JBL L1 Bookshelf Speakers Reviewed

  • By: HomeTheaterReview.com,

Subscribe to our FREE weekly newsletter Print this article

HTR Product Rating

Performance
3 Stars
Value
3 Stars
Overall
3 Stars

Disagree with our product rating? Email us and tell us why you think this product should receive a higher rating.

Page 1 | Page 2
JBL-L1-Reviewed.gif

Prejudice is a weird phenomenon. Are we all so vulnerable to the once-bitten-twice-shy system that we simply cannot deal with the rehabilitated? Hi-fi is riddled with brands which -- in the eyes of the British dealer/press/consumer -- can do no right, just as there are unworthy brands which many believe can do no wrong. JBL has, for a least a decade, been written off a domestic-audio-for-pro-wannabees, and the company has no-one to blame oter than itself. So successful is it in pro circles that it assumes that every playback system, regardless of type, warrants the kind of speakers which can loosen plaster while cutting glass. Unbreakable, yes. Brighter than an active arc-welder, ditto. Worse, they seem to embody all of the traits of America that allows psuedo-intellectual Aussies like Clive james to take the piss out of my homeland.

JBL'-ness' that allowntellectual Aussies (Aussies! The spawn of criminals!) like Clive J And JBL is as American as Levi 501s, making them the bane of Spendor/Rogers/Harbeth loversird phenomenon. Are we all so vulnerable to the once-bitten. But the times they are a'changin'.

Additional Resources

No, I haven't suddenly written off two decades as a resident of the UK. No, I'm not about to suggest that you ditch cricket for the equally mind-numbing baseball. But I buried my half-life as a Brit, my lust for Things Anglo such as LS3/5As and Lovejoy and KitKats to investigate the rumours that JBL has entered the 1990s. Indeed, so curious am I about this change of direction that I've signed up for a trilogy review as JBL is a three-headed-monster: domestic, pro and in-car. And, as I've spent the last ten months wallowing in nostalgia for my lost youth, I want to see if JBL is capable of reviving a latter-day equivalent of their best-selling speakers from the days I entered hi-fi as a civilian. What I want is a 1993 JBL Decade or Century.

So what do I find when I open the small (for JBL) L1 carton? A pair of speakers in one container, small enough to rest on 24in stands. Two-way, not three. Black ash finish. But with a couple of clues to suggest something other than a Britclone...even though metal dome drivers are a British institution. But these are titanium 1in domes with a diamond pattern stamped on to them to increase structural rigidity with no increase in mass. They rest on sloped baffles, above 6.5in woofers made from a paper-like composite of felt and glass-fibre, featuring concentric ribs. The frames are made from cast aluminium. Build quality? Terrific. Especially at £399 per pair.

The enclosure --401x209x254mm (HWD) -- betrays only one trace of resistance to modernity: the L1 isn't bi-wireable. The back contains the tuned port, with nice multi-way binding posts in a recess near the bottom.

Spec-wise, the L1 could be one of a number of standard two-ways available in the UK. The frequency response is listed as 47Hz-27kHz (+/-6dB), sensitivity is a sensible 87dB for 1W, impedance a safe 8 ohms and the power rating? An easy drive working well with 35-watters, yet it's capable of handling 200W. Remember: the three letters on the badge serve as a red rag to HM bulls. Even if you

crossing over at 3kHz to Oh, there is one other bone to pick: the drivers are not arrayed symmetrically., the tweeters offset to the left.ed rag to HM head-banging bulls. JBL could issue a telephone speaker and most of the faithful would expect it to yield 120dB at 10m. But that's the downside of having such a strong image, eg all Ford drivers can't really be boy racers, can they?

I left the grille for last because it's the one thing an L1 owner will play with for a few weeks. For some stupid reason, the designers gave it a bulge which, when positioned correctly, gives the slope-baffled L1 a perpendicular face. Unfortunately, the grille is braced with enough plastic for a 1/24th scale model of a Spitfire, and

Even worse, the area in front of the tweeter contains a tight grid which could double as a colander. And it doesn't half-bugger the dispersion. So I played them with the grilles mounted upside down. They even looked better that way...

On the other hand, there are strong arguments in favour of removing the grille altogether. In effect, it acts as a corrective filter with three positions:

1) Placed correctly, the speakers lose their sibilance, but the price you pay is a slight lack of detail and serious buggering of the imagery.

2) Placed upside-down, the tweeter is still tamed, but to a milder degree.

3) Removed, the speakers image like a dream, but then you have to worry about all that naked treble.

Which leads to amplifiers.

Page 1 | Page 2
  • Comment on this article

Post a Comment

You are encouraged to post your comments using Facebook on HomeTheaterReview.com. Simply sign in to your Facebook account below and post away.

Featured Audio-Video News

Are AV Retailers To Blame For Lofty High End AV Prices?

Are AV Retailers To Blame For Lofty High End AV Prices? -

The audio video has been in a state of flux or some time, splitting sales up between specialty dealers, big box stores, and online sellers. However, the dealers may have had more to do with this than they think.

Latest Bookshelf Speaker Reviews

Russound AirGo Powered Outdoor Speaker -

The AirGo from Russound is designed to work with Apple's AirPlay system. As Adrienne Maxwell discovered during her review, the AirGo offers an incredibly amount of convenience. But does it offer performance?

Wharfedale Jade 1 Bookshelf Loudspeaker Reviewed -

Wharfedale has been a big name in England for some time now, but, given the findings of Andrew Robinson's review, the Jade 1 bookshelf speakers should make the company's name known far and wide.

Living Sounds Audio (LSA1) Statement Monitor Reviewed -

Terry London was on the hunt for a reasonably priced bookshelf speaker that would deliver on the performance aspect as well. He found it in the Living Sound Audio LSA1 Statement Monitor.

HSU Research HB-1 MK2 Bookshelf Loudspeaker Reviewed -

HSU Research's HB-1 MK2 bookshelf speakers are cheap. However, they are also good. How good? Well read on to find out what Andrew Robinson had to say about the HB-1 MK2's performance.

Episode 900 Series ES-HT900-LCR-6 Loudspeaker Reviewed -

Great things can come in small packages. The Episode 900 Series ES-HT900-LCR-6 bookshelf loudspeakers seems to be one of these things according to Andrew Robinson's findings.

Focal Diablo Utopia Speakers Reviewed -

Focal's Diablo Utopia bookshelf speakers combine beauty with performance. HomeTheaterReview.com publisher Jerry Del Colliano put the Diablo Utopia speakers through quite a few tests during the course of his review. Find out how they did.

Focal Bird 2.1 System Reviewed -

Andrew Robinson took Focal's new Bird 2.1 system under his wing for review. He ran the Bird system through a battery of different tests to find out how well these little speakers could perform in any situation that may be asked of them.

Home Theater Review's 2011 Best Of Awards -

For a third time, the editorial staff of Home Theater Review have examined the year's offerings in AV gear and decided what they deem to be the best in every category. Find out who is the best of the best.

Paradigm Mini Monitor v.7 Loudspeaker Reviewed -

Paradigm has updated the Mini Monitor bookshelf speaker again with the v.7. The appearance has been notable updated, but what about the performance? Andrew Robinson takes a listen to find out.

Clarity HD Model One High Definition Multi-Media Speaker Monitor Reviewed -

Monster has created the Clarity HD One multi-media speakers which have an iPod dock built right into the speaker. Brian Kahn takes a look at the speakers to see what else they have to offer.