Red Rose Music Rosette 1 Integrated Amp Reviewed

By |


RedRoseMusic-Rosette-Reviewed.gifIf the McIntosh MA6900 shows just how butch an integrated amp can be, then the Red Rose Rosette 1 shows how cute one can be. This adorable little jewel measures a mere 4.5x8.2x10.6in (WHD) and it just begs to be sited next to your computer monitor, on a bookcase in your office, or on the nightstand next to your bed. But those uses, while intelligent and practical, would underestimate its worth just because of its external dimensions. It is an amplifier which calls to mind all of those audiophiles who, upon hearing an LS3/5A for the first time, couldn't believe their ears.

Its size is symbolic because the Rosette 1 isn't just the (physically) smallest amplifier Red Rose boss Mark Levinson has made, it's also the least expensive. Here we have, for the first time ever, a product approaching entry level pricing from the man who single-handedly created stratospheric price tags. And although he probably doesn't approve of the use of the 'C' word, yes - it did make me think of Cello.

Additional Resources
• Read audiophile power amp reviews from the likes of Krell, Mark Levinson, Audio Research, Linn, Naim, VAC, VTL, NuForce, Pass Labs and many others here.
• Read about tubes on the Audiophile blog, AudiophileReview.com.
• Want to read audiophile stereo preamp reviews? We have dozens from brands like ARC, Krell, Classe and many more.
• In the market for audiophile loudspeakers? Here are over 100 reviews from brands like Wilson Audio, THIEL, MartinLogan, Bowers & Wilkins, PSB, Vandersten, Magnepan and many more.

Beautifully fashioned from what look like aluminium extrusions for the sides, the Rosette 1 is shaped in the currently popular 'vertical' mode, as used by EAR for the M100A, by Holcro, and by Mark's erstwhile, eponymous company for its top models. Only here we're talking about 1/4th scale dimensions. (Its layout reminded me of an aged Sony integrated from the 1970s, with matching tuner famed for its round dial - the TA-88, I think.) So nicely made is the Rosette 1 that you can't help twiddling the machined volume control, pressing the buttons with their smooth action. But that's about all you'll do, because this amp is the most minimalist product yet in our survey of high-end integrateds.

Not only is it the smallest and least expensive, it's also the only one so far without remote control, and it bears no controls beyond on/off, volume and source select. The amplifier accepts four line level sources, while the set of phonos at the back also includes an output for tape. And there's not much more beyond the single pair of multi-way binding posts. Even the mains lead is captive to prevent you from experimenting with AC cables. To save on LEDs, power-on indication is shared with the source in use, lighting up in blue over indications marked S1 through S4.

A 50W/ch amp 'that is heavily biased towards Class A', it emulates big Class A amps in that it takes some time to run in, while day to day use also requires a long warm-up period of about 6 hours from stone cold. Although there's a few seconds of silence from switch-on, the mute preventing thumps, there is no stand-by mode - unforgivable in an amp which so clearly needs to be warmed up to sound of its best. It does not, by the way, run hot, thanks to the sides being chimney-like heat sinks. The Musical Design Company's Dave Wiley told me, 'I keep it powered up at all times and select an unused input as a mute.'

He also mentioned that the unit is particular about cables, so I started with the most expensive I could muster, working my way down. I found it ludicrous to use wires which cost as much as the amplifier itself, but he was right, and budget cables clouded the sound. Thus I stuck with 1.5in thick Kimber Select, cables so heavy that they tugged at the Rosette 1's mere 13lb weight!

Forcing myself not to relate its size to the ancillaries, I fed the Rosette 1 with the Audio Research CD3 and Musical Fidelity 3D CD players, and used it to drive LS3/5As, Wharfedale Diamond 8.1s, Quad ESLs and Wilson WATT Puppy System 6. To my delight-cum-horror, the little bugger drove the System 6 so loud and so easily that I couldn't crank it past the 12 o'clock mark in my 12x18ft room. Red Rose may have rated this as a 50-watter, but their watts must come from Texas.

But size matters did keep creeping in, because the Rosette sounds like a big amp only in its volume capabilities and bass extension. The soundstage it produces is neither wide nor deep, merely acceptable. Let's be perfectly clear about this: you certainly know you're listening to stereo discs, but the image stayed within the borders created by the outer edges of the speakers - consistently from LS3/5A to System 6 - and stage depth was nearly myopic. Within those confines, though, were superb image placement and a great sense of space around each performer. You would, however, need to look elsewhere if you like your musical arena cavernous. Groups of gospel singers were bunched together, the Glory soundtrack lost a touch of its majesty, Gladiator left the Colosseum for a bingo hall in Scunthorpe.

That, however, is the full extent of my whining, because the Rosette's behaviour in other areas was valve-like for the handling of vocals, true to its silicon base for treble speed and overall attack, and positively fluid from top to bottom, with no shocking transitions from the midband in either direction. But every amp has its party trick, and the Rosette's is more than its size: there is a genuine ace up this amplifier's sleeve. (Note to pedants: an ace up the sleeve is a trick, therefore, the metaphor's aren't mixed.)

As is well-known, Mark Levinson is a very serious, esoteric bass player of note. It stands to reason, then, that the sound of bass instruments are as important to him when he tunes his products as the sound of a clarinet is to Antony Michaelson. It's only because I knew this about Levinson beforehand that I wasn't blown out of my chair when the Rosette delivered low-end energy, extension and control more akin to that of the Krell KAV300iL or the McIntosh MA6900.

Read more on Page 2


HTR Product Rating for Red Rose Music Rosette 1 Integrated Amp

Criteria Rating

Performance

4

Value

3.5

Overall

4

Disagree with our product rating? Email us and tell us why you think this product should receive a higher rating.


Latest Amplifier Reviews

Jun 22
NAD M10 BluOS Enabled Integrated Amplifier Reviewed NAD's new M10 BluOS Enabled Integrated Amplifier ($2,749) is a very exciting product. And I don't just mean for NAD,...
NAD M10 BluOS Enabled Integrated Amplifier Reviewed

May 11
Schiit Hel High-Power Gaming/Music/Communications DAC/Amp Reviewed Schiit's step-up Hel gaming headphone amp and DAC delivers not only performance upgrades, but also some nice ergonomic touches that make it a wonderful desktop audio solution for headsets, headphones, and powered monitors alike.
Schiit Hel High-Power Gaming/Music/Communications DAC/Amp Reviewed

Apr 22
Schiit Fulla 3 Gaming DAC/Amp Reviewed As I write this, it's been about three weeks since my wife finally got approval to work from home during...
Schiit Fulla 3 Gaming DAC/Amp Reviewed

Apr 20
Naim NAIT 5si Integrated Amplifier Reviewed The Naim NAIT 5si lacks all of the digital connectivity you would expect in a modern integrated amplifier, but it's a big winner in terms of value and personality.
Naim NAIT 5si Integrated Amplifier Reviewed

Apr 15
Anthem MDX-8 Distribution Amp Reviewed Jerry calls the Anthem MDX-8 amp one of the most forward-thinking products he's seen and heard in ages.
Anthem MDX-8 Distribution Amp Reviewed

RedRoseMusic-Rosette-Reviewed.gifMaybe it's there to please Mark. Maybe it's there to compensate for the unit's size, to create a sense of perceived value. If I'm honest about it, the sheer weight of the sound created by the Rosette goes a long way toward compensating for the small soundstage dimensions. With Kodo drumming, some Rob Wasserman self-indulgence, with Sly Stone and Funkadelic and Motown - didn't matter what the source discs, the Rosette 1 loves bass. Which leads me to Barry White.

Love him or hate him, the Walrus of Love uses the lower octaves the way a masseuse uses oil. Hook up the Rosette 1 to a speaker good for at least sub-60Hz output. Put on 'Just The Way You Are'. Note how the song, rather than making you gag, acts like a quarter tab of Viagra. Rich, seductive, yes, even chocolate-y. Maybe Levinson should include a copy of his new book with every amp.

With at least three more amps to go before I take a break from costly integrateds, it's too early to say what the final tally will be. But the Rosette 1 certainly won't be beaten on compactness, probably not on price and definitely not on charm. It is a Kylie Minogue amongst Xenas. And if I hadn't just committed to a Theta Intrepid and a Philips 36in TV, I'd be buying one, if just to have as an executive toy. Not that I'm an executive. But, damn, does it look cool next to a computer monitor.

Musical Design Company, PO Box 4146, Epping, Essex CM16 6HJ
Tel 01992 573030 Fax 01992 574030
www.mdc-hifi.co.uk

A LETTER FROM THE MAN

No stranger to controversy - especially now that he's become a sex guru - Mark Levinson has courted it yet again by using an existing amplifier as the basis for the Red Rose Rosette 1. Because I heard the accusation that 'Red Rose is selling a $200 amp for $2000!' from a couple of sources (including an on-line chat group), it was deemed necessary to investigate. Unfortunately, the closest we could get to acquiring the base unit was the Korsun homepage on-line (see www.korsun.com.cn), and my inability to read Chinese meant that we were unable to get hold of one for side-by-side comparison. The base unit is sold as the Korsun (2 [micro 2].

Thus, it was our decision simply to review the Red Rose Rosette 1 in the context in which it exists, as a 2000 integrated amplifier to be judged against products of that price point. At the same time, we could not simply ignore the charge levelled against Red Rose, so we decided to contact Mark Levinson directly for a statement which would - at the very least - provide his rebuttal to the accusations.

On a personal level, I don't have a problem with the Red Rose Rosette 1 per se because it acquits itself so admirably. If, on the other hand, it turns out that a Korsun (2 is the same amp for a tenth of the price - then buy one! No, buy two!!! KK

Mark Levinson writes:
"The Red Rose Rosette 1 looks similar to a unit made for the PRC [Chinese] market by the company which manufacturers the Rosette for us. This is because I opted to use existing tooling which I found attractive and distinctive, and which also saved time and money. There is a huge sonic difference between the RRM [Red Rose] unit and the low cost PRC amplifier due to engineering refinements which include more sophisticated topology, power supply design and components, the use of active regulated power supplies, parts selection, and other design differences.

"In addition to the sonic differences, one can see that completely different PCB's exist in the RRM unit which carry different circuits and parts. All RRM units include technology developed in Seattle by the Red Rose team headed by Victor Tiscareno, SVP Engineering RRM. I

"Our technology is not to be found in any non-RRM units. Some people are suggesting that RRM is simply selling the same product as the PRC unit, for a lot more money. The rumour seems to have been started by a former employee of mine who saw an opportunity to create controversy and attack RRM based on nothing more than speculation. Anyone can see and hear the difference between the Rosette 1 and the PRC units. One is designed to be a good low cost amp while the Rosette 1 competes with high end products in the $2k-10k range.

"Some dealers in China are telling people that their amps are the same as RRM's. This is not true. There are huge differences in sonic quality, reliability, and stability. Customers beware.

"Mark Levinson"


Additional Resources
• Read audiophile power amp reviews from the likes of Krell, Mark Levinson, Audio Research, Linn, Naim, VAC, VTL, NuForce, Pass Labs and many others here.
• Read about tubes on the Audiophile blog, AudiophileReview.com.
• Want to read audiophile stereo preamp reviews? We have dozens from brands like ARC, Krell, Classe and many more.
• In the market for audiophile loudspeakers? Here are over 100 reviews from brands like Wilson Audio, THIEL, MartinLogan, Bowers & Wilkins, PSB, Vandersten, Magnepan and many more.

  • Comment on this article

Post a Comment
comments powered by Disqus