Etymotic ER4-P MicroPro In-ear Headphones Reviewed
- By: Ken Kessler
- - Reviewer's System
- Category:
- Audio Reviews, Equipment Reviews, Headphone Reviews
- Resources & Links:
- View Ken Kessler's Reviews
- January 4, 2009
Etymotic Research's earphones just may be the first audio product I've reviewed that the user
Moreover, it's cause for a behavioural modification previously unknown in audio. You really do have to re-learn headphone usage for this. Although they look, ostensibly, like generic earbuds, only better made and with elongated endpieces, the Etymotics are closer to earplugs custom-made for F1 drivers. This is not surprising as Etymotic Research, Inc. also produces ear protectors; the name even means 'true to the ear.'
Common ground with motor racing ear plugs is what makes the ER4 range so effective: proper insertion results in a 20dB-41dB noise cut, depending on which cushions you use. This level of noise reduction is precisely what an F1 driver needs, with his head mere inches from a 700hp-1000hp engine. For us, it means incredible isolation, useful on long flights, for example, and an air-tight seal that enables the ER4-P and its variants to produce simply sensational bass.
They're not, by the way, the first high-end earbuds, as there have been models over, say, £100 before; Shure, for one, has a range of very serious in-the-ear models, while Stax's SR-001s have been around for years. The SR-001s are, in effect, earbuds with a linking headband, as they're so small compared to conventional headphones; however, they do not invade your canal to anything like the depth of the Etymotics (or the Shures), and therefore do not create the necessary seal.
Etymotics arrive as a kit reminiscent of home medical apparatus. Inside the paperback-book sized black plastic box are the ER4-Ps on a 5ft lead with 3.5mm stereo plug, protected in a shaped, foam insert. A 1/4in plus adaptor is provided as well, plus three pairs of the flanged eartips (one pair pre-mounted), five pairs of foam eartips which provide better isolation, a shirt clip, a travel pouch, four replacement filters and a special tool for this purpose.
Both the spare filters and shirt clip are not mere conceits nor accessories. The minuscule filters protect the drivers from earwax and they must be replaced when clogged, which is inevitable no matter how obsessive your hygiene. The shirt clip is mandatory because the ER4 suffers unbelievably from the microphony of the cable rubbing against your clothing (or your flesh if you listen naked). You hear a whacking great, thunderous scrape every time the cable is moved. Judicious use of the clip helps - though I don't recommend clipping it to bare flesh.
That's the only downside to the Etymotics, if you can get past the notion of sticking something in your ear. The instructions, however, are comprehensive, with safety in mind. One simple test, too, helps to determine if you've inserted them with equal care: play a mono recording and the sound should be dead-centre. Unless you have one damaged ear.
The P suffix version is optimised for portables, with higher sensitivity at the frequency extremes, while the ER-4S is the more purist version without bass enhancement. (There's also an ER4-B optimised for binaural recording enthusiasts, for use with recordings not equalized for speaker playback.) Users of the ER4-P can buy an adaptor - a short cable with socket on one end and plug on the other - that converts the ER4-P to ER4-S for critical listening with home audio components.
Having the P-version without adaptor didn't stop me from trying the Etymotics with domestic audio gear; I'll report later on the differences between ER4-P and ER4-S after I get hold of the adaptor. For this review, I used the Etymotics with the Sony Walkman Pro, a couple of Panasonic and Sony personal CD players, and most critically with my own recordings made on the World's Greatest Portable: Nagra's ARES-BB. I also ran the ER4-Ps off the headphone socket from the Marantz PM-4 integrated, and used it extensively with HeadRoom's superb Total BitHead portable headphone amplifier.
No way am I going to minimise the trauma of using these for the first time. While I do firmly believe the adage 'Never stick anything in your ear larger than your elbow,' and, conversely, have total faith in the folks at HeadRoom, who supplied the review pair, it is disconcerting at best sliding the Etymotics into your ear-hole. I recommend following the instructions closely, including a pre-insertion ear cleaning. (See sidebar, 'Cleanliness Is Next To...')
As one who has a pile of super headphones to hand, along with countless earbud types, and as one who uses headphones at least two-to-three hours a day, I like to think that I have a handle on this direct-injection method of listening. No, I do not count thousands of hours of listening to personal hi-fis to be of similar worth, because most supplied-as-free earbuds suck, and the iPods' buds are legendary in their fragility and need for upgrading. Indeed, the Etymotics, along with the Shures, numerous Sennheisers,
How much of it its simply the near-total isolation, how much is the driver, the cable the filter, I don't know. And while I await trying the ER4-S, because you can detect slight bass exaggeration when using these with domestic audio components. But for portable use, well, they're the ultimate upgrade. Whether using cassette, CD or purely digital, compressed downloads, the ER4-Ps exhibit a clarity that reminded me of Stax's full-blown models, in particular the Lambdas, with the smoothness of the best Grados.
Amusingly, I got as much joy from mono recordings as I did from stereo, because Etymotic hasn't solved the ultimate headphone dilemma, that of the sound being in your head instead of around and in front of it. (Will someone
As for my stalwart Sennheiser 414s - which are certainly among the greatest headphones of all time - the ER4-Ps make them sound slightly veiled in comparison, with less impact. But there's a reason why manufacturers of conventional headphones needn't ever fear the Etymotics: they're not for everybody. Some will simply find them too creepy to use. The act of inserting them in the ear, having to clean off the wax periodically (sorry to seem coarse, but it's part of the Etymotic experience), the fiddly insertion technique - it's a world removed from the sheer comfort of the HD-414 or their newer, pocketable folding models.
If, on the other hand, their direct-injection intimacy appeals to you, the sense of isolation closing out all intrusion, you will never want to be without a pair, and you'll appreciate the underground buzz for the Etymotics. They're the closest thing so far to be directly wired to your sound source. Voices take on a realism that will have you turning your head, ripped from your reverie to see who entered the room. Transients are super-crisp, with no overhang, sibilance doesn't seem to exist, while retrieval of ultra-fine detail is without peer.
Even familiar material, like the remastered, two-disc version of Cream's
You can acquire Etymotics from UK-based UAS Enterprises Ltd, via the web site at www.pjbox.co.uk or phone 01425 475563. Thanks to the weak dollar, UAS recently announced a reduction from £230 to £199. HeadRoom Corporation has wonderful package deals with their range of truly cool headphone amps; visit their site at www.headphone.com and see if you can make the hammered greenback work your way. Whatever method you choose, you can expect to reassess completely your approach to headphone listening. Especially if you're a putz with an iPod.
Keywords
Apple iPod headphones, ultimate iPod headphones, Etymotic's ER4-P MicroPro In-ear Headphones Reviewed
- Audion Lo Sfizio Headphone Amp...
- Audio-Technica ATH-PRO5VA Close...
- Bang & Olufsen Form 2 Headphone...
- Etymotic ER4-P MicroPro In-ear ...
- Etymotic Research ER-4 In-ear H...
- Grado SR40 Headphones Reviewed...
- Grado SR80i Dynamic Headphones ...
- Monster Cable Beats by Dr. Dre ...
- STAX SRS-2050 II Basic Headphon...
- Sony MDR-RF970RK Wireless Headp...
- Sony MDR-XB500 Headphones Revie...
- Stax SR-001 Mk 2 Headphones Rev...
- Ultimate Ears UE11pro In-ear He...
Today's Top Story
California Passes Anti-Flat-HDTV Legislation To Try To Save Energy -
As a resident of California who owns a "green home" complete with new windows, high efficiency air conditioners, space-age insulation and drought tolerant planting on over two acres of hillside - today's decision to toughen standards on HDTVs is a... Click for more...
Latest Headphone Reviews
Ultimate Ears UE11pro In-ear Headphones -
So you want to live like a rock star? Then you need Ultimate Ears UE10pro in-ear monitors, as they are the absolute reference standard in-ear monitor for performers of all ages, genres and beyond. These ultra-high-technology speakers are designed to... Click for more...
Etymotic Research ER-4 In-ear Headphones Reviewed -
I will never forget the day I got my first Apple iPod. It was from Apple's PR firm and it came to my old office on Pico Boulevard in West Los Angeles. Inside there was a small note saying "if... Click for more...
Sony MDR-RF970RK Wireless Headphones Reviewed -
The $99 Sony MDR-RF970RK headphones look like most other over-the-ear headphones, with one subtle difference. These Sonys have no wires and are designed to allow the user complete freedom from the audio source. They also incorporate noise-canceling technology designed to... Click for more...
Sony MDR-XB500 Headphones Reviewed -
The MDR-XB500 headphones occupy the middle spot in Sony's "extra bass" trio of headphones. As the name suggests Sony designed these headphones to kick out serious low-end response while also providing excellent performance through the rest of the frequency range.... Click for more...
Grado SR80i Dynamic Headphones Reviewed -
The Grado name is no stranger to audiophiles, and it's a name that deserves wider recognition among the public at large. That's because, in addition to a line of well-respected phono cartridges, Grado makes high-quality headphones - including attractively priced... Click for more...
Audio-Technica ATH-PRO5VA Closed-Back Dynamic Headphones -
Audio-Technica is a name that's familiar to virtually everyone in the pro audio industry, and to many audiophiles as well. Since 1962, the company has been offering a wide range of products including phono cartridges, microphones, mixers, accessories - and... Click for more...
Grado SR40 Headphones Reviewed -
Down-pricing surely must have its limits. I mean - just how inexpensive does something have to be before the masses will accept it as justifiably priced? Or, to get to the point, what's the name 'Grado' worth in the headphone... Click for more...
Stax SR-001 Mk 2 Headphones Reviewed -
Oh, me of little faith. Worried as I was that Stax, that great Japanese purveyor of no-compromise, high-end headphones and Keeper Of The Electrostatic Faith, might have left us for good, I never really expected it to come back so,... Click for more...
Bang & Olufsen Form 2 Headphones Reviewed -
Bang & Olufsen is one of the oldest brands in the consumer electronics business, manufacturing products ranging from loudspeakers to telephones. Throughout the years, the B&O creed has been simple: create quality, user-friendly products for everyday use. B&O has been... Click for more...
Audion Lo Sfizio Headphone Amp Reviewed -
Occasionally - but thankfully not too often - a product comes along that is so pregnant with 'issues' that any review is nigh on worthless. The last time I was faced with such a perplexing situation was the Audiopax 88,... Click for more...
Latest Headphone Reviews
Ultimate Ears UE11pro In-ear Headphones -
So you want to live like a rock star? Then you need Ultimate Ears UE10pro in-ear monitors, as they are the absolute reference standard in-ear monitor for performers of all ages, genres and beyond. These ultra-high-technology speakers are designed to... Click for more...
Etymotic Research ER-4 In-ear Headphones Reviewed -
I will never forget the day I got my first Apple iPod. It was from Apple's PR firm and it came to my old office on Pico Boulevard in West Los Angeles. Inside there was a small note saying "if... Click for more...
Sony MDR-RF970RK Wireless Headphones Reviewed -
The $99 Sony MDR-RF970RK headphones look like most other over-the-ear headphones, with one subtle difference. These Sonys have no wires and are designed to allow the user complete freedom from the audio source. They also incorporate noise-canceling technology designed to... Click for more...
Sony MDR-XB500 Headphones Reviewed -
The MDR-XB500 headphones occupy the middle spot in Sony's "extra bass" trio of headphones. As the name suggests Sony designed these headphones to kick out serious low-end response while also providing excellent performance through the rest of the frequency range.... Click for more...
Grado SR80i Dynamic Headphones Reviewed -
The Grado name is no stranger to audiophiles, and it's a name that deserves wider recognition among the public at large. That's because, in addition to a line of well-respected phono cartridges, Grado makes high-quality headphones - including attractively priced... Click for more...
Audio-Technica ATH-PRO5VA Closed-Back Dynamic Headphones -
Audio-Technica is a name that's familiar to virtually everyone in the pro audio industry, and to many audiophiles as well. Since 1962, the company has been offering a wide range of products including phono cartridges, microphones, mixers, accessories - and... Click for more...
Grado SR40 Headphones Reviewed -
Down-pricing surely must have its limits. I mean - just how inexpensive does something have to be before the masses will accept it as justifiably priced? Or, to get to the point, what's the name 'Grado' worth in the headphone... Click for more...
Stax SR-001 Mk 2 Headphones Reviewed -
Oh, me of little faith. Worried as I was that Stax, that great Japanese purveyor of no-compromise, high-end headphones and Keeper Of The Electrostatic Faith, might have left us for good, I never really expected it to come back so,... Click for more...
Bang & Olufsen Form 2 Headphones Reviewed -
Bang & Olufsen is one of the oldest brands in the consumer electronics business, manufacturing products ranging from loudspeakers to telephones. Throughout the years, the B&O creed has been simple: create quality, user-friendly products for everyday use. B&O has been... Click for more...
Audion Lo Sfizio Headphone Amp Reviewed -
Occasionally - but thankfully not too often - a product comes along that is so pregnant with 'issues' that any review is nigh on worthless. The last time I was faced with such a perplexing situation was the Audiopax 88,... Click for more...
Latest Equipment Reviews
Rotel RA-1520 Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Rotel has been creating audio components for more than 46 years that have all been designed with the goal of bringing high-end audio technology to the more discriminating audiophile. Rotel's RA-1520 integrated amplifier retains the same focus, as this amplifier... Click for more...
Parasound 5250 Five Channel Power Amplifier Reviewed -
As an audio manufacturer that is very proud of its ability to design high-end audio components for the very discerning ears of Hollywood's engineers, Parasound is also insuring that their power amplifiers for the consumer market are second-to-none. The 5250... Click for more...
Vizio VSB210WS Sound Bar with Wireless Subwoofer Reviewed -
Sound bars have always been a bit of the redheaded stepchild of the home theater world for me, a replica of sorts for those unable to accommodate or afford a proper home theater. Of course I jumped to this conclusion... Click for more...
Definitive Technology Mythos 7 On-Wall Speaker Reviewed -
When it comes to perfect replication of professional theater sound, the most important component of any home theater's speaker configuration is the center channel speaker. This speaker not only has to deliver a movie's dialogue with crystal-clear audio imaging, it... Click for more...
Benchmark DAC 1 HDR Reviewed -
While analog reproduction of audio is all the rage these days, most, if not all of us have our music in some digital form. Be it on a hard drive, iPod, Compact Disc or server, we all need high quality... Click for more...
Definitive Technology UIW 75 In-Wall Speaker Reviewed -
One of the primary functions of a first-rate in-wall speaker is its ability to disperse superb high-end audio to every part of the room, no matter where the speaker itself is placed. The design team at Definitive Technology knows just... Click for more...
Outlaw Audio ECS-10 Subwoofer Reviewed -
A major problem in the past with small and compact subwoofers was their inability to deliver strong and deep low-end to the average soundstage. Outlaw Audio's design team was well aware of this challenge when they started developing the ECS-10... Click for more...
Toshiba REGZA 46SV670U LED LCD HDTV Reviewed -
LED backlighting is the way of the future for LCD televisions. Most of the top-selling LCD manufacturers now offer at least one line that uses LED backlighting. Some of these models only place the LEDs around the edges of the... Click for more...
Energy ESW-V10 Subwoofer Reviewed -
Energy is an audio manufacturer that is fairly well known for developing quality speakers at a mid-range price and now they are slowly getting into producing a more high-end subwoofer product line starting with the ESW-V10. The list price for... Click for more...
JVC LT-42X899 42-Inch LCD HDTV Reviewed -
If you have been looking for an HDTV that eliminates pesky motion blur while viewing action-packed Blu-ray discs, you should be very interested in what JVC is calling their "Clear Motion Drive III" technology. That technology is integrated into their... Click for more...





Comment on this article
0Post a Comment