Melody SP3 Amplifier Reviewed
- By: Ken Kessler
- - Reviewer's System
- Category:
- Audio Reviews, Equipment Reviews, Stereo Amplifier Reviews
- Resources & Links:
- Melody
- October 25, 2008

In a world awash with sub-$2000 Chinese-made tube amps, it takes a lot to make one that stands out from the crowd. Some champions have already emerged, especially the PrimaLunas, but there's an overwhelming sense of "so what?" to the genre.
Then something grabs you, as Melody's SP3 grabbed me. It is a non-sequitur, resembling only one slightly dearer model in the range, and it's very much entry-level: integrated, minimal facilities, small footprint, small price tag. The rest of the catalogue is decidedly more up-market.
As ever, the first thing about a component that either seduces or repels is the looks. With the SP3, it's so butch yet so adorable that you want to take it home and put it on a shelf full of either scale model Hummers or stuffed toys. Its footprint of only 11.9 by 8.1 by 13.25 inches (W/H/D) takes up barely two-thirds the space of an LP sleeve. Colored titanium gray, it oozes macho presence from its solid aluminum face plate to the hardware on top.
If this were a teenager, it would be a heavily-pierced Goth. The curved front is so carved from solid heavy metal that you have to chuckle at its Spinal Tap insouciance. Containing an impressive 10 valves - four 5881 output tubes and two each of 12AX7, 12AU7 and 6922 for preamp and driver duties - the SP3 uses a nifty mix of an easy-to-remove perforated valve cage for the output tubes and six delightfully old-fashioned slip-on sleeves to protect the glassware.
Minimalism defines the facilities and controls. The front panel contains only a volume rotary and pilot light. On-off is a rocker switch on the left side, while you can choose between its two inputs with a rocker on the right. On the rear panel are multi-way speaker terminals that allow you to choose between four or eight ohms, phono inputs and an IEC mains input. Interestingly, given the paucity of features, the unit does offer user-adjustable bias facilities on either side of the unit.
Despite this simplicity and the need to keep an eye on costs, corners do not appear to have been cut. It has robust, gold-plated terminals and sockets, the volume control is a proper 24-step switched attenuator, there's a mix of hard-wiring and PCBs inside and the unit delivers a sensible 36 watts per channel, enough to work the PMC DB1+ and the Tannoy Autograph Minis in a 12- by 18-foot room.
Blatantly, this unit has no issues with punching above its weight. In terms of both SPLs and bass response, it sounds like a bigger amplifier; I wouldn't have registered any surprise if someone told me it carried four 6550s. Its grunt will drive most "usual suspect" two-way speakers, its affinity with the PMCs promising an audiophile-satisfying system for under £2000.
What raises it above China's budget brigade is surprisingly grown-up detail and clarity. The re-mastered Doors catalogue - especially Strange Days (Elektra/Rhino 8122 79998 4) - offers a gourmet feast of previously unheard mixes: missed vocals, guitar fills, etc. The SP3 handles low-level information with such aplomb that it suggests an almost magical handling of residual noise. Even without tweaking - no tube dampers, no trick stands or feet - the SP3 demonstrated almost exactly the finesse I expect to sacrifice at this price.
Jim Morrison's familiar vocals, part husky, part liquid, enjoyed substantial body and presence, free of artifice. Sibilance was negligible, warmth was a given. You just gotta love it. Julie London's voice, followed by something from the other extreme - "Teenage Dirtbag" by Wheatus - identify this as an amp for those who adore vocal textures. Scarily, its mid-band is almost LS3/5A-worthy: accurate, clear, revelatory.
Beyond that, this little bugger actually rocks. With "Hello I Love You," the charging bass lines, militaristic drumming and cheesy organ revealed a rhythm section that never earned the plaudits it deserved. Those with taste love the Doors as a band that complimented Jim Morrison to a "T." But the new recordings remind us that Ray Manzarek, Robbie Krieger and John Densmore were/are sublime musicians, producing licks rarely heard on other works of the period. Melody's smallest allows the instruments to form a cohesive whole, while providing enough openness and clarity to allow you to focus on one virtuoso at a time.
This makes a voyage with the SP3 one of discovery. You'll have to pinch yourself and recall that we are dealing with a product costing under $1800. Its very few demerits are so euphonic, non-aggressive or non-intrusive that the compromises are no worse than going from a wine specialist Nero D'Avola to one from a supermarket. Some softness on transients, some bass flabbiness, a trace of confusion on overtly complex pieces - that's the sum of its misdemeanors.
Let's take it further: pair this with some daft under-$100 DVD player used just for CD, or an iPod, plus any decent $500-per-pair UK-made two-ways, and you have a truly enjoyable system for well under $3000. In a year's time, you can upgrade the source or the speakers, and the SP3 will just say, "Bring it on." In other words, unlike with Chinese food, you won't feel hungry an hour later.
Melody has dialed in something most hi-fi manufacturers (and users) have forgotten: fun. This little amp is like the Little Engine That Could. It's cute, feisty and it gets the job done. It has seriously tough rivals from PrimaLuna, along with umpteen entry-level Chinese amplifiers, but its looks, feel, apparent build quality, more-ish sound and irresistible price make this a guaranteed short-list habitué.
About Melody Valve Hi-Fi
Melody Valve Hi Fi Pty Ltd. was founded by Allen Wang, now president & CEO, in 1999. It's very much a part of the "new era" valve amp manufacturers, rather than one of the hangovers from the time when all such ventures were government-owned.
Melody describes itself as specializing in the "design and making of high-end acoustic equipment and devices, such as classic electronic vacuum valve amplifiers, CD players, CRT test rejuvenators, etc." It's also a multi-national concern, with headquarters and R&D in Australia.
Recently, the company showed its commitment to playing on the same field as the big boys by investing in a purpose-built factory in Shenzhen. Production facilities occupy 10,000 square feet, and it houses modern assembly lines, in-house transformer production (mains and output transformers), high-end testing facilities, burn-in rooms, paint-shops for the chasses and shipping. So, for those of you charmed by their offerings, forget any images of amps made in sheds.
- Anthem 225 Integrated Amplifier...
- Arcam Solo Integrated Amp and C...
- Audio Research REF 110 Power Am...
- Ayre Acoustics MX-R Monaural Po...
- Bryston 2B SST Stereo Amplifier...
- Cambridge Audio Azur 840W Ampli...
- Cary Audio Xciter Integrated Am...
- Classe Audio CA-M400 Mono Ampli...
- Classe' Audio CA-M400 Mono Ampl...
- Copland CTA405 Integrated Ampli...
- Decware SE84C+ Zen Triode Stere...
- Halcro dm38 Stereo Power Amplif...
- Krell Evolution 600 Mono Power ...
- Krell Evolution 900 Monaural Po...
- Krell FBI Integrated Amplifier ...
- Krell KAV-400xi Integrated Ampl...
- Marantz PM-KI-Pearl Integrated ...
- Marantz PM5003 Integrated Ampli...
- Mark Levinson No. 436 Monaural ...
- Mark Levinson No. 53 Monaural P...
- McIntosh MC275 Stereo Power Amp...
- McIntosh MC501 Monaural Power A...
- Melody SP3 Amplifier Reviewed...
- Musical Fidelity Supercharger 5...
- NAD C 725BEE Stereo Receiver Re...
- NAD C315BEE Stereo Integrated A...
- NAD C325BEE Stereo Integrated A...
- NuForce Icon / S1 Amplifier Rev...
- NuForce Reference 9 V2 Special ...
- Outlaw Audio RR2150 Stereo Rece...
- Parasound Halo JC 1 Monaural Am...
- PrimaLuna 3 and 4 Tube Power Am...
- Quad II-eighty Tube Amplifier R...
- ROTEL RB-1092 Amplifier Reviewe...
- Stereo, Mono and Audiophile Amp...
- Theta Intrepid Amp Reviewed...
Today's Top Story
AV's Next and Biggest Generation of Clients Deeply Affected By Unemployment and Under-employment -
Baby Boomers have been the driving force behind both the audiophile business and most of the two-decade long rise in popularity of home theater. Economically for Boomers there have been far more good times than bad, with recessions feeling more... Click for more...
Latest Stereo Amplifier Reviews
Cambridge Audio Azur 840W Amplifier Reviewed -
Many companies try to walk the line between affordability and high-end performance, with few ever really being able to deliver both equally well. Cambridge Audio is a company that has been rather successful at delivering products that perform better than... Click for more...
Marantz PM-KI-Pearl Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Marantz's reference line-up of products may not be as well known as its more mass-market offerings, i.e. receivers and sources, but they are still highly regarded in many circles and have garnered many critical accolades. The newest additions to Marantz's... Click for more...
Marantz PM5003 Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
The Marantz PM5003 integrated amplifier (SRP: $449.99) is a sleek, stylish audio component that delivers outstanding sound quality to music lovers and audiophiles looking for good sound on a budget, or who are putting together a second-room, summer home or... Click for more...
Cary Audio Xciter Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
The Cary Audio Xciter vacuum tube integrated amplifier is one of those products that makes me take a step back and question the decisions I've made in building my system. Don't get me wrong, I am very happy with the... Click for more...
Anthem 225 Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Integrated amps have always made a great deal of sense to me. A good integrated can get you all of, if not better, performance then their separate siblings, save you a bit on cables and shelf space and cost less... Click for more...
Outlaw Audio RR2150 Stereo Receiver Reviewed -
One might be tempted to call the Outlaw Audio RR2150 reviewed here an integrated amplifier, however, no integrated amp retailing direct for $699 has a built in MM/MC phono stage, USB input, tuner, subwoofer output, and true bass management. While... Click for more...
Decware SE84C+ Zen Triode Stereo Amplifier Reviewed -
In a world dominated by megawatt amplifiers and HDMI conversion what am I doing reviewing a SET (Single Ended Triode) tube amplifier from a boutique manufacturer named Decware? The SE84C+ is the continuation of Decware's first ever amplifier the SE84C,... Click for more...
NAD C 725BEE Stereo Receiver Reviewed -
The NAD C 725BEE stereo receiver is the type of product that I am naturally drawn to by a company that figures strongly in my history. Most of my college years were spent with a NAD receiver providing the soundtrack.... Click for more...
McIntosh MC275 Stereo Power Amplifier Reviewed -
McIntosh Laboratories is one of those select companies that have achieved legendary status among audiophiles and discerning listeners. Established in 1949, McIntosh was one of the founders of the high-fidelity audio industry, along with companies like Marantz, Harman Kardon, Fisher,... Click for more...
Theta Intrepid Amp Reviewed -
So dazzling was Theta's first amplifier, the Dreadnaught, that I ended the March, 2000 review with, "It's a ******g masterpiece." But there was a catch, price aside: the Dreadnaught measures an absurd 17.75x8.5x24in deep including the fittings. In my lounge,... Click for more...
Latest Stereo Amplifier Reviews
Cambridge Audio Azur 840W Amplifier Reviewed -
Many companies try to walk the line between affordability and high-end performance, with few ever really being able to deliver both equally well. Cambridge Audio is a company that has been rather successful at delivering products that perform better than... Click for more...
Marantz PM-KI-Pearl Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Marantz's reference line-up of products may not be as well known as its more mass-market offerings, i.e. receivers and sources, but they are still highly regarded in many circles and have garnered many critical accolades. The newest additions to Marantz's... Click for more...
Marantz PM5003 Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
The Marantz PM5003 integrated amplifier (SRP: $449.99) is a sleek, stylish audio component that delivers outstanding sound quality to music lovers and audiophiles looking for good sound on a budget, or who are putting together a second-room, summer home or... Click for more...
Cary Audio Xciter Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
The Cary Audio Xciter vacuum tube integrated amplifier is one of those products that makes me take a step back and question the decisions I've made in building my system. Don't get me wrong, I am very happy with the... Click for more...
Anthem 225 Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Integrated amps have always made a great deal of sense to me. A good integrated can get you all of, if not better, performance then their separate siblings, save you a bit on cables and shelf space and cost less... Click for more...
Outlaw Audio RR2150 Stereo Receiver Reviewed -
One might be tempted to call the Outlaw Audio RR2150 reviewed here an integrated amplifier, however, no integrated amp retailing direct for $699 has a built in MM/MC phono stage, USB input, tuner, subwoofer output, and true bass management. While... Click for more...
Decware SE84C+ Zen Triode Stereo Amplifier Reviewed -
In a world dominated by megawatt amplifiers and HDMI conversion what am I doing reviewing a SET (Single Ended Triode) tube amplifier from a boutique manufacturer named Decware? The SE84C+ is the continuation of Decware's first ever amplifier the SE84C,... Click for more...
NAD C 725BEE Stereo Receiver Reviewed -
The NAD C 725BEE stereo receiver is the type of product that I am naturally drawn to by a company that figures strongly in my history. Most of my college years were spent with a NAD receiver providing the soundtrack.... Click for more...
McIntosh MC275 Stereo Power Amplifier Reviewed -
McIntosh Laboratories is one of those select companies that have achieved legendary status among audiophiles and discerning listeners. Established in 1949, McIntosh was one of the founders of the high-fidelity audio industry, along with companies like Marantz, Harman Kardon, Fisher,... Click for more...
Theta Intrepid Amp Reviewed -
So dazzling was Theta's first amplifier, the Dreadnaught, that I ended the March, 2000 review with, "It's a ******g masterpiece." But there was a catch, price aside: the Dreadnaught measures an absurd 17.75x8.5x24in deep including the fittings. In my lounge,... Click for more...
Latest Equipment Reviews
Definitive Technology UIW 75 In-Wall Speaker Reviewed -
One of the primary functions of a first-rate in-wall speaker is its ability to disperse superb high-end audio to every part of the room, no matter where the speaker itself is placed. The design team at Definitive Technology knows just... Click for more...
Outlaw Audio ECS-10 Subwoofer Reviewed -
A major problem in the past with small and compact subwoofers was their inability to deliver strong and deep low-end to the average soundstage. Outlaw Audio's design team was well aware of this challenge when they started developing the ECS-10... Click for more...
Toshiba REGZA 46SV670U LED LCD HDTV Reviewed -
LED backlighting is the way of the future for LCD televisions. Most of the top-selling LCD manufacturers now offer at least one line that uses LED backlighting. Some of these models only place the LEDs around the edges of the... Click for more...
Energy ESW-V10 Subwoofer Reviewed -
Energy is an audio manufacturer that is fairly well known for developing quality speakers at a mid-range price and now they are slowly getting into producing a more high-end subwoofer product line starting with the ESW-V10. The list price for... Click for more...
JVC LT-42X899 42-Inch LCD HDTV Reviewed -
If you have been looking for an HDTV that eliminates pesky motion blur while viewing action-packed Blu-ray discs, you should be very interested in what JVC is calling their "Clear Motion Drive III" technology. That technology is integrated into their... Click for more...
Vizio VT420M 42-Inch LCD HDTV Reviewed -
Vizio has been hard at work designing their full product line of HDTV's to compliment every consumer's desire to own a high-quality HDTV for less than almost any other A/V manufacturer around. This well-designed HDTV retails for just under $1,000... Click for more...
Yamaha BD-S1065 Blu-ray Player Reviewed -
Yamaha recently added two new models to its Blu-ray lineup. The BD-S1065 is the least expensive of the two, priced at $599.95. We have not performed a hands-on review of the BD-S1065, but here is an overview of the player's... Click for more...
Mitsubishi Diamond Unisen LT-46249 LCD HDTV Reviewed -
The Diamond Unisen 249 Series is Mitsubishi's highest-end LCD line for 2009 and therefore is loaded with the company's most advanced technologies and features. The line includes screen sizes of 46 and 52 inches. We have not performed a hands-on... Click for more...
Sony BDP-N460 Blu-ray Player Reviewed -
The newest addition to Sony's Blu-ray line is a Profile 2.0 player that offers a wide variety of Internet-based media options. Its $249.99 MSRP puts it at the lower end of the price spectrum for Sony players. We have not... Click for more...
Kaleidescape Mini System Music and DVD Server -
The easier it is to enjoy your movie and music software, the more you will reap from the collection. If you don't believe me, just count the number of iPods you see in a day. Having the disc you want... Click for more...





Comment on this article
0Post a Comment