Nagra VPA Amplifier Reviewed
- By: Ken Kessler
- - Reviewer's System
- Resources & Links:
- Stereo Amplifiers ,
- View Ken Kessler's Reviews
- January 11, 2009
By now - 15 years before the mast(head) - most regular readers know what pushes my buttons. So is it any wonder that reviewing the Nagra VPA all-tube power amplifier is one project for which I was prepared to fight? It's right up there with the Finial turntable, the Sonus Faber Amati, the Marantz valve reissues and the Audio Research Reference components in sheer 'wantability' or curio value, and even a jaded old whore like yours truly can still get it up
£8495, though, isn't quite the price I expected. Eight-and-a-half grand is serious money by any standards, but I would not have been surprised if this most enticing of products had a five-figure price tag. No, I'm not spending your money for you; I'm just being realistic. If you factor in Swiss-ness, Nagra-ness and any other 'ness' you care to name, you'll see that the VPA has the prestige, pedigree and - as will clearly emerge - performance which make it a high-end product worthy of high-end prices.
For the Nagra faithful, it means no more waiting for a mate to the PL-P pre-amp, the jewel which started this particular DNA strain. There it was, an all-valve pre-amp from a company with (1) no track record for tubeware, (2) no patience for audiophiles and (3) the sort of reputation enjoyed only by makes which deal exclusively with the professional sector. In Nagra's case specifically, it is supremacy in the fields of on-location tape recorders (a film-industry standard, in fact), spy tape recorders, satellite broadcast receivers and other niches light-years away from the audiophile tendency.
Stuffy Swissness, though, turned out to be more flexible than any could have imagined. When both the US high-end community responded enthusiastically to the company's digital open-reel AND one of the Nagra's designers felt that he needed a new phono stage, the PL-P was born. Success way beyond Nagra's expectations - the Swiss seem sceptical and mildly pessimistic if nothing else - led to further involvement with pure audio, hence the VPA.
Now let's not get too carried away here with Nagra's seeming conversion to the ranks of the Good Guys. The company is still subject to Swiss behavioural patterns, high-end audio will forever remain a teensy part of its output and Nagra exposed a truly conservative streak by producing - as an alternative for or sop to conservatives - a solid-state power amplifier as well...just in case Nagra started to appear to 'radical'. But R&D Manager Schlup remains a rebel in Swiss terms, which explains the VPA's topology.
While the PL-P at least resembled a Nagra tape deck sans spindles, the VPA looks like no other amplifier on earth - let alone a Nagra product. And that's despite the prominence of one of the company's trademark gauges on each chassis, as specific a giveaway of something's origins as, say, a black horse on a yellow background.
Amusingly (and in keeping with the Swiss' reputation for secretive banking practices), the VPA is deceptive in so many ways, starting with the valve complement. Per amplifier, the tube line-up consists of two ECC83s and a Mullard ECC82 in the input section and two 845 output tubes. More to the point, those 845s stand proudly and shamelessly on the top plate. And yet, despite the VPA featuring a brace of the cherished triodes which are probably second only in popularity to the 300B for pure SET credibility, it is
The transformer complement? Proprietary designs conceived to avoid low-frequency saturation and high frequency ringing, two mains and one output toroidal per unit, placed at the bottom of the cabinet to aid the centre of gravity and positioned vertically because the case is so narrow. And the 110x300x370mm (WDH) machined-from-solid aluminium cabinet
In reductio, it's a pure Class-A design rated at 50W into 4, 8 or 16 ohm loads, suffering zero negative feedback. The 845s are, of course, directly-heated, thoriated tungsten triodes, the input impedance is 100k ohms, and the sensitivity 400mV for its rated output into all three impedances. An abundance of protection circuitry and overkill construction do not obscure the realisation that the VPA presents a clean path for the signal. But then you notice the details which remind you why you went Swiss. The front panel, for example, bears a pro-grade, three-position rotary switch providing on, off and mute in-between, its style and feel identical to the rotaries on the P-LP. The Nagra meter? This time it's called, instead of a 'modulometer', the Nagra Load Match Meter, and it monitors the operation of the 845s by indicating peak DC voltage and current draw on the output tube anode. Nagra says that this makes it easy to 'spot speaker mismatch (sic) and suggest corrective action.'
In keeping with pro sensibilities, the VPA is fully balanced throughout, hence an XLR-only input on the back panel. I was able, however, to try the VPA with all manner of pre-amps, including the non-XLR'd PL-P, because Nagra supplied a phono-to-XLR adaptor. It does, however, provide proof that the Swiss are not infallible. How else do you explain this company making a pre-amp fitted only with single-ended outputs, while its matching power amp arrives with balanced-only inputs?
Below the XLR socket is a bank of multi-way gold-plated binding posts, enough to provide specific connection for each of the three main impedance choices, while beneath the socket array are vents for the tubes' heat and an IEC mains input and primary on/off rocker switch. And if the VPA's tall aspect and tiny footprint raise questions of physical stability, the weighting of the chassis toward the bottom not being enough to convince you of its steadiness, note that the amp comes supplied with aluminium struts to bolt to the underside to prevent rocking from side-to-side, even on a carpeted surface.
Mere minutes were all it took to realise that the VPA lived up to its promise. However high the PL-P raised the bar to which a matching power amp must leap, however difficult an act it was to follow, Nagra responded with an amplifier that will never shame it. While I probably missed stretching its performance to extremes as regards speaker loading - long gone are my Apogee Scintillas, alas - I did manage to test it from high to low sensitivities, with impedances of 4, 8 and 15 ohms. Additionally, I am no headbanger, so absolute SPL extraction was mild, too. And yet I have no reason to discount Nagra's claims that this is one 845-equipped amplifier that is not subjected to the classic situation of 'low-power vacuum tube amplifiers (which) seldom drive difficult speaker loads with success.'
Sadly, in light of both its recent demise and exhortations from speaker manufacturers to cease and desist in recommending it, I must downplay the merits of a most deliriously perfect mate for the VPA. With a witness in the form of the Nagra importer, who will attest to the blissful synergy, I learned that the VPA took to the Rogers LS3/5A as Lewinsky did to Clinton. Which is not to say that it blew it.
Because the LS3/5A is known for its refusal to go loud without suffering major damage, it did not tax the VPA's output capability. Nor did it show - as did the Wilson WATT/Puppy 5.1 set-up - that the Nagra has the sort of bass control of which Ongaku owners can only dream. But the LS3/5A so honoured the Nagra's midband, that R.T. Services' Robert Purnell left that day shaking his head and muttering something about 'combing the classifieds'.
Every trace of detail, presented on a bed of warmth like artichoke hearts on rocket, attested to the VPA's commanding and authoritative presentation. It's as if Nagra's designers made a conscious effort to exploit the brand's professional virtues without ignoring the subjective values of typical high-end audio listeners. In this respect alone, juggling accuracy and musicality, I feel that the VPA has no peers at or near its price. In fact, the only valve amps I know of which possess this prowess to the same degree are either five times the price or long out of production. To sample this quality, try recordings like Big Daddy's 'With A Little Help From My Friends' and any of Classic Records' 96/24 titles. It's undeniable.
However much the VPA reflects the 'smallness' of the PL-P pre-amp and its portable, tape-recording siblings, the amplifier continues to deceive by always sounding like a big brute. Not SPL big, but dimensionally big, and speakers like the LS3/5As and the WATTs rise to the occasion because their point source delivery allows them to disappear, thus enhancing the illusion. If you've ever met one of those who refuses to believe that sound can extend beyond the outer edges of the speakers, insist that he hears the VPAs driving something teensy.
Although the VPA parts company with Nagra practice by not being battery-driven and portable, by containing valves and being aimed primarily at the hi-fi community, it is very much a product of a company overwhelmingly respected in the professional sector. Thus, you can think of it as either a sensible/practical buy in the way that you'd choose, say, a SAAB over a TVR, or you can regard it as sheer audiophilic self-indulgence, in the way that you'd choose the TVR over the SAAB.
Unsurprisingly, the Nagra VPA joins the two other valve amplifiers in my permanent wants list, the Audio Research Ref 600 and the Marantz Project T1. Beyond the fact that all wear tubes, they have little in common, representing as they do three different approaches to the same task: driving speakers with tubes. But the VPA - while it will never drive certain speakers the way the ARC will, nor elicit oohs and aahs in the manner of the T1 - costs so little that you could actually set up a five-channel home theatre using all VPAs and spend less than you would for a pair of either of the others.
Pinch me: I'm actually calling a Nagra product a
RT Services, 118 Mendip Heights, Didcot, Oxfordshire OX11 7TG. Tel 01235 810455; FAX 01235 810324
Sidebar:
True to his word, Herr Schlup succumbed to the pressures of protecting the VPA's valves (CE regs and all that) by creating a cover of sorts to prevent accidents. And, in the best Nagra form, he developed one of the canniest, most clever alternatives to the 'ugly cage syndrome' that one can imagine.
Each 845 is now surrounded by two concentric arrays of vertical rods, mounted to the top plate and extending above the tubes. These obviously prevent any accidental knocks from taking out an 845, but what's more interesting is the way they deal with heat. As the rods are sufficiently distanced form each other, there's plenty of space through which air can flow. But, because Nagra fitted two layers of rods, the outer ring stays cool while only the inner gets hot. The latter aids heat dissipation, the former keeps you from burning your fingers. Simple, neat and oh, so effective.
Keywords
Nagra VPA Amplifier Reviewed, Nagra, Tube amps
- Audiovalve Baldur 70 Amplifier...
- Ayre AX-7 Power Amp Reviewed...
- EAT Valves Reviewed...
- Musical Fidelity X-Pre Preamp ...
- Sonus faber Gravis Subwoofer r...
- WAVAC Amp Reviewed ...
- AMC CVT 3030 Integrated Amp Rev...
- AMC CVT 3030 Tube Integrated Am...
- Adcom GFP 555 II Preamp and GFA...
- Air Tight ATC-1 Preamp and ATM-...
- Arion Nemisis Power Amp Reviewe...
- Armonia Integrated Amp reviewed...
- Audio Analogue Maestro Settana ...
- Audio Note Conquest Amp Reviewe...
- Audio Note Gaku-On Monoblock Po...
- Audio Research CA-50 Integrated...
- Audio Research Reference 600 Po...
- Audio Research VS55 Power Amp R...
- Audio Research VSi55 Integrated...
- Beam Echo Tube Amp Reviewed...
- Beard Audio BB100 Tube Power Am...
- Cadence PRE2 Preamp and MA2 Pow...
- Carver Silver Seven Mono Vacuum...
- Cello Audio Palette, Performanc...
- Classe DR-5 Preamp and DR-5 Pow...
- Classe Thirty Preamp and the Se...
- Conuterpoint SA-1000 Preamp and...
- Copland CSA 29 Integrated Amp R...
- Copland CSA14 integrated amplif...
- Copland CTA 401 Integrated Ampl...
- Counterpoint SA-12 Power Amp Re...
- Croft Series 3 Power Amplifier ...
- Croft Series V Power Amplifier ...
- Croft Series V-C Amp reviewed...
- Dynaco Stereo 70 Tube Amp Revie...
- EAR Paravicini M100A/312 Tube A...
- EAR V-20 Amp Reviewed...
- Einstein Power Amp Review...
- Esoteric Audio Research (E.A.R....
- Fase Nimis Integrated Amp Revie...
- GRAAF GM20 Power Amp Reviewed...
- Graff GM 200 Amplifier Reviewed...
- Graff GM50B Integrated Amp Revi...
- Gryphon Callisto 2200 Integrate...
- Gryphon Callisto 2200 Integrate...
- Gryphon DM100 Dual Mono Amplifi...
- Halcro dm58 Monoblock Amp Revie...
- Jadis JPS8 Preamp and JA50 Powe...
- Krell KAV-250a and KAV-250p Rev...
- Krell KAV-300i Integrated Amp r...
- Krell MD-20 CD Transport, Krell...
- LOTH-X JI-300 Amp Reviewed...
- Lecson Quattra Integrated Amp R...
- Linn Classik Movie System with ...
- Marantz Model 7 Reviewed...
- Marantz PM54 SE Integrated Ampl...
- Marantz SC-7S1 Preamp and MA-9S...
- McIntosh MA6900 Integrated Amp ...
- McIntosh MC 275 Power Amp Revie...
- McIntosh MC2000 Power Amp Revie...
- Metaxas Opulence Preamp and Sol...
- Metaxas Solitaire Power Amp and...
- Musical Fidelity F-Series Power...
- Musical Fidelity Nu-Vista M3 In...
- Musical Fidelity Tri-Vista 300 ...
- Musical Fidelity X-Ray Integrat...
- Musical Fidelity kW750 Preamp R...
- NVA AP10 Integrated Amp Review...
- NVA AP50 Amp Reviewed...
- Nagra VPA Amplifier Reviewed...
- Niro (Nakamichi) 1000 Integrate...
- Pathos Twin Tower Amps Reviewed...
- Pink Triangle Inergral Integrat...
- Primaluna Prologue One Integrat...
- Primaluna Prologue Two Amplifie...
- Quad 33 Preamp and 303 Amp Revi...
- Radford MA50 Renaissance Class-...
- Red Rose Music Model 5 Integrat...
- Red Rose Music Rosette 1 Integr...
- Sim Audio Moon Integrated Amp R...
- Sinfonia Preamp and Amp Reviewe...
- Solen Tiger Tube/MOSFET Integra...
- Sonic Frontiers SFS-50 Tube Pow...
- Sudgen A21 Amp Reviewed...
- Sugden Masterclass Preamp and M...
- T+A K6 Integrated Amp and Compa...
- T+A V-10 Amplifier Reviewed ...
- Tag McLaren DVD32FLR DVD-Video ...
- Theta Dreadnaught Amp reviewed...
- Trilogy RC211 Power Amps Review...
- Trilogy Vti Integrated Amp Revi...
- Unison Research Power Amp Revie...
- Unison Research SR1 Tube Amp Re...
- Unison Research Simply 845 Inte...
- Valfet Audio Power Amplifier Re...
Featured Audio-Video News
Experiencing Your Dream Home Theater While On Vacation -
It isn't any news that the economy is in the dumps. Morphing your living room, garage or basement into the...
Latest Stereo Amplifier Reviews (Classic)
AMC CVT 3030 Integrated Amp Reviewed -
Name the best-selling 'audiophile' budget integrated amplifier of all time. The NAD 3020, right? Even if it isn't -- I wouldn't be surprised if it was outsold by some piece of junk from one of the Japanese majors, but I... Click for more...
Beam Echo Tube Amp Reviewed -
Elder tubies delighted with the news that the name 'Beam-Echo' has been revived need wait no longer for proof. The reincarnated constructor has re-issued the Avantic DL7-35 monoblock power amp as its debut product, marking the amplifier's 40th anniversary,... Click for more...
NVA AP50 Amp Reviewed -
How refreshing it is to see, amidst a plethora of amps so cluttered as to be rococo, a return to good old-fashioned British minimalism. Not that NVA is completely innocent of the charge of producing what in the world of... Click for more...
Krell KAV-300i Integrated Amp reviewed -
Classroom doodling, playing the Lottery - whatever forms of dreaming take your fancy, there are some fantasies you're too realistic to entertain. And not just because Ferrari has already signed this year's drivers. I mean: who'd've thought that Dan D'Agostino... Click for more...
Audio Note Conquest Amp Reviewed -
Heh, heh...I can picture at least half of you going, "Oh, no - here come more toys with prices courtesy of L. Frank Baum." Close, but no (Monte Cristo) cigar: there are ranges in the Audio Note catalogue, the models... Click for more...
Audio Research Reference 600 Power Amps Reviewed -
Don't kid yourself: reviewers get nervous, too. At least this one does whenever he has to review a product which has the potential to rewrite the rules. Hell, the latest from Bill Johnson doesn't just rewrite 'em: he's thrown... Click for more...
NVA AP10 Integrated Amp Review -
It was never Richard Dunn's intention to set me on a chase to find the cheapest tolerable mock-audiophile system one could muster. But he did submit for review the NVA AP10 single-input amplifier selling for a paltry £160 and decided... Click for more...
Marantz Model 7 Reviewed -
Twist my arm. Go on. me to review a couple of products I've been dreaming about owning for years. What's that? If I've actually been waiting for 'years', did I suddenly find some mint originals? Not quite: Marantz took it... Click for more...
Arion Nemisis Power Amp Reviewed -
In a remarkably short time, the world of single-ended triode amplification has created its own set of niches. Calling it a 'hierarchy' would suggest some sort of pecking order - and I'd rather not be so egotistical as to assume... Click for more...
Krell KAV-250a and KAV-250p Reviewed -
What signals are you receiving from Krell? What do you make of the turnaround that has produced so much prime entry-level gear? Let's not be too glib about this, for even the Krell components we're about to explore sell for... Click for more...
Latest Stereo Amplifier Reviews (Classic)
AMC CVT 3030 Integrated Amp Reviewed -
Name the best-selling 'audiophile' budget integrated amplifier of all time. The NAD 3020, right? Even if it isn't -- I wouldn't be surprised if it was outsold by some piece of junk from one of the Japanese majors, but I... Click for more...
Beam Echo Tube Amp Reviewed -
Elder tubies delighted with the news that the name 'Beam-Echo' has been revived need wait no longer for proof. The reincarnated constructor has re-issued the Avantic DL7-35 monoblock power amp as its debut product, marking the amplifier's 40th anniversary,... Click for more...
NVA AP50 Amp Reviewed -
How refreshing it is to see, amidst a plethora of amps so cluttered as to be rococo, a return to good old-fashioned British minimalism. Not that NVA is completely innocent of the charge of producing what in the world of... Click for more...
Krell KAV-300i Integrated Amp reviewed -
Classroom doodling, playing the Lottery - whatever forms of dreaming take your fancy, there are some fantasies you're too realistic to entertain. And not just because Ferrari has already signed this year's drivers. I mean: who'd've thought that Dan D'Agostino... Click for more...
Audio Note Conquest Amp Reviewed -
Heh, heh...I can picture at least half of you going, "Oh, no - here come more toys with prices courtesy of L. Frank Baum." Close, but no (Monte Cristo) cigar: there are ranges in the Audio Note catalogue, the models... Click for more...
Audio Research Reference 600 Power Amps Reviewed -
Don't kid yourself: reviewers get nervous, too. At least this one does whenever he has to review a product which has the potential to rewrite the rules. Hell, the latest from Bill Johnson doesn't just rewrite 'em: he's thrown... Click for more...
NVA AP10 Integrated Amp Review -
It was never Richard Dunn's intention to set me on a chase to find the cheapest tolerable mock-audiophile system one could muster. But he did submit for review the NVA AP10 single-input amplifier selling for a paltry £160 and decided... Click for more...
Marantz Model 7 Reviewed -
Twist my arm. Go on. me to review a couple of products I've been dreaming about owning for years. What's that? If I've actually been waiting for 'years', did I suddenly find some mint originals? Not quite: Marantz took it... Click for more...
Arion Nemisis Power Amp Reviewed -
In a remarkably short time, the world of single-ended triode amplification has created its own set of niches. Calling it a 'hierarchy' would suggest some sort of pecking order - and I'd rather not be so egotistical as to assume... Click for more...
Krell KAV-250a and KAV-250p Reviewed -
What signals are you receiving from Krell? What do you make of the turnaround that has produced so much prime entry-level gear? Let's not be too glib about this, for even the Krell components we're about to explore sell for... Click for more...
Latest Equipment Reviews
Mapleshade Time-Correcting Maple Bedrock Speaker Stands Reviewed -
For ages the adage with bookshelf and/or monitor speakers has always been getting the tweeter or tweeter/midrange as close to ear height will yield the best results. Of course proper placement in a room as well as in relation to... Click for more...
Mapleshade Samson V.1 Equipment Rack Reviewed -
Seemingly everyone makes an equipment rack of some form or another these days with varying degrees of success, however for best results you're better off going with a third party or specialty equipment rack. The problem with going with an... Click for more...
Oppo BDP-83 Special Edition Universal Player Reviewed -
Oppo Digital's first Blu-ray player the BDP-83 entered the market in mid 2009 to numerous accolades. A mere half year later, Oppo Digital, not satisfied with the untapped performance potential of the player, released the BDP-83 Special Edition reviewed here.... Click for more...
Parker Audio 95MK II Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Chances are you've never heard of or seen a pair of Parker Audio 95MK II loudspeakers. Because of that fact, you're probably thinking they're some sort of uber-esoteric, high-end, ultra-expensive loudspeakers from some designer's garage in Munich. Well, you'd be... Click for more...
Bel Canto e. One S300iu Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Integrated amplifiers have always been an effective and affordable way to get into two-channel audio. However, in recent years, integrated amplifiers have come into their own, offering performance and simplicity that even high-end separate systems have trouble matching. Case in... Click for more...
Bel Canto e.One S300 Power Amplifier Reviewed -
Stereo amplifiers have been a staple since music went from single speakers to two-way back in the day. Over the years, we've seen stereo amplifiers go from simple, manageable black boxes to over-the-top, larger-than-thou space heaters for the home and... Click for more...
OmniMount Link Series A/V Stands Reviewed -
As its name suggests, OmniMount's Link Series is a modular line of A/V stands that you can mix and match to craft the exact entertainment solution you need. You can also add on as your system grows. The Link Series,... Click for more...
Paradigm Reference Studio 20 v.5 Bookshelf Speaker Reviewed -
I've been a fan of Paradigm for years, owning and enjoying seemingly every speaker in their product line from the awesome and affordable Atoms to their flagship Signature S8s. Over the years there have been two Paradigm speaker designs that... Click for more...
Bel Canto REF 1000M Mono Amplifier Reviewed -
When one thinks of a 500-Watt mono amplifier you probably picture a large, heat sink clad hunk of steel that weighs more than the car you drove it home in and probably costs more too. What if I told you... Click for more...
OmniMount VideoBasics TV Mounts Reviewed -
You've spent the extra money to buy an ultra-thin HDTV. The last thing you want to do is hinder the minimalist look by mating the TV with a bulky wall-mount. OmniMount designed the VideoBasics line of flat-panel TV mounts with... Click for more...





Comment on this article
0Post a Comment