Epson Home Cinema 5030UBe LCD Projector Reviewed

By |

Page 1 Page 2

Home-Cinema-5030UBe_1.jpgPerformance
The first step in my review process is to measure the display's various picture modes to see which one comes closest to reference standards (see�"How We Measure and Evaluate HDTVs"��for more information). Usually, when measuring a display device's picture modes right out of the box, I can rely on either the Cinema/Movie mode or THX mode (if there is one) to be the closest to reference standards. That wasn't the case here, with the Natural mode actually having the closest-to-accurate white balance and color points. The grayscale Delta Error in this mode was just 5.08, the average gamma was 2.18, and all six color points had a Delta Error well below three. This mode would make a good choice for the user who does not plan to have the projector calibrated and generally watches content in a dim, rather than completely dark, room. The THX mode came in a close second with a grayscale Delta Error of 6.0 and a darker average gamma of 2.39, closer to the ISF-recommended 2.4 standard for a completely dark theater room. For that reason, I opted to use the THX mode as my starting point for calibration. The pre-calibration color temperature was a bit too warm, or red. Using the RGB offset and gain controls, I was able to dial in a more neutral color temperature with better color balance across the spectrum from dark to light. I left the gamma setting as is and ended up with a grayscale Delta Error of just 2.67 and gamma of 2.39. The THX mode's color points also measured under the DE3 target out of the box, but by a slightly higher margin than the Natural mode. Using the advanced color management system, I was able to slightly improve the accuracy of several color points. However, it's worth noting that the primary colors of red, green, and blue were all a bit under-saturated in both the THX and Natural picture modes, and I could not correct this using the CMS. Red, green, and blue were spot-on in color brightness (luminance), which is important, but they simply fell a little short in saturation. The resulting image certainly wasn't lacking in color saturation for HDTV and Blu-ray sources, but still these modes didn't offer the precise adjustability and correction I have seen elsewhere. (The 5030UBe's Cinema picture mode has a wider color gamut, with points outside the Rec 709 triangle; so, even though this mode is less accurate to begin with, it might be the better starting point for calibration, provided the CMS can dial back the colors correctly.)

Once the calibration process was complete, I moved into my real-world demos. Much like its predecessor, the Home Cinema 5030UBe's performance receives high marks for its versatility - combining high light output with a good auto iris that allows you to use the projector in a variety of lighting conditions. Indeed, this guy can crank out a lot of light in its brighter picture modes. In the Dynamic picture mode, I measured 64 ft-L with a full white test pattern on my 1.1-gain, 100-inch screen. I could watch HDTV shows during the day even with the window blinds open at the back end of the room. Mind you, the Dynamic mode is quite inaccurate out of the box, with a very strong green emphasis at brighter signal levels. The Living Room mode measured about 41 ft-L and produces an out-of-the-box picture that looks more natural and measures a bit closer to reference standards. Of course, both modes offer the full complement of advanced calibration controls to dial in a more accurate picture, but you will likely lose a bit of real and perceived image brightness through the calibration process.

There are a lot of budget projectors out there that boast high light output. What you pay for when you step up to the 5030UBe is the ability to also get a good black level for better contrast with movies in a dark room. With the auto iris engaged, the 5030UBe served up a respectably deep black level with film sources while still maintaining solid light output to produce a well-saturated image. The Natural, Cinema, and THX modes all had similar light output, around 13.5 to 16.5 ft-L before calibration in the lowest (and quietest) lamp mode. The Natural mode was the brightest of the three, and the THX mode was the dimmest. After calibration, the THX mode measured about 13.1 ft-L, which is a little dimmer than the ISF minimum recommendation of 14 ft-L. You can improve light output a bit by moving to the brighter lamp mode (or starting with a brighter picture mode and calibrating it), but that adds fan noise, too. I found the calibrated THX image to offer just the right amount of brightness for my screen - enough to keep HDTV and Blu-ray sources looking rich and dimensional, but not too bright to hurt my eyes during abrupt transitions from dark to light.

Since I still had my review sample of the 5020UB, I was able to do some head-to-head comparisons of the calibrated projectors, using their THX modes. Epson claims that the new iris produces better blacks at the same rated light output, for better overall contrast. Unfortunately, my X-rite I1Pro 2 meter is not precise enough to measure small black-level differences, so I had to rely on what I could see. With my favorite black-level demos from The Bourne Supremacy (Universal) and Flags of Our Fathers (Paramount), the new 5030UBe did produce a slightly deeper shade of black, but it was not a significant difference. Both of the projectors did an equally good job rendering the finest black details in these scenes. More obvious (and something I could measure) was that the older 5020UBe review sample was a little bit brighter - it measured about 5 ft-L brighter in the THX mode, and I actually thought the 5020 did a better job of preserving light output in the scenes' brighter elements. The faces of Matt Damon and Franka Potente in chapter one of The Bourne Supremacy were a little dark and flat through the 5030 but still had nice brightness through the 5020, which gave a sense of better overall contrast. These were pretty subtle differences, though. All in all, performance between the two models was quite close.

On the processing side, the 5030UBe passed all of the basic film and video tests on the HQV Benchmark and Spears & Munsil test discs, although it didn't correctly handle the more complex cadences. It cleanly rendered my 480i demo scenes from Gladiator (DreamWorks) and The Bourne Identity (Universal), with no major instances of moir� or jaggies. Without employing frame interpolation, the 5030UBe showed the typical loss of motion resolution in my FPD Benchmark resolution pattern, blurring lines down to DVD480. The Frame Interpolation modes improved motion resolution up to about HD720 (the HD1080 lines were still blurry) and did a good job with the various motion-detail test clips. All three FI modes produce that smoother effect with film sources, but Epson continues to refine the choices. To my eyes, this year's Low mode seemed to be more subtle in its smoothing effect than in years past, to the point I would actually consider leaving it on to get the improved motion resolution. I also appreciate the fact that the 5030UBe serves up a very clean image without a lot of digital noise, even with the noise reduction control turned off.

Finally, the 5030UBe did a very good job with 3D sources. Its high light output and 480Hz Drive technology help compensate for the lose of image brightness caused by the active-shutter glasses, and I saw no crosstalk in my favorite crosstalk demo (the floating objects in chapter 13 of Monsters vs. Aliens/20th Century Fox) or in the other demos I watched from Life of Pi (20th Century Fox) and Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (Buena Vista). I did feel like 3D color saturation was just a hair less than I've seen elsewhere.

The Downside
Home-Cinema-5030UBe_2.jpgMy quibbles with the 5030UBe are primarily ergonomic in nature. First off, the 3LCD panel does need a bit of alignment to properly balance red, green, and blue. Out of the box, you can see some red and green lines around objects, indicating the need to use the Panel Alignment tool in the setup menu - which is both easy to use and effective. I should note that the panel alignment on my 5030UBe review sample was much improved over the 5020UB, requiring less work to fix and producing better results.

At the brighter lamp setting, the 5030UBe's fan noise is not excessive but is certainly noticeable, whereas the lower lamp mode is pleasantly quiet. The fan noise averaged about 7 to 8 dB louder in the brighter mode, using a basic dB meter on my iPhone for comparison. The 3D picture modes are locked to the brighter lamp mode, so you have to accept the presence of the fan noise with 3D content. I'm happy to report that, even though I live at an elevation of about 5,000 feet, I did not need to use the 5030UBe's High Altitude mode, which adds even more fan noise.

The WirelessHD feature in the 5030UBe is certainly convenient in the setup process, and performance-wise I saw no meaningful degradation in the signal quality. However, the projector is very slow to switch between resolutions in WirelessHD mode. If your Blu-ray player or DVR is set to deliver each source or channel's native resolution, be prepared to look at a black screen for up to 10 seconds when you switch from, say, a 720p channel to a 1080i channel or, in my case, the Oppo's 1080p menu to a 480i DVD. The solution is to let a different AV component handle all the signal conversion and feed only one resolution to the projector. Also, WirelessHD requires line-of-sight, so you can lose the signal by simply walking between the path of the transmitter and receiver. Be mindful of this as you plan your installation.

Competition and Comparison
The Home Cinema 5030UBe's $2,599-$2,899 price tag positions it above the crowded budget category but below mid-level 1080p models like�Sony's VPL-HW55ES�($3,999),�JVC's DLA-X35($3,499), and�Optoma's HD8300�($3,300). Other projectors right around the same price point include the�Panasonic PT-AE8000U�and the�Sony VPL-HW30ES. BenQ recently introduced a wireless DLP projector that uses 5GHz WHDI technology between the transmitter and receiver; the�W1500 projector�has an MSRP of $2,299.

Not at all surprising at this price point is the fact that the Home Cinema 5030UBe is not 4K-compatible, so it's not the right choice for the projector shopper who is thinking about making the move to 4K in the near future. The cheapest true 4K projector available right now is Sony's VPL-VW600ES at $15,000. JVC's new e-Shift projectors are not true 4K projectors; they manipulate the 1080p chips to reproduce a 4K resolution, but they at least accept a true 4K signal through their HDMI inputs and thus can serve as a bridge for the shopper to wants to ease into 4K at a lower price point - although the cheapest model is still $5,000.

Conclusion
Once again, Epson has delivered a very good performer for a very good price. The Home Cinema 5030UBe may not quite match up in black-level performance and precision with pricier LCoS models for the dedicated home theater room, but its great light output, good black level, and flexible setup features make it a wonderfully versatile projector for the shopper who wants to enjoy good performance in a variety of lighting conditions. Unless you really hate the idea of running an HDMI cable or simply can't do so in your situation, I recommend you save $300 and get the non-wireless 5030UBe version for $2,599. For the even more value-conscious shopper, you might want to look for a deal on the last year's 5020UB. In my opinion, the performance differences are not significant enough to mandate that you invest in the newer model. Whichever route you choose, I think you'll be more than satisfied with the results.

Check out our gallery of 7 Hot Projectors Below . . .

Additional Resources

Page 1 Page 2

HTR Product Rating for Epson Home Cinema 5030UBe LCD Projector

Criteria Rating

Performance

4

Value

4

Overall

4

Disagree with our product rating? Email us and tell us why you think this product should receive a higher rating.


Latest Front Projector Reviews

Jan 29
JVC DLA-NX9 8K D-ILA Projector Reviewed At CEDIA this past fall, JVC announced (and has subsequently released) a new firmware update for its current generation 4K...
JVC DLA-NX9 8K D-ILA Projector Reviewed

Dec 09
Home Theater Review's Best of 2019 Awards As 2019 comes to a close, we at HomeTheaterReview.com look back at all the products we reviewed this year and pick the best of the bunch, from affordable favorites to flagship products that make us drool.
Home Theater Review's Best of 2019 Awards

Nov 25
BenQ HT3550 Projector Reviewed Earlier this year, BenQ released the HT3550 projector as a replacement for last year's HT2550. Those familiar with BenQ's product...
BenQ HT3550 Projector Reviewed

Oct 21
Epson Home Cinema 5050UB Projector Reviewed Epson's UB line of home theater projectors have traditionally bridged the gap between budget and high-end. The Home Cinema...
Epson Home Cinema 5050UB Projector Reviewed

Apr 22
Sony VPL-VW695ES Projector Reviewed Back in the early 2000s, when commercial cinemas began switching from film to digital, Sony saw an opportunity to take...
Sony VPL-VW695ES Projector Reviewed