The wireless headphone market is a diverse landscape of varying prices, quality, and features. Edifier, known for its desktop audio products on Amazon, has recently unveiled the Stax S5, a successor to the well-received S3 model. With a $100 price increase, does the S5 justify its higher cost? Let's delve into a comprehensive comparison and review of these two models.
The Stax S5 enters the market at a crucial juncture, where wireless technology is rapidly advancing and consumer expectations are at an all-time high. With a sleek design, a host of new features, and promises of superior sound quality, Edifier aims to capture the attention of those willing to invest in premium audio experiences. But in a field crowded with options from established giants and innovative newcomers, can the S5 carve out its own niche? This review will delve deep into the specifications, sound quality, and user experience of both the S3 and S5 models, offering a comprehensive comparison to help you decide if the latest from Edifier is the right choice for your listening needs.
Design and Build Quality: Both the S3 and S5 share a similar design philosophy, prioritizing comfort and functionality. The S5, like its predecessor, offers a well-balanced fit and weight distribution. However, a recurring criticism persists: the predominant use of plastic in construction detracts from the premium feel one might expect at this price point. While the S5 maintains the comfort of the S3, it misses an opportunity to elevate the tactile experience with more premium materials.
Technical Specifications and Features
S3 Specs:
S5 Specs:
The S5 builds upon the S3's foundation with several notable improvements. The introduction of Snapdragon Sound technology and support for additional high-resolution codecs like aptX Lossless and LDAC signifies a clear step up in wireless audio capabilities. The S5 also boasts an extended low-end frequency response, reaching down to 10Hz compared to the S3's 20Hz limit.
Both models offer impressive 80-hour battery life, setting them apart in the market where 40-70 hours is more common. The S5 retains the dual connectivity feature of the S3, allowing seamless switching between two devices.
Sound Quality: The S5 continues Edifier's commitment to high-fidelity audio. The planar magnetic drivers in both models deliver precise and detailed sound reproduction. However, the S5's upgraded driver technology, including the 2μm thin film and 2nd generation EqualMass™ wiring, pushes the boundaries further, approaching the performance of electrostatic headphones.
In listening tests, the S5 demonstrates a noticeable improvement over the S3. The sound signature remains balanced, with a slight emphasis on clarity and detail over bass impact. This neutral approach caters well to audiophiles seeking accurate reproduction across various genres.
The S5's extended frequency response is particularly noticeable in the low end, offering a more nuanced bass presentation compared to the S3. However, those seeking a bass-heavy profile might find both models slightly restrained in this regard.
Additional Features: The S5 introduces several new features absent in the S3, significantly enhancing its overall package:
Value Proposition: At a $100 premium over the S3, the S5 presents a multifaceted value proposition that warrants careful consideration:
However, the value equation isn't straightforward:
Ultimately, the S5's value proposition is strong for tech-savvy audiophiles and those who appreciate the latest features. For others, the S3 remains a compelling option that balances performance and cost effectively. The decision between the two will largely depend on individual priorities and budget considerations.
Conclusion: The Edifier Stax S5 successfully builds upon the strengths of the S3, offering tangible improvements in audio technology and features. While the aesthetic design might not scream luxury, the sound quality delivers on the promise of high-end audio. For those willing to invest in superior wireless audio, the S5 presents a refined listening experience that justifies its price tag. However, the S3 remains a viable option for those seeking excellent sound quality at a slightly lower price point.
The S5 solidifies Edifier's position in the premium wireless headphone market, proving that sometimes, it's what's inside that counts most. Whether the upgrade is worth it will depend on individual priorities, but both the S3 and S5 stand as testaments to Edifier's commitment to audio excellence.
