Sonus faber Guarneri Memento Speakers Reviewed
- By: Ken Kessler
- - Reviewer's System
- Category:
- Audio Reviews, Bookshelf Speaker Reviews, Equipment Reviews
- Resources & Links:
- Dynamic Loudspeaker ,
- Sonus faber
- October 26, 2008
In December 1993, when the original Guarneri appeared, who knew it would turn out to be the milestone model in the Italian speaker company's history? Once could easily postulate, even back then, that designer Franco Serblin was fired up by a need to raise the stakes in the speaker market. After all, every time Sonus faber came up with a new look (even that of the Extrema, which was an isolated model), lesser brands ripped off the form.
By 1993, though, the company was sophisticated enough to indulge in more than cabinetry fillips, and the brand was well into the stage where it was specifying proprietary drivers, or providing input into their suppliers' designs. The gloves - probably kid, made by Forzieri - were off.
What dominated the entire Homage series that it launched was Serblin's drive to emulate the Cremonese violin makers. Thus the Guarneri's cross-section reflected that of a lute, the woods were aged and assemblage using centuries-old techniques. Even the glues and varnishes were made from recipes that harked back centuries. While skeptics initially posited that the Guarneri exuded style over substance, the sound was simply breathtaking, and the speaker was an instant hit. In addition to siring the later Homage models and many dozens of rip-offs, it sold in its original form in serious numbers for 13 years.
Back then, I said it was one of the best small monitors I'd ever heard, and I have owned a pair ever since. It has been - after the Marantz CD12/DA12 CD player - the longest-serving reference component in my review system. My opinion, over the years, has been continually reinforced. You can therefore guess that I approached the Memento the way a devoted Porsche 911 or Leica M-series owner greets the replacement model: eager, nervous, curious, like preparing for a not-so-blind date.
Despite the singular brilliance of the Guarneri, a catalogue mainstay familiar to many of you, the differences are numerous, but obvious only to obsessives. Indeed, only the single terminals (instead of bi-wiring) and the prow on the grille tell non-geeks that they're auditioning the Memento rather than the original. But it is, cabinet shape aside, a virtually new speaker; even the supplied pedestals have been tweaked, the wedge-profiled base producing a six-degree slant. This ensures that the drivers' emissions centers are on the same plane. This allows the speaker to produce more coherent phase alignment and response.
For the active ingredients, the mid/woofer is derived from the Stradivari and Amati midranges. As the company put it, between the original Guarneri's and the Memento's mid-bass drivers are 12 years of technological development. The main difference is the new shaped cone and the use of Kapton instead of aluminum as the coil's support. "As a result, we have a 150mm, ultra-dynamic linearity driver with a CCAW/Kapton eddy current-free voice coil. Its dynamically linear magnetic field motor incorporates Kellogg and Faraday rings, and all moving elements have been optimally ventilated for resonance-free response."
So, too, does a new tweeter replace the Dynaudio Esotar of the original. A 25mm ring radiator tweeter with dual toroidal wave developed directly from that in the Stradivari, it's identical to one in the Amati Anniversario. Sonus faber feels that it is "more linear, more focused and a little more directive." It takes mere seconds to confirm the company's belief that the Memento's sound is "more detailed and refined if compared with the Guarneri Homage."
While the dimensions and shape are more or less the same as those of the Guarneri Homage, at 210 by 340 by 380mm (W/D/H), the wood is now solid maple instead of solid walnut and the small black wood segments have been changed to increase their ability to reduce and control resonances and vibrations. This produced an added benefit during manufacture: "There's no more need to tune the cabinet with some copper/lead devices, as [there] was for the older model."
Naturally, with two new drivers, a new crossover followed. Proudly, the company will tell you that the new one is less complex, though it maintains first-order networks "which link this project to our past tradition. It was designed using the philosophy of the least interference with the musical path. So it is a conceptually minimalist implementation using six-decibel/octave slopes and components of the highest quality and coherence." Its crossover point is 2.5kHz, and the impedance is four ohms. Like its predecessor, the Memento is - simpler network aside - still a hungry bugger of a speaker. Forget the 30-200-watt recommended range. Less than 100 watts is a waste of time.
Another minor change, beyond the aforementioned reversion to single wiring, is that both terminals are nickel rather than one gilded and one nickel. Unsurprisingly, given that Franco and his son-in-law Massimiliano (a metallurgist) are the geniuses behind the sublime Yter cables, the entire matter of wiring and connectors has been addressed with new version. Inside the Memento, replacing the silk-covered Litz of yore, is the uniquely structured silver-palladium alloy conductor found throughout the current Homage range. I will tell you at this point that Yter turned out to be the only wire worth using with the Memento, as its symbiotic nature provided a coherence and seamlessness that no other cable could match.
Aesthetically, the Guarneri is still pretty enough to silence bitchy wives, and it now comes in the red finish that previously existed for only a handful of pairs, but which found favor with the Amati and Stradivari. That wonderful graphite finish is an option, and the leather baffle has been restyled.
Sonically, well, you need to approach this with a caveat, and that caveat is: "Be ready for surprises." My all-time favorite audiophile joke (I only know two, besides certain brands that qualify as farcical) goes like this: How many audiophiles does it take to change a lightbulb? Answer: Three. One to change the bulb and two to argue about how much better the old one was.
I've never been of that school, preferring to give the benefit of the doubt to any manufacturer with the guts to revise a classic. One needn't have worried with the Guarneri Memento. It audibly and clearly advances on the ur Guarneri. Subjectively, there seems to be more weight down below, maybe a shade more extension, certainly a lot more control. Accusations of too much euphony haunted the original; the Memento is indubitably more detailed and transparent.
But the character? Despite sounding bigger - the scale of the stage it creates will baffle those who equate the function with cabinet size - and although it exhibits a far more convincing disappearing act than the original, the Memento (set up with the necessary severe toe-in that crosses the speakers in front of the listener) resembles the original in key ways. With vocals in particular - and I used a spread ranging from the broadband power of Jackie Wilson to the frailty of Sinead O'Connor - there remains a naturalness that places the vocalist texturally and spatially in the room, just in front of the speaker line. Strings still shimmer. Transients remain sharp but non-aggressive. To put it another way, it sounds more real and detailed, without sacrificing any warmth.
There is no doubt about one thing: the evolutionary step between the Guarneri Homage and the Guarneri Memento is as distinct and impressive as that between any other world-class technical product after a 13-year lifespan: cars, cameras, you name it. The trick was not losing the virtues that made the original so desirable.
This may sound contradictory, but if you have a pair of the originals, don't feel compelled to change them. They're still magnificent, and I intend to use mine until the driver cones decompose. But if you want to own the best-looking small speaker ever made, which just happens to sound as amazing as it looks, turn your eyes toward Italy. Sonus faber has done it again. And despite the 600-pound gorilla in the catalogue called "Stradivari," the Guarneri Memento just may be the best all-round speaker they've made to date.
If this review had appeared in December, I would have stolen a seasonal Chanukah refrain that states "A great miracle happened here." Not only has Sonus faber improved its 14-year-old masterpiece in every way, it's managed to lower, in real terms, the retail price! You don't need an accountant's math skills to understand that £5500 in 1993 vs. £6500 in the present is a serious price reduction. I've always loved the Guarneri. Now I positively adore it.
Sonus faber Philosophy and History
Franco Serblin's stroke of genius back in 1993 - since proven to be a viable direction for Sonus faber rather than a cul-de-sac like the fascinating Extrema - was to marry high-tech and centuries-old luthier skills to speaker building. While sound came first, and the Guarneri Homage proved that a speaker under 400mm tall could deliver genuine bass and a true sense of scale, the industry-shaking element was its styling. Debate still rages as to who produced the first "boat-tailed," tapered-rear, box-type speaker, but there's no doubt that it was the Guarneri that put it on the map.
As a result, it was proven that amazing sound could issue forth from gorgeous enclosures, more in keeping with fine furniture than geekware. Even the grille design - a row of strands continued down the front of the dedicated stand, recalling violin strings - has been employed by rivals, both with and without Sonus faber's blessings.
But Sonus faber always stayed one step ahead and each successive model, named after a Cremonese luthier, upped the ante, culminating in the astounding Stradivari. Like the Guarneri, it was copied within mere months of its launch. But fancy woodwork isn't enough: the Homage models are tuned by and for the most critical ears in the business. Serblin has stayed true to the original Homage concept, and it is with delicious irony that the smaller Guarneri Memento has raised the bar higher still. Roll on CES, and the first public hearing of the "baby" Stradivari.
Keywords
Sonus faber reviewed, Sonus Faber Guenari reviewed, Sonus faber bookshelf speakers
- Aerial Acoustics 5B Monitor Lou...
- Aux Classic 2.1 Desktop Speaker...
- B&W Nautilus 805 Loudspeakers R...
- Bookshelf Speaker Reviews & "Wi...
- Bose 301 Bookshelf Speakers Rev...
- Bose SoundDock II Reviewed...
- Boston Acoustics Classic CS 231...
- Bowers & Wilkins 685 Bookshelf ...
- Bowers & Wilkins CT 700 Series ...
- Bowers & Wilkins LM1 Satellite ...
- Dynaudio Contour 1.4 Bookshelf ...
- Dynaudio Excite X12 Loudspeaker...
- Focal XS 2.1 Speaker System wit...
- Infinity Cascade Model Five Lou...
- Infinity Primus P162 Loudspeake...
- JBL Control NOW Loudspeaker Rev...
- JBL On Air Control 2.4G Wireles...
- JBL Studio L Series L830 Booksh...
- JBL WEM-1 Wireless Expansion Mo...
- Klipsch Synergy B-3 Bookshelf L...
- Logitech Z-2300 2.1 Desktop Spe...
- Meyer Sound X-10 Powered Loudsp...
- NuForce Icon / S1 Amplifier Rev...
- Orb Audio Mod4 Home Theater Spe...
- Outlaw Audio BLS Bookshelf Loud...
- Outlaw Audio LCR Loudspeaker Re...
- PSB Imagine B Bookshelf Loudspe...
- PSB Imagine T Loudspeaker Revie...
- Paradigm AMS-350 In-Wall Speake...
- Paradigm Atom Monitor V.5 Speak...
- Paradigm Mini Monitor V.5 Louds...
- Paradigm Studio 100 5.1 Speaker...
- Revel Concerta M12 Bookshelf Sp...
- Revel Performa M22 Monitor Loud...
- Sonus faber Guarneri Memento Sp...
- Wilson Audio Duette Bookshelf L...
- Xhifi XDC-1 Desktop Audio Syste...
Today's Top Story
California Passes Anti-Flat-HDTV Legislation To Try To Save Energy -
As a resident of California who owns a "green home" complete with new windows, high efficiency air conditioners, space-age insulation and drought tolerant planting on over two acres of hillside - today's decision to toughen standards on HDTVs is a... Click for more...
Latest Bookshelf Speaker Reviews
Dynaudio Excite X12 Loudspeaker Reviewed -
Dynaudio is well known for their consumer, pro audio and automotive loudspeakers, and they are also one of the foremost OEM (original equipment manufacturer) providers of raw drivers to other loudspeaker companies. The company's Excite X12 is a compact bookshelf... Click for more...
Infinity Cascade Model Five Loudspeaker -
The Infinity Cascade Series models are unique among loudspeakers--they have a completely distinctive, slim and narrow appearance, and they utilize exclusive Maximum Radiating Surface (MRS) flat-panel drivers that incorporate unconventional design attributes. The Cascade Model Five is the smallest model... Click for more...
Aerial Acoustics 5B Monitor Loudspeaker Reviewed -
The model 5B compact monitor represents the entry level into the Aerial line of loudspeakers, but shares the lofty aspirations of its higher priced siblings. The $2,200 per pair 5B was designed to offer the rich and dynamic performance that... Click for more...
Meyer Sound X-10 Powered Loudspeakers -
In the world of audiophila, when it comes to the absolute best speaker money can buy there is great debate. Are the Wilson Alexandrias better than the JM Labs Grand Utopias or should you seek out an older pair of... Click for more...
Focal XS 2.1 Speaker System with iPod Dock -
Focal is best known for their expensive audiophile speakers. Their Utopia line of speakers tops out in price at nearly $200,000 per pair. My very limited listening experiences with Focal had left me with a positive impression. When I heard... Click for more...
Paradigm Studio 100 5.1 Speaker System Reviewed -
The Paradigm Studio v.5 series was introduced at CES 2009 as the fifth iteration of the Studio series. The Studio series was first introduced about a decade ago and, as the version number implies, it has been updated as new... Click for more...
Bowers & Wilkins CT 700 Series Loudspeakers Reviewed -
It didn't take me long to realize that this wasn't going to be your normal product review. Not because the product, Bowers & Wilkins' new CT 700 series loudspeaker, is either bad or wholly unique, but because, unlike other traditional... Click for more...
JBL On Air Control 2.4G Wireless Speaker System -
Wireless consumer electronic products are so prevalent these days that they're at the point of being taken for granted. (How many of you remember the Paleolithic days when the remote control was actually wired to the TV?) So, it's no... Click for more...
JBL WEM-1 Wireless Expansion Module -
Many people would love to install a home theater (yes, there are still legions of people out there who don't have one), but face a very real obstacle: how do they get the wires from the A/V receiver to the... Click for more...
JBL Control NOW Loudspeaker Reviewed -
The JBL Control NOW loudspeaker (like its outdoor cousin, the JBL Control NOW AW all-weather speaker) has a unique design that facilitates its use in a wide range of placement situations. Its quarter-round elbow shape - picture a giant piece... Click for more...
Latest Bookshelf Speaker Reviews
Dynaudio Excite X12 Loudspeaker Reviewed -
Dynaudio is well known for their consumer, pro audio and automotive loudspeakers, and they are also one of the foremost OEM (original equipment manufacturer) providers of raw drivers to other loudspeaker companies. The company's Excite X12 is a compact bookshelf... Click for more...
Infinity Cascade Model Five Loudspeaker -
The Infinity Cascade Series models are unique among loudspeakers--they have a completely distinctive, slim and narrow appearance, and they utilize exclusive Maximum Radiating Surface (MRS) flat-panel drivers that incorporate unconventional design attributes. The Cascade Model Five is the smallest model... Click for more...
Aerial Acoustics 5B Monitor Loudspeaker Reviewed -
The model 5B compact monitor represents the entry level into the Aerial line of loudspeakers, but shares the lofty aspirations of its higher priced siblings. The $2,200 per pair 5B was designed to offer the rich and dynamic performance that... Click for more...
Meyer Sound X-10 Powered Loudspeakers -
In the world of audiophila, when it comes to the absolute best speaker money can buy there is great debate. Are the Wilson Alexandrias better than the JM Labs Grand Utopias or should you seek out an older pair of... Click for more...
Focal XS 2.1 Speaker System with iPod Dock -
Focal is best known for their expensive audiophile speakers. Their Utopia line of speakers tops out in price at nearly $200,000 per pair. My very limited listening experiences with Focal had left me with a positive impression. When I heard... Click for more...
Paradigm Studio 100 5.1 Speaker System Reviewed -
The Paradigm Studio v.5 series was introduced at CES 2009 as the fifth iteration of the Studio series. The Studio series was first introduced about a decade ago and, as the version number implies, it has been updated as new... Click for more...
Bowers & Wilkins CT 700 Series Loudspeakers Reviewed -
It didn't take me long to realize that this wasn't going to be your normal product review. Not because the product, Bowers & Wilkins' new CT 700 series loudspeaker, is either bad or wholly unique, but because, unlike other traditional... Click for more...
JBL On Air Control 2.4G Wireless Speaker System -
Wireless consumer electronic products are so prevalent these days that they're at the point of being taken for granted. (How many of you remember the Paleolithic days when the remote control was actually wired to the TV?) So, it's no... Click for more...
JBL WEM-1 Wireless Expansion Module -
Many people would love to install a home theater (yes, there are still legions of people out there who don't have one), but face a very real obstacle: how do they get the wires from the A/V receiver to the... Click for more...
JBL Control NOW Loudspeaker Reviewed -
The JBL Control NOW loudspeaker (like its outdoor cousin, the JBL Control NOW AW all-weather speaker) has a unique design that facilitates its use in a wide range of placement situations. Its quarter-round elbow shape - picture a giant piece... Click for more...
Latest Equipment Reviews
Rotel RA-1520 Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Rotel has been creating audio components for more than 46 years that have all been designed with the goal of bringing high-end audio technology to the more discriminating audiophile. Rotel's RA-1520 integrated amplifier retains the same focus, as this amplifier... Click for more...
Parasound 5250 Five Channel Power Amplifier Reviewed -
As an audio manufacturer that is very proud of its ability to design high-end audio components for the very discerning ears of Hollywood's engineers, Parasound is also insuring that their power amplifiers for the consumer market are second-to-none. The 5250... Click for more...
Vizio VSB210WS Sound Bar with Wireless Subwoofer Reviewed -
Sound bars have always been a bit of the redheaded stepchild of the home theater world for me, a replica of sorts for those unable to accommodate or afford a proper home theater. Of course I jumped to this conclusion... Click for more...
Definitive Technology Mythos 7 On-Wall Speaker Reviewed -
When it comes to perfect replication of professional theater sound, the most important component of any home theater's speaker configuration is the center channel speaker. This speaker not only has to deliver a movie's dialogue with crystal-clear audio imaging, it... Click for more...
Benchmark DAC 1 HDR Reviewed -
While analog reproduction of audio is all the rage these days, most, if not all of us have our music in some digital form. Be it on a hard drive, iPod, Compact Disc or server, we all need high quality... Click for more...
Definitive Technology UIW 75 In-Wall Speaker Reviewed -
One of the primary functions of a first-rate in-wall speaker is its ability to disperse superb high-end audio to every part of the room, no matter where the speaker itself is placed. The design team at Definitive Technology knows just... Click for more...
Outlaw Audio ECS-10 Subwoofer Reviewed -
A major problem in the past with small and compact subwoofers was their inability to deliver strong and deep low-end to the average soundstage. Outlaw Audio's design team was well aware of this challenge when they started developing the ECS-10... Click for more...
Toshiba REGZA 46SV670U LED LCD HDTV Reviewed -
LED backlighting is the way of the future for LCD televisions. Most of the top-selling LCD manufacturers now offer at least one line that uses LED backlighting. Some of these models only place the LEDs around the edges of the... Click for more...
Energy ESW-V10 Subwoofer Reviewed -
Energy is an audio manufacturer that is fairly well known for developing quality speakers at a mid-range price and now they are slowly getting into producing a more high-end subwoofer product line starting with the ESW-V10. The list price for... Click for more...
JVC LT-42X899 42-Inch LCD HDTV Reviewed -
If you have been looking for an HDTV that eliminates pesky motion blur while viewing action-packed Blu-ray discs, you should be very interested in what JVC is calling their "Clear Motion Drive III" technology. That technology is integrated into their... Click for more...





Comment on this article
0Post a Comment