Toshiba 42HP84 Plasma HDTV Reviewed

By |


Thin is in and it looks to stay that way for the foreseeable future. Although bulkier tube televisions and big-box RPTVs can still generate some of the best pictures available, LCD and plasma flat panel displays continue to dominate the television market. Whether it's above the fireplace in your friend's living room or above the bar at your local watering hole, flat panels are everywhere you look.

Additional Resources
• Read more plasma HDTV reviews by
• Explore Blu-ray player options in our Blu-ray Player Review section.

Although some recent advances have improved black levels and shadow detail on LCD TVs, plasma continues to be the popular favorite. The 42-inch 42HP84 HDTV monitor from Toshiba, a company long associated with quality displays, is sure to turn a few heads and is certainly worthy of your attention.

Plasma displays have some inherent strengths and weaknesses, and it's critical that you be aware of these before you start shopping. Getting the bad news out of the way first, remember that most plasmas do not handle low-grade, standard definition content very well. This means that analog cable signals and VHS recordings tend to look rather poor. This issue can be minimized by pairing your display with a quality scaler/line doubler, such as DVDO's iScan HD (see review on page 76).

Also remember that plasmas are subject to image "burn-in", whereby an image or line can become permanently engrained in the display due to prolonged viewing of a stationary image. A good example of this is the stock ticker running along the bottom of CNBC, or the "pillarbox" bars that flank 4:3 content on your 16:9 screen. Whenever possible, fill your entire screen with the picture/zoom mode that is least offensive to you. In case you don't believe in burn-in, I should point out that Toshiba has placed a large, bold-text box on NINE different pages of the 42HP84 owner's manual warning owners about this plasma phenomenon. The box is also kind enough to remind you that "This type of damage is NOT covered by your warranty." Consider yourself warned.

The good news is that plasma displays are capable of tremendous picture quality, especially with HDTV and DVD sources. Also, plasmas tend to be capable of very high brightness and they perform exceptionally well in rooms with high amounts of ambient light. Anyone with a CRT-based RPTV will tell you that one uncovered window or glass door can completely wash out your picture during daylight hours. This is not the case with plasma. Finally, as with LCD panels, plasmas are extremely easy to mount on the wall and they instantly add a splash of style to any room. Toshiba's 42HP84 is no exception.

Unique Features
Proving that it's ready to be connected to the latest and greatest source devices, Toshiba's 42HP84 features a High Definition Multimedia Interface (HDMI) input. HDMI provides a 100% digital signal path for both video and multi-channel digital audio over a single cable. Many new DVD players and set-top boxes feature HDMI (or DVI, which is identical to HDMI but for video only). If you can take advantage of this connection, HDMI will give you the best possible picture on the 42HP84.

To risk sounding greedy for a moment, I'd really like to see two HDMI inputs on future Toshiba plasmas, and on all quality displays for that matter. Most new DVD players and set-top boxes now feature HDMI output and most households have both devices. In my case, my Onkyo DV-SP1000 reference DVD player has a 1080i-capable HDMI output. But, my VOOM satellite receiver also has a digital output (DVI) which I'd like to use to watch my HDTV (with a DVI/HDMI adapter.) So which do I choose? In the end, I gave the HDMI input to my VOOM box since that's outputting native HDTV. I relegated the DVD to component video, but it'd be nice if I didn't have to make that compromise. With analog connections becoming a thing of the past, I'd be happy to forfeit both of the 42HP84's rear-panel composite/S-Video inputs in exchange for a second HDMI input.

For viewers who like to multi-task, the 42HP84 has a unique Picture-out-Picture (POP) feature which allows you to watch two windows side by side in the display. This handy feature extends to the set's various inputs, so you can watch a DVD in your POP window while surfing your cable channels in the main window. Several buttons on the remote handle this feature, including one which lets you swap the window content, and another to toggle which window's audio is output.

Speaking of audio, the built-in speakers on the 42HP84 are definitely unique. Many plasma displays forego speakers entirely, expecting the consumer to use a 5.1 speaker system. That's fine, and that will certainly sound better than any set's built-in speakers. But some installations (such as a bedroom) require nothing more than a decent set of built-ins. The column speakers on the 42HP84 are beautifully integrated into the panel's design, and while they do make the unit considerably wider, they're an artful and useful addition.

An extra bonus is the presence of WOW• Surround and Virtual Dolby Surround for creating enhanced 3D sound with only two speakers. During my evaluation period, I detected some cabinet resonance during a bass-heavy Sheryl Crow song playing over a scene from Jersey Girl. This was only detectable when the WOW• TruBass setting was engaged (the default setting). Toshiba was unable to duplicate this problem at their facility so it may have only been an isolated issue specific to my review sample.

Read more about the Toshiba 42HP84 on Page 2.

HTR Product Rating for Toshiba 42HP84 Plasma HDTV

Criteria Rating







Disagree with our product rating? Email us and tell us why you think this product should receive a higher rating.


Jul 22
Hunter Douglas Throws Shade at Blinds of the Past Hunter Douglas's new premium shade automation solution promises increased reliability, decreased noise, and new shade customization options.
Hunter Douglas Throws Shade at Blinds of the Past

Jul 21
Luxman's New Flagship will Baby Your SACDs and CDs Luxman's new D-10X features a revolutionary new Delta-Sigma digital-to-analog converter from ROHM Semiconductor.
Luxman's New Flagship will Baby Your SACDs and CDs

Jul 20
BenQ TH685 Console Gaming Projector Reviewed There are a bunch of junk projectors under $1,000 with minimal light output and atrocious color. But with enough brightness for high-ambient light conditions and pretty good color accuracy, the BenQ TH685 is not one of those projectors.
BenQ TH685 Console Gaming Projector Reviewed

Jul 20
Will Apple's AirPods Pro Start a 3D Audio Revolution? AirPods Pro and other spatial audio listening devices promise to change the way we listen to music. But how do they work?
Will Apple's AirPods Pro Start a 3D Audio Revolution?

Jul 17
Astell&Kern's New Audio Player has Two Different DACs Astell&Kern's new SE200 lets users choose between two different DACs for a custom listening experience.
Astell&Kern's New Audio Player has Two Different DACs
Toshiba_42HP84_Plasma_HDTV.gif Installation/Setup/Ease of Use
Although the 42HP84 was yearning to hang above my fireplace, I reviewed it using the included tabletop stand. The stand is an extremely well-made, heavy-duty support and makes for a great alternative if wall mounting is not an option. Connection to my VOOM satellite receiver was made with a BetterCables HDMI cable and an Ultralink HDMI/DVI adapter. I connected my Onkyo DVD player with Monster THX component video cables and I also connected a run-of-the-mill coaxial cable to check out basic cable. On-screen menus were intuitive and the unit's backlit remote gave me little to complain about. OK, maybe one complaint. I wish Toshiba would change their Mode selection button; I shouldn't have to tap a button five times to switch from controlling my DVD player to controlling my VCR. Nitpicks aside, the 42HP84 was a snap to get up and running.

Final Take
Perhaps I did it to prolong my anticipation of getting to the good stuff, but whatever the reason, I started my video evaluation by looking at basic, analog cable. I didn't expect much in the way of picture quality, and that's about what I got. There's no getting around the fact that plasma does not do well with low-resolution, standard definition content. Old reruns of Seinfeld looked grainy and pixilated and often times unwatchable if I sat too close. Newer stuff such as a recent episode of Joey fared slightly better, but the same problems persisted. One issue that did arise during this test that is not a result of poor source material is a barely perceptible flicker in the light gray pillarbox bars on either side of the 4:3 image. This problem was news to Toshiba and they were unable to duplicate it on their end. It was hard to pick up sometimes, more pronounced other times. It seemed to coincide with a lot of movement near the borders of the 4:3 image. In the grand scheme of things, it was very minor and I don't recommend using the 4:3 mode anyway, if you can help it.

Moving on to DVD and HDTV, it was as if a different television spontaneously appeared. While watching DVD episodes of The West Wing's third season, I marveled at the lush images the 42HP84 was able to conjure. The red, white and blue flags adorning the White House looked perfectly natural and colors on the whole looked accurate. After some picture setting adjustments, blacks were relatively black and grayscale tracked well. Switching over to my VOOM box connected via HDMI, I was overwhelmed that this was the same display I was watching cable on only hours ago. At a distance of 2x the width of the display, my VOOM HD programming looked better than I thought it could. Using the receiver's 1080i setting, I immediately lost myself in the pictures and found myself otherwise detained on a kayaking tour of China.

The 42HP84, like many other plasmas, is not made for yesterday. It was not designed with cable and VHS in mind. The 42HP84 is a television of tomorrow, built to shine when DVD or HDTV is giving the orders. If you're looking for a high quality plasma panel capable of truly stunning images, give this Toshiba a look and I promise you'll like what you see.

Toshiba 42HP84 Plasma
42" 720p HDTV Monitor
1024 x 768 panel resolution
(1) HDMI input
(2) HD component video inputs
(2) S-Video inputs
(3) A/V composite inputs
Built-in speakers w/SRS ® WOW
Virtual Dolby Surround
50 5/32"W x 30 5/32"H x 12 19/32"D
Weight: 113 lbs.
MSRP: $5,499

Additional Resources
• Read more plasma HDTV reviews by
• Explore Blu-ray player options in our Blu-ray Player Review section.

  • Comment on this article

Post a Comment
comments powered by Disqus