iAV Consumers Struggle With Online vs. Retail Debate

Subscribe to our FREE weekly newsletter Print this article

Amazon_AV_receiver_screenshot.jpgThe anger is palpable with many of the comments we see on HomeTheaterReview.com's review pages. A vocal group of consumers feel slighted by local brick and mortar retailers and are looking online for more value as a prolonged, three-year recession rages on. Enthusiasts want their AV fix, but without the power of the equity of their homes to finance, say, a $10,000 50-inch plasma like they could have back in 2004 - the motivations behind consumers are different now than they were even in 2007.

Additional Resources
• Read more original content like this in our Feature News section.
• See similar stories in our AV Dealers and Installers News section.
• Explore industry trade news from HomeTheaterReview.com.

It's no secret the profit margins that specialty AV dealers work on can be as high as 50 percent for some product categories like speakers and accessories. For video, margins are far less and sometimes below 10 percent these days in a warehouse club- and big box store-driven marketplace. In order to keep the doors open, the air conditioning on and the floor stocked with even a modest sample of products - a specialty dealer needs to make 25 to 35 percent margins selling products. Many retailers such as Best Buy struggle with their overhead versus, say, a Costco - even Blue Shirts cost money that Costco doesn't spend in a sales transaction. Specialty retailers often have ordering people, managers, and repair techs and mostly because of scale simply cannot run with the same efficiencies that nationwide chains benefit from. That doesn't mean that they are worthless as some readers on the Internet suggest that they are. Without specialty AV dealers - there are no in-store demos - and while the in-home demo from Internet dealers can definitely be compelling, it's not the same as being able to go into a good retailer and play with the top performing goodies. Both have their place in determining value in the buying decision.

Many specialty retailers also do themselves no favors with their behavior and business model. Few on the Internet can fault specialty dealers who morph into custom installers. Custom guys don't have to floor very much product other than the "just in time" inventory that they use on the jobs being installed at the time. With sources like AVAD, the HTSA and now even Amazon.com shipping direct to retailers at cost - they don't even really need to be authorized dealers for many of the products they sell. Custom installers can do retail sales but they often don't really care, as the transactions are very expensive and often lead to consumers buying used from the Internet or out of state to save sales tax. Custom installers scale their businesses back to core, high profit installation-based sales for people who don't have the savvy of the Internet buyer and it does their profit margins just fine.

Gone is the retail location, to be replaced by a warehouse. Gone is the $250,000 demo room because sexy install photos on an iPad sell to architects, designers and contractors just as well and at higher profit margins. Literally, specialty retailers are wooed to become custom installers because they can work less to make the same or more money with lower overhead and higher margins. While they are a key part of the top AV brand dealer distribution networks - some custom installers or appointment-only dealers can offend the hardcore enthusiasts as they stereotypically don't show or demo much (or any) product. Internet buyers don't like this but must understand the business model. At the same time, dealers who do floor a lot of products can be very hard to work with. One notable high end dealer went out of his way to attack me and our publication on Facebook recently. If he's out attacking publishers who create reviews for consumers to read FOR FREE and then come into his store - then I ask you, how would he treat you when you came into his audiophile salon? The answer: think Julia Roberts in Pretty Woman if she was shopping on Rodeo Drive for a pair of Sasha WPs. To me, his business model stinks just about as bad as his customer service, which is exactly why I didn't send him a very good personal friend of mine who is a top hedge fund manager. He literally doesn't deserve the referral nor is he getting it.

Internet retailers are eating up market share in this bad economy with "better than you can believe" prices on strong performing products. AV enthusiasts seek out the Outlaw Audios, Orb Audios, Oppo Digitals, Aperion Audios and other online retailers for fantastic value, high performance products and low prices that make the specialty stores look silly. But put price aside as these retailers don't have retail margins to worry about - what Orb, Aperion and Outlaw do that is so excellent is customer service. They bend over backwards to give the consumer a fantastic experience that beats out traditional brick and mortar retail - and for that they deserve the sale, loyalty and profit that they make. Orb Audio salespeople spend more time helping consumers make the right decisions about AV receivers, setting up a cable box or plugging in an Oppo player than they do selling their namesake speakers. And that's how it should be and they know it. Orb, like other top online retailers will go the extra mile to earn the client in ways that old-school stores and custom dealers often will not; thus they get the sale.

The truth is: online retail only represents about 20 percent of overall retail purchases but in the specialty AV world - their market share is getting larger and larger. At the same time - not all online retailers are created equal. Some sell flawed components at "unbelievable" prices to consumers who are asked to deal with unthinkable levels of grief. At the same time - you see a company like Outlaw Audio shelve their next-gen HDMI AV preamp before it shipped because it didn't meet their quality control and reliability standards despite the fact that the company had 5,000 orders (you do the math) waiting to be filled.

This type of high ethical standard is what all retailers should deliver. Clients are to be earned and nurtured. It's far harder to lose one than gain one. People who just walk in the door and ask to buy XYZ product at retail prices are not so much of a sale as they are an order. Building a relationship with consumers and offering them fair value gives a retailer the right to ask for the sale again and again. Fair customer service, top performing products and going the extra mile makes consumers want to refer their friends at time when it's harder today to sell anything to anybody. Too many customers buy only on price but none of them have given up on getting good customer service and value. Basically, whether he's buying online or at retail, the customer wants it all and one thing that hasn't changed in this prolonged recession is the fact that the customer is always right.

Additional Resources
• Read more original content like this in our Feature News section.
• See similar stories in our AV Dealers and Installers News section.
• Explore industry trade news from HomeTheaterReview.com.

  • Comment on this article

  • By Daryl Wall

As a Retailer with well over $1M worth of inventory displayed and operational in our professionally designed 5,000 sq. ft. boutique store I think that I want to address some of your comments in this article.

First of all I understand the allure of the "good deal" on the internet. And, quite frankly, from what I have seen on offer there, if that's where a person wants to do most of their shopping then they are probably not our customer anyway. Anyone who would buy sound (which is, after all, the business we are in... not gear but sound) without first listening to it probably deserves the "good deal" that they are getting. If one is basing their buying decisions on the reviews and opinions of others no matter how competent or detailed the review may be, then I question their wisdom, quite frankly. That said, if people want to spend money based on someone else's opinion that is certainly their right.

And that brings me to my second point: Please don't come into my store and take up my time and the time of my staff to set up a comprehensive demo for you, answer all your questions, swap out components for comparision, ask for a "best price deal," and then go and buy on the internet. As a matter of fact, please don't come into my store at all. You are not a customer, you are a shopper and a time waster and, frankly, I'd rather not speak to you.

Does that sound harsh? Well, consider this. My staff make up a significant portion of their income based on commission. When you come in to my store whether you are "just looking" (HEY!... We're not a freakin' museum!!!) or you are taking up my time and the time of my staff on a fact finding mission, you are, at worst, taking them away from other activities where they could be making money or, at best, getting their hopes up that you are actually a legitimate customer and then dashing those hopes when they find out that this is only an information gathering excursion so that you can spend money elsewhere. Imagine if, on a daily basis, your boss walked through your office with a couple of hundred dollars in his hand waving it under your nose as potential "bonus money" and then snatched it away 9 times out of 10 because he was actually intending all along to send it to another department altogether. Now you have a picture of what a time waster does to a professional sales person.

You talk about "earning business." I couldn't agree more. That is why we offer full installation and warranty service, including an aggressive loaner program and a legitimate, no charge, extended warranty and no-loss trade up program. But none of that seems good enough when all someone is interested in is price.

Now I get that there is a perception out there (as mentioned elsewhere in this week's edition of this very newsletter) that $2,000.00 is the new $20,000.00. But I am here to tell you it is a false perception. There is no $2,000.00 Receiver on the market that can hold a candle to a $20,000.00 Classe or McIntosh Pre/Power combo. The $2,000.00 projector that can even call itself a projector in the presence of a $20,000.00 Runco Q750 doesn't exist. And there sure aren't a pair of $2K speakers that wouldn't cower in front of a pair of $20K B&W 800s in full voice.

There is a PERCEPTION that you can get legitimate hi-fi for $2K but is it an illusion. Can you get more for $2K now than you could 5 or 10 years ago? Absolutely! But you can get a hell of a lot more for $20K now than you could 5 or 10 years ago too.

So, Mr. Internet shopper. Read your reviews. Talk to your friends. Get all the advise you want out there from anyone who will offer an opinion (and everyone has one!). And then go and buy your sound based on other people's opinions.

When you are ready, though, to spend your money on legitimate hi-fi, then visit the professionals at your local boutique and find out what real service is about.

  • By Vic Winkler

The audio business has changed as much as many other businesses have. One thing that I lament is there are fewer high end audio stores where I could listen to new gear or gear combinations. What I do like is that if I know what I want, I can get more for less.

Another thing I dislike INTENSELY is that this same drive toward lowering the price of audio gear means most of it is today manufactured where everything else seems to be made: In China.

I'm on a tear to support quality products made in the USA. Cost is an object, but there are enough great American made products in the audio space that I am still delighted! Sadly, few of them are available in stores.

  • By Rumproast

@ Daryl, I certainly agree with your comment regarding people coming into your store, asking lots of questions eating up your time and expertise to then turn around and buy said equipment online. It is frustrating at best as it happened often to a friend of mine.

Now your comment of "buying on other peoples opinions" I can understand and I am under the impression that your store is not a chain. With that said and if you choose what you sell in your store, then are you not selling people your opinion of good audio?

Post a Comment

You are encouraged to post your comments using Facebook on HomeTheaterReview.com. Simply sign in to your Facebook account below and post away.

Featured Audio-Video News

Are AV Retailers To Blame For Lofty High End AV Prices?

Are AV Retailers To Blame For Lofty High End AV Prices? -

The audio video has been in a state of flux or some time, splitting sales up between specialty dealers, big box stores, and online sellers. However, the dealers may have had more to do with this than they think.

Latest Feature News Stories

Are AV Retailers To Blame For Lofty High End AV Prices? -

The audio video has been in a state of flux or some time, splitting sales up between specialty dealers, big box stores, and online sellers. However, the dealers may have had more to do with this than they think.

How To Build and Equip Your Home Theater PC -

Home Theater PCs have become more and more popular as digital media becomes more streamlined. Andrew Robinson decided to build an HTPC from the ground up. Here's how it went.

How The DAC Got Its Groove Back -

With the advent of digital music and the easily portable nature of that format, the need for digital to analog convertors has grown and the DAC has made a journey to get to where it is today. This is that story of that journey.

The 10 Best Sounding Rooms from the New York Audiophile Show 2012 -

Jeremy R. Kipnis visited the 2012 New York Audiophile Show. He went room to room, seeing what the show had to offer. These ten rooms are what he deemed to be the best sounding systems and products presented.

How Does an OLED TV Work? -

OLED is one of the technologies that could begin the new era of HDTVs. That is all well and good, but how exactly does this new technology work and why is better than we have now?

Update On The Latest Video On Demand Technology -

Streaming technology is constantly evolving, bringing better content to your HDTVs faster in and in higher volumes. Adrienne Maxwell checks in on the technology to evaluate the state of the field.

Samsung Introduces Tube-Based Audio Products -

Samsung has stepped up its game in the audio realm, adding new table top audio systems, home theater systems, and soundbars. Adrienne Maxwell was in attendance at the Samsung event where the new products were announced.

Audiophilia's Future Looks Bright If Headphone Users Can Convert To Full Systems -

HomeTheaterReview.com publisher Jerry Del Colliano made a surprising discovery on Facebook that may show that their is hope for the youth of today to embrace the audiophile hobby.

Update: Kaleidescape Manages to Secure Stay of Injunction from Courts -

In yet another surprising turn, Kaleidescape has managed to secure a stay in their continuing appeal process regarding the legality and legitimacy of the company's media servers.

Kaleidescape Denied Stay In Court Appeal -

Kaleidescape was just dealt a huge blow by the California courts in their continued battle over the company's DVD media server systems. This time the news may not only be bad for the company, but the dealers and consumers as well.