Is Brighter Better? LED HDTVs Are Flying Off Of Store Shelves

Subscribe to our FREE weekly newsletter Print this article

LED_model_LG.gif

Anyone who reads home theater magazines or online publications knows the hot new thing is LED HDTV. Samsung and Toshiba are pushing them like mad and, despite the higher prices, people are lining up to buy them by the tens of thousands. This is a resounding success for a new video technology, especially considering how established plasma and LCD are in the consumer psyche today.

LED offers a number of key advantages over plasma and LCD.
• LED HDTVs use reportedly 40 percent less energy than do plasma HDTVs.
• LED HDTVs are physically light and therefore could be (though this is highly not recommended) hung on the wall like a picture. HomeTheaterReview.com recommends you use only the best mounting hardware for performance and safety.
• LED HDTVs are brighter than the beam coming out of the top of the Luxor.
• Reported contrast ratios on LED HDTVs are off the charts compared to those of any other video source today.

Retailers are ecstatic about LED as, in a recession-starved home theater market, LED is driving people in the doors to spend money on HDTVs that have some actual margin in them. Blame the fact that Costco and Wal-Mart will sell an HDTV to make $100, the key reason why Circuit City, Tweeter and The Good Guys went Chapter 7. For the time being, LED offers a chance to retailers who struggle to sell audio as a way to make a little money.

Consumers flip out for LED the second they see it. The main reason is because it is so bright. For those who haven't seen the technology in person: prepare yourself for a beamingly bright experience. The green angle only helps. The weight issue is nice, too, because a 60-inch plasma is, without question, a two-man job to hang.

Reviewers are torn about LED in these early days. Like consumers, we appreciate the brightness. However, to the trained eye, viewings of units like the popular Samsung 55-inch LED being sold at Best Buy suffer from many video maladies when looking past the WOW factor of the brightness. After an extended viewing session with the set, one respected reviewer noticed issues like macro blocking on fast-moving scenes. The level of grayscale is very limited, which negatively affects the black performance of early LEDs compared to LCD and plasma HDTVs in today's marketplace. The refresh rate (the 120 Hz and 240 Hz part the salesman is always talking about) often makes movies and sports look artificial and mechanical, despite the fact it's supposed to cure that malady. The lack of grayscale makes the image on Blu-ray movies often lack the level of low light detail that you will see on more developed LCD and especially on plasma HDTVs. If you are watching an LED to view the U.S. Open on a sunny day, it will look fantastic. On a Blu-ray copy of The Sopranos or a Jerry Bruckheimer film, you might struggle a little with the low-level lights.

Toshiba's first-generation LED offers a lot of promise to solve many of these video issues in the early goings of LED HDTVs, as we have had an early look at the Toshiba and the Samsung. Both sets are in for review at HomeTheaterReview.com this summer. Stay tuned for the full-feature, fully-calibrated reviews in the coming weeks.

LED HDTVs have all the potential in the world and are likely the future of a booming category of home theater products. They look great on daylight sources and are brighter than a supernova. This brightness lures the consumers in and makes them forget about a recession and this may be the strongest reason why LED could be the best format right now.

  • Comment on this article

  • By gabiernacki

There is no inherent reason why LED backlit LCD displays should produce a better static (native) contrast ratio than old cold cathode technologies. Although LED technology is better in dynamic mode because LED brightness can be dimmed faster, it cannot produce good blacks without also crushing whites in any static image unless local dimming is employed. Unfortunately the latest generations of LED backlit LCD displays shun local dimming apparently to improve profit margins.

  • By phillip

Now, if only there were some quality movies on TV. I have the FIOS system and have all the movie channels and there is just a bunch of re-runs on 97% of the time. I end up watching
documentaries on the History Channel or the Military Channel on my Marantz projection
system....IN BLACK AND WHITE!
No matter the technology we buy, its re-runs, re-runs and more re-runs.

  • By Dan

It doesn’t matter what back light it uses. It is still LCD with lousy black levels. Might look good in a bright room but turn off the lights, Sit off to the side a bit and it looks like crap.

  • By Steven

This is an incredibly misleading article. LED is not a new technology. It's no different than LCD technology, because that's exactly what it is. The difference is the back (or side) lighting. Samsung's "LED" line is a side-lighting LCD which looks worse than their rear LED TVs.

It's a marketing gimmick to call them "LED" and even a "new video technology." Call them what they are, LCD video display with LED light engine.

  • By su do

Whatever the technology, LED vs LCD vs PLASMA - the pictures do look different in the store side by side - watching the same exact video feed.

  • By whataboutit

You forgot another major (MAJOR) problem with current LED sets: Screen Uniformity. Online forums, consumer reviews, even professional reviews are abuzz with reports of mura (clouding) and flashlighting issues. These issues effectively ruin any gain in black levels and create PQ problems far worse than any other technology.

  • By whataboutit

You forgot another major (MAJOR) problem with current LED sets: Screen Uniformity. Online forums, consumer reviews, even professional reviews are abuzz with reports of mura (clouding) and flashlighting issues. These issues effectively ruin any gain in black levels and create PQ problems far worse than any other technology.

Post a Comment

You are encouraged to post your comments using Facebook on HomeTheaterReview.com. Simply sign in to your Facebook account below and post away.

Featured Audio-Video News

Are AV Retailers To Blame For Lofty High End AV Prices?

Are AV Retailers To Blame For Lofty High End AV Prices? -

The audio video has been in a state of flux or some time, splitting sales up between specialty dealers, big box stores, and online sellers. However, the dealers may have had more to do with this than they think.

Latest LED HDTV

How Does an OLED TV Work? -

OLED is one of the technologies that could begin the new era of HDTVs. That is all well and good, but how exactly does this new technology work and why is better than we have now?

SunBriteTV Smashes Price Barrier with Signature Series -

SunBriteTV officially brings the company's Signature Series to market, which will allow consumers to experience outdoor entertainment at a more affordable price than the company has ever offered before.

What New Features Should You Expect From 2012 HDTVs? -

4K and OLED and 3D have all been talked about as the next big technology for HDTVs, but what about the technologies that are already available on nearly every HDTV? The apps, the networking, and control technologies are all getting a makeover in 2012.

What Technology Will Save HDTV: OLED or 4K And At What Price? -

HDTVs have a vacancy at the top, where the high end lives. Now their are two technologies that could be vying for that top spot: OLED and 4K. But which one has the better chance to make it happen?

SunBriteTV Allows Users to Take the Game Outside with New Signature Line -

SunBriteTV has opened up the company's line of products to consumers with the introduction of a more affordable line of Signature products that will give consumers all the benefits of SunBriteTVs outdoor technologies.

Vizio Announces 2012 Line of HDTVs, Includes 21:9 and 3D Models -

Vizio is bringing something really big to the marketplace with their 2012 line of HD televisions. Literally. Vizio is releasing the company's new CinemaWide television line that features models with a 21:9 aspect ratio amongst other impressive features.

Samsung Unveils Super OLED HDTV -

Samsung has announced a brand new television that uses new technology to deliver great picture quality by utilizing the OLED technology, a first for the company and very rare at this screen size.

Is a Narrower Focus the Key to Survival for Some TV Manufacturers? -

It's hard to be in the television business right now. The market has seen a lot of new variables enter and had a few setbacks, which is definitely affecting the manufacturers - even the big ones.

LG Reveals Nano Full LED HDTV - the LW980S -

LG Electronics has given the first glimpse of their new LED HDTV that seems to have it all, the LW980S, which features fully backlit LED lighting as well as several other features that are in demand.

Insignia Unveils Connected TV with TiVo Design -

To adapt to the modern connected consumer, Best Buy's proprietary electronics line, Insignia, has come out with a new connected television that will allow customers to access apps and connect to online content.