• AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Sumiko Pear Cartridge Reviewed


  • January 10, 2009

| Print Page | Adjust Font Size:

Free Home Theater Review Weekly Newsletter.

Enter your e-mail below to get Home Theater Review's weekly newsletter with the latest equipment reviews and home theater news sent directly to your inbox.


*Required

Wooden-bodied cartridges have always - since my first taste of Koetsu - charmed the hell out of me. I remember lusting after a Mr. Briar, a Grado Reference is never far from my headshell, and Koetsu, well, this brand remains for me the moving-coil of choice. So Sumiko (which also distributes Sonus Faber in the USA and thus has an appreciation of Things Timbered) was singing my song when it chose to mark a quarter century not with the silver of a wedding anniversary but with a lovely block of pearwood.

Sumiko's Celebration Pearwood Signature is a traditional moving-coil design in that it's low-output and uses an elliptical stylus instead of some trick profile. In this respect, the historical element is correct because (if my memory serves me well) Sumiko started out by distributing Japanese moving-coil cartridges, at a time when nearly all m-cs were low output types. Thus, if an anniversary model is to commemorate previous efforts and happens not to be a replica per se, then the Celebration sets the right tone. Moreover, beyond the shape and the stylus, the Celebration is as modern as it gets.

If you spring for this little masterpiece, spend a good 20 minutes reading the superb booklet before removing the cartridge from its little cedar box. Its text walks you through the design story and set-up procedure better than any cartridge manual I can recall. For the sake of brevity, then, let me just tell you that the cartridge has an output of 0.5mV, an internal impedance of 30 ohms and a load impedance of 1k ohm. The output, though low, was enough to drive the little NAD head-amp such that I could use it through Roksan's Caspian integrated amplifier without swinging the volume control much past the 11 o'clock position for normal levels. On the other hand, some who need more wallop will prefer this with a step-up; it adores the EAR 834P.

Sumiko selected Alnico magnets for the Celebration, with the front yoke pressure fit against the magnet. The cantilever itself is made from long-grain boron suspended by a special synthetic rubber material, while the aforementioned elliptical stylus is made from a low mass PH diamond said to be the most costly available - despite the lack of a tricky profile. Its perfectly cubist body helps the eye determine azimuth and rake angle.

With the above recipe, you guessed correctly if you assumed this was easy to install. Well, almost. Its total weight of 7g was too light for the SME Series V without the use of added mass at the headshell, while the cartridge wears tiny pins at the back necessitating the crimping of the tags on some tonearm leads. Worst of all, some putz put the wrong size Allen key in the bag, so I had to find the right one in my typically chaotic tool box. The good news is that the bolts go straight into the solid metal top-plate fixed to the upper surface of the wooden carcase, so nuts are not required below. Factor in those parallel sides, and you can almost forgive the designer for hiding the stylus under the body, with no viewing slot or Denon-like line drawn at the front.

Auditioned in both a Rega arm (on a Basis 2000) and the SME Series V on the SME 10, the Sumiko defies exhortations about run-in: it sounded magical straight out of the box. This cartridge has the uncanny knack of making solid-state equipment sound tubed, of making metal tweeters seem soft-domed a la mid-1970s BBC designs, and of caressing a voice like a honey-lemon mixture attacking a smoker's rasp. From Willie Nelson to Art Garfunkel and every texture in between, the Celebration, uh, celebrates vocals. At the same time, it exhibits so little tracing activity that super-sweet instruments gain no grating hints of edginess, or whatever the anti-vinyl brigade insists is present on all LP playback.

A track which made me stop in my tracks (groan...) was 'Georgia', on Classic Records' reissue of Willie Nelson's . The harmonica? Real and in the room. Willie's slight nasality and tremor? All present and correct. But the magic came not in the voice or the instruments, but the slight echo and air around the vocal. It's one of the best displays of 'atmospherics' I've heard since the original Koetsu Urushi. Take it as a given that this cartridge resolves space, especially front-to-back depth.

Almost as a bonus - given that everything else is so good, how could you demand more? - the bass is near perfect by my admittedly old-fashioned criteria. This cartridge lacks the kind of crunch or slam which will make it the transducer of choice for those who worship 12in singles. But when I listened to Classic's remastering of S&G's , the bass extension and control - from 'Cecilia' to 'Baby Driver' - added a weight I'd forgotten about, having always considered the LP a bit 'feathery'. Boy, was I wrong.

In an age where DVD-Audio and SACD loom large, where MP3 is doing its best to create a generation of listeners nurtured with lowest-common-denominator noise, it's hard to recommend a cartridge costing £995 to any but you, the converted. So it's time we got selfish and said to hell with the Philistines. Sumiko probably couldn't make enough if word ever got out that the Celebration is simply so nice that it's like aural comfort food. I loved it.

Keywords

Sumiko Pear Cartridge Reviewed

Subscribe to the Newsletter
Subscribe to HomeTheaterReview.com's Weekly Newsletter to get the latest news, reviews and insight on the world of home theater, HDTV and audiophile equipment. Subscription is 100% FREE!
*Required
Email Marketing by VerticalResponse
subscribe to rss Subscribe with RSS
Follow home theater equipment reviews and daily news via our RSS feed.
Related Source Component Reviews (Classic):
  • Comment on this article

    0
Post a Comment

Please answer the following question (required) before posting to help us prevent Spam.


enter to win

Today's Top Story

AV's Next and Biggest Generation of Clients Deeply Affected By Unemployment and Under-employment

AV's Next and Biggest Generation of Clients Deeply Affected By Unemployment and Under-employment -

Baby Boomers have been the driving force behind both the audiophile business and most of the two-decade long rise in popularity of home theater. Economically for Boomers there have been far more good times than bad, with recessions feeling more... Click for more...

Latest Source Component Reviews (Classic)

Theta Chroma Digital to Analog Converter Reviewed -

Given that Theta's sublime Pro Gen V is a device which consistently astounds me with its transparency, speed, coherence and freedom from digitalia, there should be no surprise that it's my reference converter. Much as I adore the Marantz DA-12... Click for more...

Meracus Imago CD Transport Reviewed -

No, I don't know what 'Meracus' means, and I stopped playing around with anagrams after I reached 'ear scum'. How about 'US Cream'? No way: Meracus is so decidedly, unabashedly a German company that it couldn't possibly apply. Oh, is... Click for more...

Marantz CD-63II K.I. Signature CD Player Reviewed -

On the surface, it's just another set of modifications, right? Another way to sell CD-63s, eh? I suppose that a cynic could look at it that way, but - after hearing the 'K.I. Signature' - the cynic would have to... Click for more...

Bow Technologies ZZ-Eight CD Player Reviewed -

It could have grown out of the ZZ-One integrated amp, a Siamese twin just itching to use its amplifying sibling as a plinth. Whether or not it should be 'stacked' is doubtful, given the ventilating properties of the ZZ-One's end... Click for more...

YBA CD3a Player Reviewed -

Blame the end of the Millennium, the coming of DVD, the arrivals of HDCD/20-bit remastering/XRCD, what-have-you. All I know is that we're experiencing a flood of deliberately off-the-wall CD players, and if this is anti-digital backlash, then it's over a... Click for more...

Wilson Bensch Circle Turntable Reviewed -

No puns about 'squaring the circle', 'Will the Circle Be Unbroken?', 'circle jerks' or any of that stuff: the most-obviously named turntable since the Revolver is exactly the dream Wilson Benesch watchers hoped it would be. Its shape, its simplicity,... Click for more...

Theta Pro Gen V-A Digital to Analog Converter Reviewed -

Not keeping tabs on other reviewers, I can't say if it's normal practice to use as a reference something which members of the public cannot purchase. Hot-rodded hardware, prototypes which never made it into production - there are plenty of... Click for more...

Rega Planet Turntable Reviewed -

Buying into certain 'schools' of audio thought requires the same kind of metaphorical lobotomy as becoming a slavish football supporter or joining a religious cult. In real terms - if you let the mind-set supplant part of your personality -... Click for more...

Quasar LE Turntable Reviewed -

'Gorgeous.' That's the word I kept hearing, every time someone noticed the Quasar LE turntable in for review. And one of the first to utter it was the owner of a Michell Orbe, itself no canine. What these individuals cooed... Click for more...

Linn LP12 Turntable Reviewed -

Military manoeuvres come no more complicated. Merely considering a 'top secret' review involving a panel of seven or so listeners is to court disaster, as 'secrets' and 'journalists' are mutually incompatible. But we knew, as the only British hi-fi magazine... Click for more...

Latest Source Component Reviews (Classic)

Theta Chroma Digital to Analog Converter Reviewed -

Given that Theta's sublime Pro Gen V is a device which consistently astounds me with its transparency, speed, coherence and freedom from digitalia, there should be no surprise that it's my reference converter. Much as I adore the Marantz DA-12... Click for more...

Meracus Imago CD Transport Reviewed -

No, I don't know what 'Meracus' means, and I stopped playing around with anagrams after I reached 'ear scum'. How about 'US Cream'? No way: Meracus is so decidedly, unabashedly a German company that it couldn't possibly apply. Oh, is... Click for more...

Marantz CD-63II K.I. Signature CD Player Reviewed -

On the surface, it's just another set of modifications, right? Another way to sell CD-63s, eh? I suppose that a cynic could look at it that way, but - after hearing the 'K.I. Signature' - the cynic would have to... Click for more...

Bow Technologies ZZ-Eight CD Player Reviewed -

It could have grown out of the ZZ-One integrated amp, a Siamese twin just itching to use its amplifying sibling as a plinth. Whether or not it should be 'stacked' is doubtful, given the ventilating properties of the ZZ-One's end... Click for more...

YBA CD3a Player Reviewed -

Blame the end of the Millennium, the coming of DVD, the arrivals of HDCD/20-bit remastering/XRCD, what-have-you. All I know is that we're experiencing a flood of deliberately off-the-wall CD players, and if this is anti-digital backlash, then it's over a... Click for more...

Wilson Bensch Circle Turntable Reviewed -

No puns about 'squaring the circle', 'Will the Circle Be Unbroken?', 'circle jerks' or any of that stuff: the most-obviously named turntable since the Revolver is exactly the dream Wilson Benesch watchers hoped it would be. Its shape, its simplicity,... Click for more...

Theta Pro Gen V-A Digital to Analog Converter Reviewed -

Not keeping tabs on other reviewers, I can't say if it's normal practice to use as a reference something which members of the public cannot purchase. Hot-rodded hardware, prototypes which never made it into production - there are plenty of... Click for more...

Rega Planet Turntable Reviewed -

Buying into certain 'schools' of audio thought requires the same kind of metaphorical lobotomy as becoming a slavish football supporter or joining a religious cult. In real terms - if you let the mind-set supplant part of your personality -... Click for more...

Quasar LE Turntable Reviewed -

'Gorgeous.' That's the word I kept hearing, every time someone noticed the Quasar LE turntable in for review. And one of the first to utter it was the owner of a Michell Orbe, itself no canine. What these individuals cooed... Click for more...

Linn LP12 Turntable Reviewed -

Military manoeuvres come no more complicated. Merely considering a 'top secret' review involving a panel of seven or so listeners is to court disaster, as 'secrets' and 'journalists' are mutually incompatible. But we knew, as the only British hi-fi magazine... Click for more...

All Source Component Reviews (Classic)

Latest Equipment Reviews

Definitive Technology UIW 75 In-Wall Speaker Reviewed -

One of the primary functions of a first-rate in-wall speaker is its ability to disperse superb high-end audio to every part of the room, no matter where the speaker itself is placed. The design team at Definitive Technology knows just... Click for more...

Outlaw Audio ECS-10 Subwoofer Reviewed -

A major problem in the past with small and compact subwoofers was their inability to deliver strong and deep low-end to the average soundstage. Outlaw Audio's design team was well aware of this challenge when they started developing the ECS-10... Click for more...

Toshiba REGZA 46SV670U LED LCD HDTV Reviewed -

LED backlighting is the way of the future for LCD televisions. Most of the top-selling LCD manufacturers now offer at least one line that uses LED backlighting. Some of these models only place the LEDs around the edges of the... Click for more...

Energy ESW-V10 Subwoofer Reviewed -

Energy is an audio manufacturer that is fairly well known for developing quality speakers at a mid-range price and now they are slowly getting into producing a more high-end subwoofer product line starting with the ESW-V10. The list price for... Click for more...

JVC LT-42X899 42-Inch LCD HDTV Reviewed -

If you have been looking for an HDTV that eliminates pesky motion blur while viewing action-packed Blu-ray discs, you should be very interested in what JVC is calling their "Clear Motion Drive III" technology. That technology is integrated into their... Click for more...

Vizio VT420M 42-Inch LCD HDTV Reviewed -

Vizio has been hard at work designing their full product line of HDTV's to compliment every consumer's desire to own a high-quality HDTV for less than almost any other A/V manufacturer around. This well-designed HDTV retails for just under $1,000... Click for more...

Yamaha BD-S1065 Blu-ray Player Reviewed -

Yamaha recently added two new models to its Blu-ray lineup. The BD-S1065 is the least expensive of the two, priced at $599.95. We have not performed a hands-on review of the BD-S1065, but here is an overview of the player's... Click for more...

Mitsubishi Diamond Unisen LT-46249 LCD HDTV Reviewed -

The Diamond Unisen 249 Series is Mitsubishi's highest-end LCD line for 2009 and therefore is loaded with the company's most advanced technologies and features. The line includes screen sizes of 46 and 52 inches. We have not performed a hands-on... Click for more...

Sony BDP-N460 Blu-ray Player Reviewed -

The newest addition to Sony's Blu-ray line is a Profile 2.0 player that offers a wide variety of Internet-based media options. Its $249.99 MSRP puts it at the lower end of the price spectrum for Sony players. We have not... Click for more...

Kaleidescape Mini System Music and DVD Server -

The easier it is to enjoy your movie and music software, the more you will reap from the collection. If you don't believe me, just count the number of iPods you see in a day. Having the disc you want... Click for more...

Read All Reviews