TDL Studio 0.5 Bookshelf Loudspeakers Reviewed
- By: Ken Kessler
- - Reviewer's System
- Resources & Links:
- Bookshelf Speaker Reviews ,
- View Ken Kessler's Reviews
- February 13, 1990
Bass versus size -- the age-old dilemma has been addressed in a
number of ways, some successful and some (usually electronic) not
so successful. And whatever the satellite system designers
produce -- hidden subwoofers, for example -- British hi-fi
enthusiasts seem to prefer one full-range enclosure per channel.
One of the best ways of squeezing a quart out of a pint has been
the transmission line concept, a not-too-distant relative of the
folded horn. Among the pioneers of this system was IMF, which
metamorphosed into TDL, familiar to most readers for a range
crowned by the huge Reference Standard. But TDL rewrote the books
with the diminutive Studio 1, with a footprint and an overall
space requirement matching that of yer garden variety two-way
bookshelf-speaker-on-a-stand.
I have to admit that I was surprised at how well the Studio 1
worked, because I thought that the convoluted folds which make up
a transmission line could be reduced only so far. But TDL has
reduced the speaker even further -- in size and in price -- to
produce a transmission line speaker tiny enough to be called
'cute'.
Before saying any more, I want you to be aware of the two most
relevant specs if this review is to have any meaning. First of
all, the Studio 0.5 has a footprint of only 200x304mm (WxD) and
its height is a mere 620mm. Add to this the dedicated stands and
you increase it by only 70mm plus spikes. Best of all, though, is
the price -- #399, plus #70 for the stands, the latter a perfect
match in both sonic and aesthetic terms.
The Studio 0.5 looks like a junior TDL, a shrunken-down
'minilith' which still looks commanding in the all-black finish.
The grille is black cloth stretched over a rigid frame, the
cut-outs large enough to preclude any edge diffraction. The box
itself is finished in black ash veneer, with the back and baffle
in black paint. With the grille removed, you'll see at the top a
ferro-fluid-controlled 25mm magnesium alloy tweeter, protected by
a mesh dome and featuring a separate rear chamber.
Below this, its bottom edge situated roughly half-way up the
baffle, is a 135mm doped polypropylene-coned woofer, tiny enough
to look like it belongs in a Celestion 3-sized box. It features a
phase plug sprouting from the centre and utilizes a Kapton
former, vented pole magnet and cast alloy chassis. At the very
bottom are the two ports for the transmission line.
The back conatins two pairs of hefty binding posts in a recessed
area near the top; they accept bare wire, spade lugs or banana
plugs, although they're too far apart for 19mm spaced pairs.
Still, access is good and the barrels are large enough to provide
a good grip. The speakers arrive with solid core wire links, but
bi-wiring offered such obvious improvements that I can't imagine
why anyone would be so tight-fisted as to run these in
single-wire mode.
In addition to the clever carpentry, the secret of the 0.5 is the
use of the long-throw woofer, which offers high power handling to
compensate for the efficiency loss associated with trying to
extract deep bass from a small enclosure. The Kapton voice coil
former contributes higher power handling by virtue of its ability
to withstand higher temperatures. The use of this non-metallic
material also increases the electrical 'Q' of the driver. The
phase plug is fitted to improve the transition from the bass/mid
driver to the dome tweeter.
The crossover point for the 0.5 is at 3kHz, accomplished by a
simple 5-element design incorporating the aforementioned
bi-wiring capability. Other 'magic' wrought on this speaker
consists of a nice, safe nominal impedance of 6 ohms and a
reasonable but not high sensitivity of 85dB. I used the speaker
successfully with the Musical Fidelity B1 to see how it would
fare with a budget amp, while I tested its limits with the far
heftier Counterpoint SA-100.
Other products in the review system included the Basis turntable
with SME Series V arm, Lyra Lydian cartridge, California Audio
Labs Tempest II SE CD player, Counterpoint SA-1000 pre-amp and
wire from Lieder, MasterLink, Space & Time, Sony, Audio-Technica,
plus a few I won't name as they sounded unduly awful. The
profusion of cables leads me straight to the primary curse which
plagues this speaker.
Let's not mince words, huh? This speaker is so inordinately fussy
for what should be an easy-to-use, upper-mass-market model that
it will challenge any inveterate tweaker to near-breakdown. Maybe
it's the metal dome tweeter, still an ornery device regardless of
its genuine potential, or maybe it's the strange dispersion
pattern -- whatever, this speaker needs as much fine-tuning as
any megabucks dipole, so don't expect to just slap a pair on the
floor for maximum boogie-ness.
For starters, the 0.5 teeters on the edge of brightness, despite
the copious amounts of bass which prevent it from sounding
lightweight or top-heavy. If you used these in a blindfold test,
I'll guarantee that your buddies will think that they're hearing
something the size of an Isobarik or a KEF 105. But this rich
bottom end doesn't counterbalance a tizz which leads you to an
array of cables for fine-tuning purposes. Unless, of course,
you're lucky enough to have a dozen amplifiers and sources at
your disposal for producing a better match.
Item 1: Solid core and/or thin strand wire -- both of which I've
always though were lousy, desperate solutions of the
two-wrongs-don't-make-a-right variety -- aggravated the situation
so much that I even substituted short lengths of my preferred
multi-strand cable when assessing the speakers in single-wire
form. I didn't want to gut the 0.5s to find out what was inside,
but I wouldn't be surprised if it was solid core and/or
thin-strand.
Item 2: Positioning is hypercritical, and not just in terms of
toe-in, or proximity to the walls. More important than either is
the amount of tilt you settle on, adjustable via the stands which
have spikes long enough to allow you to tilt the 0.5 back by a
few necessary degrees. This is entirely dependent on the distance
between the speaker and your listening seat, and it's as critical
as the tilt factor of the Apogee Stage. The only way to
accomplish this is by enlisting the help of a friend or two, so
you can bark out orders from the hot seat. But it's worth it.
Once you've eliminated the potential for tizz, you're treated to
a remarkably coherent sound, the bass-to-mid-to-treble
transitions matching the Studio 1 for consistency. Don't ask me
why, but the speaker sound smoother when bi-wired, despite
splitting the crossover, which does suggest that the links are
inordinately critical when you're using a bi-wireable speaker in
single-wire mode. That inch or two of solid core...yecchh.
The bass quantity is tuned, as expected, according to the
proximity to the walls. I wouldn't advise raising the speaker
(above the level provided by the dedicated stand) as a substitute
for the tilt, because the height off the floor via the stand is
ideal for bass quality, especially control. The tilting
accomplishes one thing, focussing the image for more accurate and
therefore three-dimensional portrayal; although raising the
speaker so that it fires at ear level would accomplish the same,
it ¬will¬ compromise the bass. So, just as with the legendary
Hadcock arm, addressing one area of set-up is bound to butcher
the perfection you've attained in another. To repeat myself:
persist with the dedicated stand.
Once the ideal postioning has been achieved -- and I'd offer more
advice, but this can only be done by ear and in the actual
listening room -- you can ready yourself for amazement. Now I am
not trying to set you up for an experience akin to listening to a
tower full of Infinity 12in drivers, or a JBL Everest, or a
Duntech. But you'll find that little can touch this baby at #399
when it comes to weight, slam, mass -- whatever you're looking
for if you've embarked on a quest for more bass.
Regardless of what you think makes a speaker sound 'big' -- the
mass provided by deep bass or dispersion which fills the space in
front of the listener -- you'll be pleased to note that a
painstakingly installed pair of 0.5s can mimic some real
monsters. Image height, when gauged from the listening seat with
the tilt just so, isn't quite as convincing as with a pair of
Divas. But the 0.5, positioned with the tweeter some 6in below
the height of my LS3/5As, matches that of my favourite
BBC-approved giant killer. Stage width extends beyond the edges,
as it should; try it with the James Boyk microphone test CD for
proof. And depth? This baby could fool you into thinking it's a
thoroughbred dipole.
But however good the spatial characteristics, the smooth midband
and the clear treble (assuming you've paid heed to what I've
written above), it's the bass quality which lifts this wa-a-ay
above like-priced competition. Given that you'll hear these in a
shop where the staff has taken the time to set them up with the
ludicrous amounts of attention they demand, you'll be staggered
by the extension, the solidity and the control. There's no fat at
all when you're in the hot seat, though -- and I know this sounds
weird -- they sound as flabby as an Isobarik off axis.
What the Studio 0.5 will not do is tempt those who think that
controlled bass must be as tight as a drunk on New Year's Eve.
The Studio 0.5 is rich, not dry, and the harmonics on acoustic
bass are liquid and flowing. What happens when you play bass
derived from a keyboard hooked up via MIDI is that the edge is
softened. I consider that a virtue, because it may even fool you
into thinking that a musician rather than a computer operator
made the recording, but those weaned on MC Hammer won't be
amused. Fine, let them stick their heads in the bass bins down at
the club.
I've gotta say it: my fetishistic love for the LS3/5A
notwithstanding, I feel that the TDL Studio 0.5 is the best
speaker you can buy for under #500. And if you add the stands to
the #399, for a total of #469, you're left with #30 to buy that
extra length of cable for bi-wiring while staying below the
half-grand mark. If this speaker doesn't win some industry kudos,
then the Oscars and the Booker prize won't stand alone as warped
awards.
Keywords
TDL Studio 0.5 Bookshelf Loudspeakers Reviewed
- KEF KIT100 Speaker System Revi...
- Opera Mini Bookshelf Loudspeak...
- Stirling LS3 V2 Bookshelf Loud...
- AAD PL-100 / PL-200 / PL-200C /...
- ALR Entry 2M Loudspeakers Revie...
- ATC A7 Loudspeakers Reviewed...
- ATC SCM20 Bookshelf Loudspeaker...
- Anthony Gallo Acoustics Due Lou...
- Anthony Gallo Due Speaker Syste...
- B&W Nautilus 805 Loudspeakers R...
- B&W Solid Sub/Sat Speaker Syste...
- B&W VM1 Speakers and AS1 Subwoo...
- Boston Acoustics P400 Home Thea...
- Bowers and Wilkins (B&W) 602 Bo...
- Canton Movie 10-MX II Home Cine...
- Castle Durham 900 Loudspeakers ...
- Celestion 3000 Ribbon Loudspeak...
- Celestion 5 Loudspeakers Review...
- Celestion SL700 Loudspeaker Sys...
- Dali Evidence Speaker Ensemble ...
- Definitive Technology Powermoni...
- Definitive Technology Procinema...
- Diapason Karis Bookshelf Loudsp...
- DynAudio Contour T2.5 Speakers ...
- Energy ACT6 SUB/SAT Speaker Sys...
- Indigo Stage One Bookshelf Spea...
- Infinity Kappa Series and Inter...
- Infinity TSS-750 Home Cinema Sy...
- JBL L1 Bookshelf Speakers Revie...
- JBL Northridge E Series 24A WII...
- JBL SCS160SI Home Speaker Syste...
- JBL SCS300.7 Surround Cinema Sp...
- JBL XPL 90 Loudspeakers Reviewe...
- JL Audio XR650-CSI Component Sp...
- JM Labs Micron Carat Speakers R...
- JM Labs SIB & CUB 5.1 Speaker S...
- KEF Q-Series Speaker System Rev...
- KEF Reference 205/201/202C and ...
- KEF XQ Series and psw3500 Louds...
- Klipsch Synergy Series SLX/SUB-...
- LOTH-X ION BS1 Loudspeaker Revi...
- Loth-X Ino Amaze Loudspeakers R...
- Mirage OMNISAT 6 Speakers Revie...
- Mirage Omnisat Micro Loudspeake...
- Monitor Audio Bronze Series Lou...
- Monitor Audio Reference 1200 "G...
- Monitor Audio Studio 10 Loudspe...
- Opera Callas Speakers Reviewed...
- Opera Platea Loudspeakers Revie...
- Orb Audio Mod4 Custom Home Thea...
- Paradigm Phantom Speakers Revie...
- Phase Technology Velocity V-10 ...
- Polk Audio RM6900 Home Theater ...
- RBH CT-7.1 Compact Theater Spea...
- RBH MC Series Mark II Reviewed...
- Rogers LS3a Bookshelf Speakers ...
- Rogers db101 Speakers Reviewed...
- Roxsan Hotcakes Bookshelf Louds...
- Ruark Epilogue Loudspeakers Rev...
- Sonance Cinema Ultra II LCR Spe...
- Sonus fabber Musical Loudspeake...
- Sonus faber Concerto GP Loudspe...
- Sonus faber Cremona Bookshelf L...
- Spendor S-3/5 Speakers Reviewed...
- Spendor S3 Speakers Reviewed...
- TDL Studio 0.5 Bookshelf Loudsp...
- THEIL Viewpoint Speakers and Sm...
- THIEL ViewPoint Speakers Review...
- Tannoy 603 Audiophile Loudspeak...
- Tannoy Arena 5.1 Loudspeaker Sy...
- Totem Acoustic: TRIBE I, TRIBE ...
- Wharfdale Diamond 8.1 Speakers ...
- Wharfedale Diamond 8 Series Spe...
- XHi-Fi xDucer 2.1 Desltop Louds...
- Yamaha DVX-S120 Home Cinema Spe...
- Zingali Coliseum Loudspeakers R...
Featured Audio-Video News
Experiencing Your Dream Home Theater While On Vacation -
It isn't any news that the economy is in the dumps. Morphing your living room, garage or basement into the...
Latest Bookshelf Speaker Reviews (Classic)
Rogers db101 Speakers Reviewed -
Wealth by association is a funny concept. But that's never stopped merchandisers from exploiting weird non-sequiturs like Ferrari-badged wristwatches, Marlboro clothing or any of the perfumes which inevitably follow the success of a designer in the rag-trade. And while writing... Click for more...
Sonus faber Concerto GP Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Keeping one step ahead of the competition has been Sonus Faber's trick ever since the birth of an Italian 'school' of speaker design. Whatever the origins of the genre - and there are stories to make Boccaccio blanch - the... Click for more...
B&W Solid Sub/Sat Speaker System Reviewed -
Sub-woofer/satellite systems can be a pain in the butt for reviewers because all the myriad permutations must be addressed. And, hey, does the B&W Solid Solutions system permutate. That's not B&W's fault. They're dealing with a format established years ago... Click for more...
ATC A7 Loudspeakers Reviewed -
"Hot minis continue to proliferate." It's the kind of phrase you'd expect to find in any show report, in any magazine, covering any British hi-fi show. It's the clichÈ that has marked the British loudspeaker industry ever since the 1970s,... Click for more...
Sonus fabber Musical Loudspeaker Reviewed -
It's easy to forget that, once upon a time, the doyen of Italian speaker manufacture made amplifiers. They were mainly valved, oozed the sort of woodcraft found in the company's speakers and sported daft names like 'Quid'.* They were not... Click for more...
Ruark Epilogue Loudspeakers Reviewed -
'Y'gaddaseeit!' 'Y'gaddaseeit!' 'Y'gaddaseeit!' Three times is usually enough to convince me that something's afoot. Ordinarily, there's so much new and worthwhile kit at a hi-fi show that the surfeit of brilliant new products tends to overwhelm. But when a consensus... Click for more...
Opera Platea Loudspeakers Reviewed -
It's not just sound which comes in waves: hardware trends seem to as well. With domestic congestion, urban dwelling and bitch-wives* from hell deeming with increasing vehemence that any speaker larger than a loaf of bread is an intrusion, it... Click for more...
B&W Nautilus 805 Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Presuppose for just a second that the cheapest model in a range will always outsell the model above it in logarithmic proportion. Presuppose it all the way up the range, to its flagship edition, and you can only imagine the... Click for more...
Diapason Karis Bookshelf Loudspeakers Reviewed -
While there's been no announcement to the effect, nor a banner across the upper corner to indicate it, this is part of a series of reviews. The theme? To find a replacement for the late, lamented LS3/5A. The requirements are... Click for more...
ALR Entry 2M Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Irony, said to be something which Americans fail completely to comprehend, was written all over this assignment because of one teensy detail. Before I was allowed to review ALR's Entry 2M budget two-way loudspeaker, I was commanded from on high... Click for more...
Latest Bookshelf Speaker Reviews (Classic)
Rogers db101 Speakers Reviewed -
Wealth by association is a funny concept. But that's never stopped merchandisers from exploiting weird non-sequiturs like Ferrari-badged wristwatches, Marlboro clothing or any of the perfumes which inevitably follow the success of a designer in the rag-trade. And while writing... Click for more...
Sonus faber Concerto GP Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Keeping one step ahead of the competition has been Sonus Faber's trick ever since the birth of an Italian 'school' of speaker design. Whatever the origins of the genre - and there are stories to make Boccaccio blanch - the... Click for more...
B&W Solid Sub/Sat Speaker System Reviewed -
Sub-woofer/satellite systems can be a pain in the butt for reviewers because all the myriad permutations must be addressed. And, hey, does the B&W Solid Solutions system permutate. That's not B&W's fault. They're dealing with a format established years ago... Click for more...
ATC A7 Loudspeakers Reviewed -
"Hot minis continue to proliferate." It's the kind of phrase you'd expect to find in any show report, in any magazine, covering any British hi-fi show. It's the clichÈ that has marked the British loudspeaker industry ever since the 1970s,... Click for more...
Sonus fabber Musical Loudspeaker Reviewed -
It's easy to forget that, once upon a time, the doyen of Italian speaker manufacture made amplifiers. They were mainly valved, oozed the sort of woodcraft found in the company's speakers and sported daft names like 'Quid'.* They were not... Click for more...
Ruark Epilogue Loudspeakers Reviewed -
'Y'gaddaseeit!' 'Y'gaddaseeit!' 'Y'gaddaseeit!' Three times is usually enough to convince me that something's afoot. Ordinarily, there's so much new and worthwhile kit at a hi-fi show that the surfeit of brilliant new products tends to overwhelm. But when a consensus... Click for more...
Opera Platea Loudspeakers Reviewed -
It's not just sound which comes in waves: hardware trends seem to as well. With domestic congestion, urban dwelling and bitch-wives* from hell deeming with increasing vehemence that any speaker larger than a loaf of bread is an intrusion, it... Click for more...
B&W Nautilus 805 Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Presuppose for just a second that the cheapest model in a range will always outsell the model above it in logarithmic proportion. Presuppose it all the way up the range, to its flagship edition, and you can only imagine the... Click for more...
Diapason Karis Bookshelf Loudspeakers Reviewed -
While there's been no announcement to the effect, nor a banner across the upper corner to indicate it, this is part of a series of reviews. The theme? To find a replacement for the late, lamented LS3/5A. The requirements are... Click for more...
ALR Entry 2M Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Irony, said to be something which Americans fail completely to comprehend, was written all over this assignment because of one teensy detail. Before I was allowed to review ALR's Entry 2M budget two-way loudspeaker, I was commanded from on high... Click for more...
Latest Equipment Reviews
Mapleshade Time-Correcting Maple Bedrock Speaker Stands Reviewed -
For ages the adage with bookshelf and/or monitor speakers has always been getting the tweeter or tweeter/midrange as close to ear height will yield the best results. Of course proper placement in a room as well as in relation to... Click for more...
Mapleshade Samson V.1 Equipment Rack Reviewed -
Seemingly everyone makes an equipment rack of some form or another these days with varying degrees of success, however for best results you're better off going with a third party or specialty equipment rack. The problem with going with an... Click for more...
Oppo BDP-83 Special Edition Universal Player Reviewed -
Oppo Digital's first Blu-ray player the BDP-83 entered the market in mid 2009 to numerous accolades. A mere half year later, Oppo Digital, not satisfied with the untapped performance potential of the player, released the BDP-83 Special Edition reviewed here.... Click for more...
Parker Audio 95MK II Loudspeakers Reviewed -
Chances are you've never heard of or seen a pair of Parker Audio 95MK II loudspeakers. Because of that fact, you're probably thinking they're some sort of uber-esoteric, high-end, ultra-expensive loudspeakers from some designer's garage in Munich. Well, you'd be... Click for more...
Bel Canto e. One S300iu Integrated Amplifier Reviewed -
Integrated amplifiers have always been an effective and affordable way to get into two-channel audio. However, in recent years, integrated amplifiers have come into their own, offering performance and simplicity that even high-end separate systems have trouble matching. Case in... Click for more...
Bel Canto e.One S300 Power Amplifier Reviewed -
Stereo amplifiers have been a staple since music went from single speakers to two-way back in the day. Over the years, we've seen stereo amplifiers go from simple, manageable black boxes to over-the-top, larger-than-thou space heaters for the home and... Click for more...
OmniMount Link Series A/V Stands Reviewed -
As its name suggests, OmniMount's Link Series is a modular line of A/V stands that you can mix and match to craft the exact entertainment solution you need. You can also add on as your system grows. The Link Series,... Click for more...
Paradigm Reference Studio 20 v.5 Bookshelf Speaker Reviewed -
I've been a fan of Paradigm for years, owning and enjoying seemingly every speaker in their product line from the awesome and affordable Atoms to their flagship Signature S8s. Over the years there have been two Paradigm speaker designs that... Click for more...
Bel Canto REF 1000M Mono Amplifier Reviewed -
When one thinks of a 500-Watt mono amplifier you probably picture a large, heat sink clad hunk of steel that weighs more than the car you drove it home in and probably costs more too. What if I told you... Click for more...
OmniMount VideoBasics TV Mounts Reviewed -
You've spent the extra money to buy an ultra-thin HDTV. The last thing you want to do is hinder the minimalist look by mating the TV with a bulky wall-mount. OmniMount designed the VideoBasics line of flat-panel TV mounts with... Click for more...





Comment on this article
0Post a Comment