For Once The Music Industry Got It Right With Rush's Moving Pictures Album on Blu-ray

Subscribe to our FREE weekly newsletter Print this article

Rush_Bluray.gifNobody is more critical than me about how the record industry has blown what was once a $33,000,000,000 per year domestic music business in the early 1990s and turned it into a low-resolution $11,000,000,000 business dominated by Apple's iTunes, MP3 files, ring tones and convenience over sound quality. With that said - I just found what I have been looking for (which isn't a U2 album but that would be good too) in the form of Rush's 25th Anniversary re-release of their epic, progressive rock record: Moving Pictures on Blu-ray, released by Mercury.

Additional Resources
• Read more original commentary in our Feature News section.
• See similar stories in our Music Industry News section.
• Explore even more stories in our Blu-ray Software News section.
• Search for a Blu-ray player to play the Rush Blu-ray on.

Moving Pictures is one of the best records of its genre including hit songs like "Red Barchetta," "Limelight," and "Tom Sawyer" as well as an overall concept to the record that makes the other songs more meaningful than the filler that is part of most other albums. The performance from the Canadian trio is absolutely fantastic if not historic. Nobody questions if Rush can play their instruments, but what's so absolutely fantastic about the Moving Pictures re-release is the fact that it comes with both a remastered Compact Disc of the record as well as a Blu-ray. A remastered CD of a record that I bought back in the day isn't going to get me to write a feature story about the album, but the additional Blu-ray is. This Blu-ray to me represents the way records should be sold today. There is a stereo mix, a 5.1 mix and a DTS Master Audio mix, much like you'd expect from a blockbuster Hollywood movie on Blu-ray. Uncompressed audio sounds much more like master tape than a lower resolution 16 bit Compact Disc and in casual comparisons between the CD and the Blu-ray - it's easy to hear that the Blu-ray is better sounding, more dynamic and more open.

Rush's Moving Pictures does do a few things wrong in that the packaging is in a traditional CD-style paper case, not in a Blue plastic box like you would expect from a Blu-ray disc. The navigation is a little tricky, especially if you are trying to get to the three HD music videos included on the disc. But for whatever the record does wrong - it does so many things right that you can finally see a path to why you'd buy your music back all over again.

Will studios embrace music on Blu-ray? I am not sure, as so many of the big label executives actually believe that you, the consumer, simply cannot hear the difference. You absolutely can. In return for higher resolution stereo and surround sound versions of our favorite records - we will trade out playing these Blu-ray discs in a copy-protected format. Compact Discs are not copy-protected, thus can easily be stolen as opposed to music on Blu-ray which is far harder to swipe.

How do you tell the labels that you love music in HD? Buy the disc or download the HD version of the album. I'd say in this case - buying the Blu-ray is better. Make Moving Pictures a success all over again, much like Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon on 5.1 SACD was a resounding success while almost every other DVD-Audio and SACD didn't sell nearly as well.

Back catalog records are very profitable for a label to sell in new formats, especially ones like Blu-ray. When the music business was cranking north of 30 billion per year domestically - back catalog CD sales made up close to 80 percent of the overall sales. Blu-ray alone likely can't return the music business back to 30 billion per year in sales, but it can help make up some of the losses, abate music piracy and pay tribute to the art recorded in the major labels' back catalogs. The truth is - all of the majors have their back catalogs just sitting there in 24 bit 96 kHz HD-Audio resolutions, but they don't think we will buy it from them. They think consumers only care about how many files they can cram onto an iPod Nano. That's crap. People care about music as well as audio quality and will pay for it. I am suggesting that you start by buying Rush's Moving Pictures re-release on Blu-ray.

Additional Resources
• Read more original commentary in our Feature News section.
• See similar stories in our Music Industry News section.
• Explore even more stories in our Blu-ray Software News section.
• Search for a Blu-ray player to play the Rush Blu-ray on.

  • Comment on this article

  • By JerseyBiker

I think one of the problems is that the last generation have grown up with MP3 music. Many of them do not realize they are listening to watered down music. Even many older people don't realize the difference. I have had people argue with me that MP3's are better than CDs or just as good. They probably have crappy systems and can't tell the difference. I do have an iPod Nano but I only use it when jogging, flying, on vacation or other times where I obviously can't take my surround system. I don't buy CDs very often now because my favorite genre is jazz. I have an extensive collection on CDs and vinyl. jazz doesn't go out of style. But on occasion I will buy something new or old on CD. Maybe when they come out with more Blu-Ray titles I'll start buying more often.

  • By Hipshot

I totally agree. I am afraid that if we don't support high quality audio, we will lose it. I admit I do buy the odd itunes song for my ipod to work out at the gym with. But I also just bought Dark Side Of The Moon and Dire Straits Brothers In Arms on sacd to play on my Oppo BDP-95. And the sound quality is second to none.

I will probably buy this Rush recording even though I am not a huge fan of the band but would be a good addition to my music.

Agreed with the above. I've been buying less and less CDs over the past decade or so, based on the fact they sound like crap due in part to the Loudness Wars (Rush's Vapor Trails is a prime suspect there). I've got a much larger budget these days and would very much like to amass a collection of good listening material, and like some others after the rise and fall of DVD-A and SACD, have gone back to vinyl. While not perfect and I certainly don't "celebrate" vinyl like some people out there, it's about all that's left. Music Industry, please bring us back into the 21st century for my options of music choices!

Agreed with the above. I've been buying less and less CDs over the past decade or so, based on the fact they sound like crap due in part to the Loudness Wars (Rush's Vapor Trails is a prime suspect there). I've got a much larger budget these days and would very much like to amass a collection of good listening material, and like some others after the rise and fall of DVD-A and SACD, have gone back to vinyl. While not perfect and I certainly don't "celebrate" vinyl like some people out there, it's about all that's left. Music Industry, please bring us back into the 21st century for my options of music choices!

  • By Hipshot

Wow! I just looked up this album. Only seven songs. And I only know two of them. Oh Well. I guess this album was a bit before my time.

I agree with this being a great move my the industry. Working in a record store, I can attest to this version outselling the standard CD/DVD edition. However, I doubt all the support for this one title will encourage more industry types to push forward more remasters like this. I could mention the Neil Young Archives box, which I imagine was also a success, but I can tell you most consumers were happier with the simple CD box, vs the DVD or Blu-Ray versions (too expensive or can't play it in my car were the excuses). There's Tom Petty's Damn the Torpedoes on Blu-Ray that I've seen sell maybe 2 times. There's the King Crimson 40th Anniversary albums that come with Hi-Res audio on DVD's that are selling on occasion, but only when the 30th anniversary CD's are not in stock along side them (meaning price is more of a deciding factor than the quality of the audio). There is already great options out there, but nobody buys them. The hi-res audio market is aimed at 40+ men with disposable income and home theaters. Most kids (16-25) with disposable income would rather throw it at $350+ Beats Studio headphones for their stolen MP3's on their idevice. No joke. At least vinyl has had a resurgence in interest, but even it probably pulls less than $1M a year for the majors. Plus, a lot of places won't carry LP's in stock due to the terms on returning the product (which is not an option), so it becomes a gamble for stores.

If hi-res audio ACTUALLY took off, I'd be its biggest supporter, but in the meantime, I just do my part to support it through the artists I like who are able to get their work released that way. I still support DVD-A and SACD when they happen. I still support vinyl. I definitely support Blu-Ray. I will always support CD. I do my best to talk up quality to the consumers in my store, but in the end, it's price and convenience that wins 99% of the time.

People still don't know what HD really means or what exactly a Blu-Ray player is capable of. That's not the consumers fault. The bog box stores of the world could be helping everyone if they'd actually sell the details of the equipment and inform the consumer rather than just trying to grab the cash for ANY purchase.

I am going against most by buying a state-of-the-art CD player, but which includes a USB dock, and several digital inputs to act as a DAC. I first used a Burmester 09 CDP, but switched over to a Wadi S7i with GNSC Statement mod. I can honestly tell you I get much better sound with just CD's, than most high rez downloads. But, then I can also do hi-rez with my MacBook Pro. But the Wadia is still king.

  • By Frans

Silently I hope that at least some of the kids that run around with the Dr. Dre Beats headsets and listen to stolen music on their idevices actually evolve into more discerning listeners as they get exposed to the massive sound quality differential. It will take wider adoption to help propel Blu-ray Audio into a large enough audience to make it worthwhile for the labels. Some already offer free-downloads of the ripped versions to stay competitive, but I would be curious as to what the ratio is between unique buyers of the Blu-Rau Audio discs to unique downloaders is (serial codes will help to ascertain this).

Either way, I have both Rush' "Moving Pictures" and Tom Petty's "Damn the Torpedoes" - the latter actually sounds as good or better than the prior!

I am not sure why we are not seeing multiple CDs worth of content on 1 Blu-ray, but assume it's teachnically possible if not econimically feasible due to the competing factors of purchase price and remastering cost. Either way, this is a great development that has been missing since the decline of DVD-A/SACD and I welcome it!

Thanks Jerry for this review and taking the time to point this release out!

  • By Frans

Silently I hope that at least some of the kids that run around with the Dr. Dre Beats headsets and listen to stolen music on their idevices actually evolve into more discerning listeners as they get exposed to the massive sound quality differential. It will take wider adoption to help propel Blu-ray Audio into a large enough audience to make it worthwhile for the labels. Some already offer free-downloads of the ripped versions to stay competitive, but I would be curious as to what the ratio is between unique buyers of the Blu-Rau Audio discs to unique downloaders is (serial codes will help to ascertain this).

Either way, I have both Rush' "Moving Pictures" and Tom Petty's "Damn the Torpedoes" - the latter actually sounds as good or better than the prior!

I am not sure why we are not seeing multiple CDs worth of content on 1 Blu-ray, but assume it's teachnically possible if not econimically feasible due to the competing factors of purchase price and remastering cost. Either way, this is a great development that has been missing since the decline of DVD-A/SACD and I welcome it!

Thanks Jerry for this review and taking the time to point this release out!

Post a Comment

You are encouraged to post your comments using Facebook on HomeTheaterReview.com. Simply sign in to your Facebook account below and post away.

Featured Audio-Video News

Are AV Retailers To Blame For Lofty High End AV Prices?

Are AV Retailers To Blame For Lofty High End AV Prices? -

The audio video has been in a state of flux or some time, splitting sales up between specialty dealers, big box stores, and online sellers. However, the dealers may have had more to do with this than they think.

Latest Music Industry

Digital Music Sales Overtake Physical Sales -

Well, it has finally happened. Digital distribution of music, encompassing both downloads and streaming, have overtaken physical sales of music for the first time in history. But this may not be all bad.

KEF Muon's Used to Play at The Who's Launch of Quadrophenia - The Director's Cut -

A new version of The Who's Quadrophenia has been made, and during the launch event where the tracks were premiered, KEF was there with the company's Muon speakers to provide the sound.

The Man Who Could Save HD Music Is Gone - A List of Who Could Be Next -

The music industry has been struggling for some time. And it will need innovative thinking and powerful individuals to turn it around. Jerry Del Colliano offers a few ideas of who those people could be.

For Once The Music Industry Got It Right With Rush's Moving Pictures Album on Blu-ray -

Audiophile music has been a bit of a battle to obtain. With the ease and convenience of MP3 downloads, it is hard to convince record labels to release an album on Blu-ray. That is why the re-release of Rush's Moving Pictures album is worth talking about.

B&W Announces Second Sound Sessions Event with Jeff Bridges -

Bowers & Wilkins continues the company's new agenda of bringing music to consumers in unique ways with the second Sound Sessions event, this time featuring an event with Jeff Bridges.

Bowers & Wilkins Announces First Sound Session with Tinie Tempah -

Bowers & Wilkins has launched an exciting new program to put fans in touch with musical artists so that they can experience and discuss music in a comprehensive way and in VIP style.

Selling HD Content To A Generation of Thieves That Honestly Don't Know Its Wrong To Steal -

There is a dynamic at work with audio and video content that might be funny if it wasn't so alarming. A lot of users haven't figured out the equation that if they obtain all of their entertainment for free, the entertainers don't have the money to make anything else.

The Rolling Stones in High Definition Exclusively from HDtracks.com -

The band has been around for almost five decades, but only now are classic tracks from the Rolling Stones being made available in high-definition digital downloads in the fidelity FLAC format, courtesy of ABKCO Records and HDtracks.com.

The Beatles Arrive on iTunes -

Given the prominence of the Beatles in modern music, one would have imagined the band would have made it to iTunes long ago. Then again, given the legal wrangling that has often surrounded the Fab Four, it's great that it hasn't taken longer.

Google Plans To Launch iTunes Competitor By December -

Google is already one of the world's most-used sites for finding information. Now Google is hoping to also become a top destination for finding and downloading music with its Google Music, designed to be a competitor to the current music download champ iTunes.