Video News
Experiencing Your Dream Home Theater While On Vacation -
It isn't any news that the economy is in the dumps. Morphing your living room, garage or basement into the...
Latest Bookshelf Speaker Reviews (Classic)
Rogers db101 Speakers Reviewed -
Wealth by association is a funny concept. But that's never stopped merchandisers from exploiting weird non-sequiturs like Ferrari-badged wristwatches, Marlboro clothing or any of the perfumes which inevitably follow the success of a designer in the rag-trade. And while writing... Click for more...
Sonus faber Concerto GP Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Keeping one step ahead of the competition has been Sonus Faber's trick ever since the birth of an Italian 'school' of speaker design. Whatever the origins of the genre - and there are stories to make Boccaccio blanch - the... Click for more...
B&W Solid Sub/Sat Speaker System Reviewed -
Sub-woofer/satellite systems can be a pain in the butt for reviewers because all the myriad permutations must be addressed. And, hey, does the B&W Solid Solutions system permutate. That's not B&W's fault. They're dealing with a format established years ago... Click for more...
ATC A7 Loudspeakers Reviewed -
"Hot minis continue to proliferate." It's the kind of phrase you'd expect to find in any show report, in any magazine, covering any British hi-fi show. It's the clichÈ that has marked the British loudspeaker industry ever since the 1970s,... Click for more...
Sonus fabber Musical Loudspeaker Reviewed -
It's easy to forget that, once upon a time, the doyen of Italian speaker manufacture made amplifiers. They were mainly valved, oozed the sort of woodcraft found in the company's speakers and sported daft names like 'Quid'.* They were not... Click for more...
Ruark Epilogue Loudspeakers Reviewed -
'Y'gaddaseeit!' 'Y'gaddaseeit!' 'Y'gaddaseeit!' Three times is usually enough to convince me that something's afoot. Ordinarily, there's so much new and worthwhile kit at a hi-fi show that the surfeit of brilliant new products tends to overwhelm. But when a consensus... Click for more...
Opera Platea Loudspeakers Reviewed -
It's not just sound which comes in waves: hardware trends seem to as well. With domestic congestion, urban dwelling and bitch-wives* from hell deeming with increasing vehemence that any speaker larger than a loaf of bread is an intrusion, it... Click for more...
B&W Nautilus 805 Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Presuppose for just a second that the cheapest model in a range will always outsell the model above it in logarithmic proportion. Presuppose it all the way up the range, to its flagship edition, and you can only imagine the... Click for more...
Diapason Karis Bookshelf Loudspeakers Reviewed -
While there's been no announcement to the effect, nor a banner across the upper corner to indicate it, this is part of a series of reviews. The theme? To find a replacement for the late, lamented LS3/5A. The requirements are... Click for more...
ALR Entry 2M Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Irony, said to be something which Americans fail completely to comprehend, was written all over this assignment because of one teensy detail. Before I was allowed to review ALR's Entry 2M budget two-way loudspeaker, I was commanded from on high... Click for more...
Latest Bookshelf Speaker Reviews (Classic)
Rogers db101 Speakers Reviewed -
Wealth by association is a funny concept. But that's never stopped merchandisers from exploiting weird non-sequiturs like Ferrari-badged wristwatches, Marlboro clothing or any of the perfumes which inevitably follow the success of a designer in the rag-trade. And while writing... Click for more...
Sonus faber Concerto GP Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Keeping one step ahead of the competition has been Sonus Faber's trick ever since the birth of an Italian 'school' of speaker design. Whatever the origins of the genre - and there are stories to make Boccaccio blanch - the... Click for more...
B&W Solid Sub/Sat Speaker System Reviewed -
Sub-woofer/satellite systems can be a pain in the butt for reviewers because all the myriad permutations must be addressed. And, hey, does the B&W Solid Solutions system permutate. That's not B&W's fault. They're dealing with a format established years ago... Click for more...
ATC A7 Loudspeakers Reviewed -
"Hot minis continue to proliferate." It's the kind of phrase you'd expect to find in any show report, in any magazine, covering any British hi-fi show. It's the clichÈ that has marked the British loudspeaker industry ever since the 1970s,... Click for more...
Sonus fabber Musical Loudspeaker Reviewed -
It's easy to forget that, once upon a time, the doyen of Italian speaker manufacture made amplifiers. They were mainly valved, oozed the sort of woodcraft found in the company's speakers and sported daft names like 'Quid'.* They were not... Click for more...
Ruark Epilogue Loudspeakers Reviewed -
'Y'gaddaseeit!' 'Y'gaddaseeit!' 'Y'gaddaseeit!' Three times is usually enough to convince me that something's afoot. Ordinarily, there's so much new and worthwhile kit at a hi-fi show that the surfeit of brilliant new products tends to overwhelm. But when a consensus... Click for more...
Opera Platea Loudspeakers Reviewed -
It's not just sound which comes in waves: hardware trends seem to as well. With domestic congestion, urban dwelling and bitch-wives* from hell deeming with increasing vehemence that any speaker larger than a loaf of bread is an intrusion, it... Click for more...
B&W Nautilus 805 Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Presuppose for just a second that the cheapest model in a range will always outsell the model above it in logarithmic proportion. Presuppose it all the way up the range, to its flagship edition, and you can only imagine the... Click for more...
Diapason Karis Bookshelf Loudspeakers Reviewed -
While there's been no announcement to the effect, nor a banner across the upper corner to indicate it, this is part of a series of reviews. The theme? To find a replacement for the late, lamented LS3/5A. The requirements are... Click for more...
ALR Entry 2M Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Irony, said to be something which Americans fail completely to comprehend, was written all over this assignment because of one teensy detail. Before I was allowed to review ALR's Entry 2M budget two-way loudspeaker, I was commanded from on high... Click for more...
Latest Equipment Reviews
Mapleshade Time-Correcting Maple Bedrock Speaker Stands Reviewed -
For ages the adage with bookshelf and/or monitor speakers has always been getting the tweeter or tweeter/midrange as close to ear height will yield the best results. Of course proper placement in a room as well as in relation to... Click for more...
Mapleshade Samson V.1 Equipment Rack Reviewed -
Seemingly everyone makes an equipment rack of some form or another these days with varying degrees of success, however for best results you're better off going with a third party or specialty equipment rack. The problem with going with an... Click for more...
Oppo BDP-83 Special Edition Universal Player Reviewed -
Oppo Digital's first Blu-ray player the BDP-83 entered the market in mid 2009 to numerous accolades. A mere half year later, Oppo Digital, not satisfied with the untapped performance potential of the player, released the BDP-83 Special Edition reviewed here.... Click for more...
Parker Audio 95MK II Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Chances are you've never heard of or seen a pair of Parker Audio 95MK II loudspeakers. Because of that fact, you're probably thinking they're some sort of uber-esoteric, high-end, ultra-expensive loudspeakers from some designer's garage in Munich. Well, you'd be... Click for more...
Bel Canto e. One S300iu Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Integrated amplifiers have always been an effective and affordable way to get into two-channel audio. However, in recent years, integrated amplifiers have come into their own, offering performance and simplicity that even high-end separate systems have trouble matching. Case in... Click for more...
Bel Canto e.One S300 Power Amplifier Reviewed -
Stereo amplifiers have been a staple since music went from single speakers to two-way back in the day. Over the years, we've seen stereo amplifiers go from simple, manageable black boxes to over-the-top, larger-than-thou space heaters for the home and... Click for more...
OmniMount Link Series A/V Stands Reviewed -
As its name suggests, OmniMount's Link Series is a modular line of A/V stands that you can mix and match to craft the exact entertainment solution you need. You can also add on as your system grows. The Link Series,... Click for more...
Paradigm Reference Studio 20 v.5 Bookshelf Speaker Reviewed -
I've been a fan of Paradigm for years, owning and enjoying seemingly every speaker in their product line from the awesome and affordable Atoms to their flagship Signature S8s. Over the years there have been two Paradigm speaker designs that... Click for more...
Bel Canto REF 1000M Mono Amplifier Reviewed -
When one thinks of a 500-Watt mono amplifier you probably picture a large, heat sink clad hunk of steel that weighs more than the car you drove it home in and probably costs more too. What if I told you... Click for more...
OmniMount VideoBasics TV Mounts Reviewed -
You've spent the extra money to buy an ultra-thin HDTV. The last thing you want to do is hinder the minimalist look by mating the TV with a bulky wall-mount. OmniMount designed the VideoBasics line of flat-panel TV mounts with... Click for more...





Comment on this article
0Post a Comment