Pound Wise and Penny Foolish - How The Home Theater Business Can Learn From Luxury Sectors Still Trying To Bilk Consumers
- By: HomeTheaterReview.com
- Resources & Links:
- View Jerry Del Colliano's Reviews
- July 7, 2009

Rising temperatures mean vacation time for many people around the world and I am no different. Just last week I took my wife to a luxury resort here in California to celebrate her birthday. It's a stunning property that we have been going to off and on since it opened in 2002. Mission style architecture, ocean views and an organic farm that grows much of the food served on site only begins to describe the appeal. Easy access by car, thus no lines at LAX, cool summer weather and access to some of the best wineries in the world only makes the value proposition even more tempting. Upon arrival - and thanks to one of the few useful perks that come from having an American Express Platinum Card - my wife and I were upgraded to an absolutely huge room complete with an ocean view and a fresh fruit amenity. Things were really looking up for this long weekend getaway.
My wife and I hadn't stayed at this resort for nearly two years despite its upside, as physically the property is five stars. Nobody argues with that when looking at the property - but the service is another story. Oh, the service is such a tragedy that you want to WILL it to be better. More than one bitter Angelino has mentioned how you can sit by the pool and wait an hour or longer to have someone even ask you if you want a fruity drink or a lunch menu. Regrettably, in the current deep recession, there are even fewer staff to meet the demands of increasingly needy guests. When asked for a New York Times at Sunday brunch at 11:30 I was not only told by a 16 year old host that "We are out," he also told me "Brunch is over" as he handed me the lunch/dinner menu. Brunch wasn't over, nor were they out of newspapers. He just wouldn't get one because he is lazy, mismanaged and doesn't care or understand about the luxury consumer unless he can communicate with them via texting. My wife and I started to get angry again as we were reliving the reasons why we didn't return to this hotel and were feeling foolish.
We ended our mediocre stay a day early and upon check out our bill was off by 11 percent in the hotel's favor. They missed applying a credit for a lunch and a few other small details. They were apologetic and seemingly really wanted us to return again; however upon closer look at the bill they charged $21 for an 11 minute phone call (there is no cell coverage there for anyone with service outside of AT&T), as well as $8 for one of those small, mini-bar sized bottles of Diet Coke. I had four of them during my stay. With all due credit to the hotel, when we checked out - they removed the phone call and other little zingers from my bill - but much of the damage was done. Nobody likes being played the fool and I was feeling that way. On the drive home I started thinking about how this nickel and diming seeps its way into the home theater business and how toxic it is toward keeping consumers from coming back for more and more high end, high priced AV equipment for their rigs.
There is one leading media server company that is absolutely dominant today selling unbelievably high priced, standard definition media servers. They have the guts to charge $1,000 for a 1 Terabyte hard drive for storage for clients who have drives that fail. Even ultra-rich people know that a hard drive doesn't cost $1,000 - it costs more like $150 and that they are being ripped off. What if the media server cost $9,000 instead of $8,000 and it came with a 10 year hard drive guarantee? Dealers would be able to sell on the fact that this luxury media server comes packed with the support that all computer companies should offer but don't. But no, they chose to grind their incredibly wealthy consumers, and many of these type of consumers don't like it. Mercedes Benz is making a similar mistake today by pulling their four year warranties for two year coverage that doesn't get you through even the shortest of MB Credit preferred leases. BMW is making a major issue of their four year warranties with Lexus and Acura laughing to the bank as consumers switch loyalties in the car market. One thing about this bad economy is that some companies act so shortsighted, which leaves wonderful market share opportunities out there to be had by forward thinking companies.
How a Herman Miller Dealer Does Customer Service Right
I recently had the inside of my house repainted. Many of the downstairs walls were scratched up after fostering upwards of a dozen Golden Retrievers (as part of my wife's and my charity work). Upon leaving, my painters pointed out that my Herman Miller Aeron Chair was spitting parts on the floor and looked enthusiastically broken - which it clearly was. They apologized to no end, but I blamed it on the extra 10 pounds that I have gained in the last two years (post fat-ass comments below) and quickly called the retailer that I bought the chair from - Jules Seltzer on Beverly Boulevard in West Hollywood.
The Jules Seltzer people wanted to know every detail about the chair including a number of dates, numbers and codes slickly hidden on the chair. Upon getting them all of the information they needed - they let me know that the $900 chair has a whopping 12 year warranty and that my part was ordered. They would be calling in a week to arrange for someone to come to my home at no cost and fix the chair.
I was blown away. The cost of a house call alone had to be $75 above and beyond the cost of the parts and the shipping of the parts. Because of this kind of fantastic service and support - I am a completely loyal customer. The next time I need more office furniture (and they have some really nice stuff) I am going to Jules Seltzer and likely nowhere else. They have simply earned my loyalty.
The home theater business is long past the Krell versus Mark Levinson audiophile comparisons from the 1990's. The high end consumer electronics business competes today directly with other luxury goods such as travel, cars, fashion and so much more. People with money today know that they can spend it on anything they want and expect more service, more goodies, and more upgrades - all for less money. It's the way of the new economy and likely is going to be how it stays for years to come. With HDMI connection issues, constantly changing firmware updates and other headaches associated with today's home theater systems - what if a top installer bought a dozen copies of a good, new Blu-ray movie and brought them along with a bow on them and a little card attached to the disc so that when the client gets home they get an unexpected present from their AV installer. "Here's a copy of (fill in the name of the movie) on Blu-ray. I thought you would like it - specifically chapter 7 where you will see your projector really shine. Thank you again for your business." Mr. Rich Client will remember this small but unexpected gesture of kindness and he will tell his other rich friends.
It's the little details that earn and retain the best, most high end clients. Today they can rightfully demand more value, more service all for less money. Costco and Wal-Mart can do the price thing better than any specialty retailer on the planet, which is perfectly reasonable when you are buying a 24 pack of paper towels - but when it comes to your home theater, people with money want the touchy-feely goodies and attentive service. The good news is that they simply aren't that hard to deliver.
Keywords
Pound Wise and Penny Foolish - How The Home Theater Business Can Learn From Luxury Sectors Still Trying To Bilk Consumers
- Dr. Floyd E. Toole Receives 20...
- Silicon Image (SIMG) Show Firs...
- Viacom and Time Warner Find Mi...
- 2010 CES Show Report- Andrew Ro...
- 5 Reasons Why You Need To Go Se...
- A New World Order - Where and H...
- AV Identity Crisis: Radio Shack...
- AV Manufacturers Need To "Floor...
- AV's Next and Biggest Generatio...
- An Open Letter To Audiophile Re...
- Apple Denies Rumor About 1080p ...
- April Showers Goes Wide Via iTu...
- Atlantic Technology and Solus/C...
- Audio Video Guru Writes Book Ab...
- Best Buy Offers Buyout To 4,000...
- Best Buy Plans Thirteen New Sto...
- Blu-ray Limits Its Growth Rate ...
- Blu-ray and SACD in the Same Pa...
- CDs Sales Tank in 2008 While Bl...
- CEA Says Black Friday Electroni...
- CEA and CNET Say Consumer Confi...
- CEDIA 2009 Show Report - Andrew...
- CEDIA 2009 Show Report - Jerry ...
- CEDIA 2009 Show Report - Ken Ta...
- CES 2009 Home Theater and Audio...
- CES 2009 Report From HomeTheate...
- CES 2010 Show Report - Adrienne...
- CES 2010 Show Report - Brian Ka...
- CES 2010 Show Report - Jerry De...
- CES 2010 Show Report - Ken Tara...
- CES Show Attendance Slips To 11...
- California Passes Anti-Flat-HDT...
- Can The Home Theater Business R...
- Cash For Clunkers - Meet The AV...
- Circuit City Liquidates But Cou...
- Circuit City To Relaunch As An ...
- Comcast Cleared To Buy NBC Than...
- Consolidation Is Taking the "Sp...
- Critics Say All HDMI Cables Sou...
- DTV Converter Coupons Now On Fi...
- Denon To Add VRS From Anchor Ba...
- DirecTV Investor Lends Over $50...
- Dish Network Loses Over 100,000...
- Dish Network's Profit Dips 81 P...
- Dynaudio To Distribute Octave A...
- Dynaudio's Puccini Sound System...
- Elevator Music Kings Muzak File...
- Embattled Final Loudspeakers Fi...
- Experiencing Your Dream Home Th...
- Finding New Consumers After The...
- First Annual Loss for Sony in 1...
- First-Ever McIntosh Boutique Op...
- Global TV Revenues Decline 12 P...
- Going Direct - The Gold Rush in...
- HD Giants Files Chapter 11...
- HDMI 1.4 - Another New Example ...
- HDTV Demand Outlook Improves In...
- HDTVetc.com Relaunches Online H...
- Hitachi Splits Off Consumer Gro...
- Hitachi To Acquire Remaining Sh...
- Home Theater Enthusiasts Can Ta...
- Home Theater Review Celebrates ...
- Home Theater Review Improves On...
- Home Theater Review Is Third La...
- Home Theater Review Launches Ne...
- Home Theater Review Updates Its...
- HomeTheaterReview.com Improves ...
- IMAX Chooses Audyssey Laborator...
- Improving The Carbon Footprint ...
- InFocus To Be Taken Private By ...
- Is 99 Cents the New Free For Mo...
- Is Cheap The New Green? Not For...
- Is Dish Network Looking To Get ...
- Is The Home Automation Business...
- Kaleidescape Loses Legal Appeal...
- Klipsch Sells Aragon and Acurus...
- Krell Takes On An Investor To M...
- Krell To Recall Four Amp Produc...
- Large LCDs Break Sales Volume R...
- Last Chance at Circuit Liquidat...
- Legendary Music Photographer Ji...
- Legendary Speaker Designer Jim ...
- Lutron Sponsors Green Life Smar...
- Mark Levinson, Lexicon and Reve...
- Meridian Opens a Concept Store ...
- More Black Friday Specials From...
- NEW HOME THEATER AND AUDIO/VIDE...
- NHT Goes "Dark" In Bad Economy...
- NHT To Relaunch As An Internet-...
- Netflix Pops 45% Gains In Q4 In...
- Nowhere To Sell: Specialty AV M...
- Obama Calls For Feb. 17 DTV Swi...
- Panamax Co-Founder and Family K...
- Panasonic Buys Sanyo...
- Paradigm Cinema 90 CT System To...
- Parent Company of Stereophile &...
- Parent Company of Sunfire, Pana...
- Parks Associates forecasts over...
- Parks and Assoc. Say Consumers ...
- Pioneer To Leave The HDTV Busin...
- Polk, Bose & Video Players To S...
- Porn Interrupts Super Bowl Broa...
- Pound Wise and Penny Foolish - ...
- Procella Audio Launches With Hi...
- QED Cables Issues HDMI White Pa...
- Rumor: You Tube To Be Releasing...
- Samsung Inks a DRM Deal with In...
- Samsung and Blockbuster Ink VOD...
- Samsung, Dreamworks and Technic...
- Saving Audiophila Part 2: The R...
- Saving Audiophila: How To Get a...
- Should Sirius-XM (SIRI) Fire Th...
- Sirius XM In Fear Of Takeover F...
- Sirius XM Shows Loss In Overall...
- Sirius XM To Release iPhone App...
- Sirius-XM (SIRI) To Raise Rates...
- Sony Cuts 16,000 Jobs as the En...
- Sony and Best Buy To Sell Exclu...
- Sony's Quarterly Profit Dives $...
- Specialty AV Brands Look To Dea...
- Study Says HDTVs in More Than 5...
- Sunday's Super Bowl Was 2nd Big...
- Telarc Records To Stop Producin...
- The $2,500 and Under Room - How...
- The 10 Best Audiophile Speakers...
- The 10 Best Up-and-Coming Compa...
- The AV Business Is Cautiously O...
- The Limitation On Specialty AV'...
- The Lost Art of The High End Au...
- Too Big To Fail: AV Manufacture...
- Toshiba To Make Blu-ray Players...
- U.S Credit Freeze Hurting The H...
- VIZIO Licenses Digital TV Paten...
- Vizio Now Number 2 Flat HDTV Se...
- WADIA Founder, Don Wadia Moses ...
- What Bernie Madoff Could Teach ...
- What Happened At Krell and Why ...
- What The AV Business Can Learn ...
- What if HDMI Actually Worked?...
- Will Blu-ray Profile 3.0 Be the...
- Will CES 2009 Flop Because of T...
- Wilson Audio To Release New "Sa...
- Winning and Losing In Las Vegas...
Featured Audio-Video News
Experiencing Your Dream Home Theater While On Vacation -
It isn't any news that the economy is in the dumps. Morphing your living room, garage or basement into the...
Latest Industry Trade News
Experiencing Your Dream Home Theater While On Vacation -
It isn't any news that the economy is in the dumps. Morphing your living room, garage or basement into the screening room of your dreams is harder today than ever before but fret not - there is a way for... Click for more...
Finding New Consumers After The 25 Year Boom In Home Theater Is Over -
We are pretty open and overt about how we make our living here at HomeTheaterReview.com. We don't own a store. We don't have an ecommerce portal or affiliate deals. We don't even sell t-shirts or coffee mugs (perhaps someday). The... Click for more...
Samsung, Dreamworks and Technicolor Ink Deal For 3D -
Samsung Electronics America, Inc., DreamWorks Animation SKG and Technicolor just announced that they have formed a global strategic alliance for the delivery of a complete 3D home entertainment solution in 2010. The three companies have joined forces to accelerate the... Click for more...
Home Theater Review Updates Its Comments System -
HomeTheaterReview.com has changed the way users can post comments on the site. From now on users must either use their Facebook accounts and/or create a HomeTheaterReview.com account to post comments. This comes as many spammers and flamers have tried unsuccessfully... Click for more...
Will Blu-ray Profile 3.0 Be the Magic Bullet For Audiophile HD Music? -
Even for audiophiles, SACD is fading out of favor. Fewer labels are releasing new SACDs, and the labels that are still selling them are bringing out fewer discs. And of course for years now, DVD-Audio has been essentially extinct. What... Click for more...
CES 2010 Show Report - Brian Kahn -
CES was notably more upbeat and crowded this year. If CES can be viewed as an indicator of the year ahead, this year will be a rebuilding year, we will not get back to the pre-recession heights quite yet but... Click for more...
CES 2010 Show Report - Adrienne Maxwell -
Apparently, consumers want 3D HDTV, whether they know it yet or not. 3D was the It technology at this year's CES. The industry is convinced that the big-screen success of 3D, especially Avatar, will translate into a desire for 3D... Click for more...
2010 CES Show Report- Andrew Robinson -
Coming off of a fairly subdued 2009 CEDIA I wasn't entirely sure what to expect from 2010 CES. The buzz around the convention was that consumers and manufacturers were in good spirits and happy that 2009 was behind them. I... Click for more...
CES 2010 Show Report - Jerry Del Colliano -
The 2010 Consumer Electronics Show (CES) is over and despite many predicting total gloom and doom for the business, the mood was notably up as was attendance. The draw on the show was the fact that many companies made decisions... Click for more...
CES 2010 Show Report - Ken Taraszka, MD -
While the down economy has hit every industry hard, ours being no exception, the 2010 CES showed a big change in attitude. People were optimistic, new models abounded and the crowd was the largest seen in a long time. Proving... Click for more...




Comment on this article
9Jerry,
I hate bad service. As a professional in the A/V industry I have seen some amazing levels of service from our dealers. Why not hand out an Home Theater Review award of customer service excellence?
Brad O'Toole
Transparent Audio, Inc.
Hi Jerry, Great article. I agree 100%. Most businesses have no idea how to build customer loyalty. Short story. We've had furniture and a wall unit designed and built by a well-known NYC company, and we were pleased with everything. So we hired them to design and build a new bathroom vanity for us. Weeks go by and we don't get the final drawings. Today we call and the brilliant salesman says, "The drawings are too big to fax. Can you come in and approve them?" Idiot. He should have mailed them to us when they were done last week. What does it cost? $10 at the most? Clueless. Thanks for the opportunity to vent. David
Jerry,
The times they are a-changin to be sure. Looking at a recent AVAD flyer and seeing B&K and Martin Logan on the cover my thoughts were ... "wow, you can actually put together a reasonably good highend system thru AVAD"! The elitist high-end "shoppe" is being forced out to pasture. BTW the server company that I think you are referring to does charge quite a bit and seems to be morphing some now but the service they deliver is, in my experience, on a par with the H-M experience. That experience, in this case being notified that your hard drive is out of spec and that they have a replacement in the mail as they speak, is something you don't experience often in this field. Maybe they should re-arrange their pricing architecture but the end result is there.
Chris Wells
GreenTechNW
No QUESTION Transparent would win one of those awards. You guys treat your customers like gold. The upgrade process keeps the consumer in the game and enthusiastic about AV for years. It also keeps their value high which today is NEEDED to make more sales.
AVAD is a meaningful channel. They sell VERY good brands now.
AVAD isn't perfect. They just closed up in Vegas. Things are tough for them too. The company's they sell ARE NOT CREATING CONSUMER DEMAND. They are LAZY in many cases. They think they can NOT advertise, not promote and just live off of their brand equity. Guess what - rich people are either a) buying other stuff or b) not buying anything at all.
The snobery of the audiophile magazines and highend audio salons is a JOKE and MUCH of the cause of their demise. NOBODY wants what they sell or to be treated that way. They cater to a Baby Boomer only client list who are now getting on Social Security and don't need to replace their $12,000 Wilsons with new $28,000 a pair ones. The snobs in the magazines and at the dealers NEVER embraced the next generation and they are doomed because of it. These dealers need products like Sooloos, Krell's KID, WADIA, EMM Labs (killer expensive DAC with USB in) etc...
Great Article, too bad nobody mentioned this to Circuit City.
Here's a shout-out to great service and customer relations from an audio company. I bought a pair of Etymotic Research earbuds way back in the days before all the other companies realized there was a market for quality in-ear buds. I think they were something like $300 at the time, which was a chunk of change for a tiny little accessory. Years went by and I was delighted with the sound and the noise isolation with my custom-fitted earmolds. Then one day I was trying to reseat the speaker tube back in the rubber earmold and I snapped it in half. Damn. $300 (or whatever the current equivalent) down the drain. I contacted the company and they said to send it in. They not only replaced it for free, including free return shipping, but upgraded it to the latest version. I spoke to real people on the phone who knew the product, knew my specific case, and sounded eager to help me and to take on the issue as their own.
Nowadays there are other companies making high end ear buds, but I am sold on Etymotic's service and attention to customer satisfaction. It's so rare that it stands out like a neon sign when you finally encounter it.
I agree, Jerry! It's so annoying to be a deserving, rich person like yourself get bad service from lazy, stupid 16-year-olds. I mean, don't they see your fancy car, Beverly Hills address, and American Express Platinum Card??? Maybe if you weren't such a status-obsessed egomaniac you wouldn't be mistreated by people who actually work for a living.
John - I noticed you weren't man enough to post your real email address. Impressive.
For the record, when I was 16 years old I worked at Bryn Mawr Stereo as one of the top grossing part time sales people in an 18 store regional mid-level chain. I worked 5 hours a week and closed as I was trained to do. I did do a) because it was fun and b) because I need to pay for my car. To suggest that I don't know about work ethic or customer service makes you look like a fool.
The POINT of the article is to compare luxury goods with the AV business and travel does compete with high end audio and home theater. The days of Levinson vs. Krell are long over.
I'd be interested to hear how you feel about having to pay $1,000 for a $100 hard drive in your media server or $17 for a class of chard in a plastic cup that takes 35 minutes to arrive. I prefer to be treated like Jules Selzer Assc. treated me with the Herman Miller chair. But you can have it your way when you spend your money.
Post a Comment